Concept
Other Form Objections
Form of questions
Other Form Objections
Leading is only one of several complaints a party can make about how a question is put. Rule 611(c) addresses it expressly: leading questions should not be used on direct examination except as necessary to develop the witness’s testimony, and the court should ordinarily allow them on cross-examination.1 A question can fail in other ways. On direct or redirect it may call for a narrative or characterize testimony. On direct or cross it may be compound, repetitive, or unintelligible, or it may ask the witness to speculate. On cross-examination or recross it may also argue with the witness, assume facts that are not in evidence or are in dispute, or misquote the witness’s earlier testimony.2 Together these defects are called trial objections, because they attack the form of the question, or the responsiveness of the answer, and not the content of the answer itself.3
The difference in target shapes the remedy. An objection to content asks whether the jury may hear the information at all. A form objection asks only whether this question, put this way, is a fair way to get it, so a sustained objection ordinarily sends the examiner back to ask again.
The argumentative, assumption, and vagueness objections discussed below are not expressly codified in the Federal Rules or the Revised Uniform Rules (1974), but the trial judge may enforce them in discretion under Rules 403 and 611(a).4 Rule 611(a) directs the court to exercise reasonable control over the mode and order of examining witnesses so as to make the procedures effective for determining the truth, avoid wasting time, and protect witnesses from harassment or undue embarrassment.5 Because that discretion is broad, rulings are often informal. The court may say, “Counsel, lay additional foundation,” “Counsel, rephrase the question,” or simply “Counsel, move along.”6
An objection to “the form of the question” may suffice to raise most of these problems, but a specific objection makes the judge more likely to sustain it.7 A named defect shows the court what to cure and lets the examiner fix it in one move. The three objections that follow address different faults. The argumentative question presses the witness to accept the examiner’s inference. The question that assumes facts not in evidence slips a disputed premise past the witness. The vague or compound question leaves the witness unable to answer cleanly. The first of these is the argumentative question.
Argumentative Questions
An examiner may not ask a question that merely pressures the witness to assent to the examiner’s inferences from, or interpretations of, testimony already admitted.8 Such a question seeks no new substantive information. It challenges or argues with the witness about what the existing record means. Asked with evident disbelief, “Do you really expect the jury to believe that?” and “How can you reconcile those statements?” are the standard examples, and each draws the objection that the question is “argumentative” or that counsel is “badgering the witness.”9
The second label ties the objection to Rule 611(a)(3), which directs the court to protect witnesses from harassment or undue embarrassment.10 No rule names the objection, however, and the judge enforces it in discretion under Rules 403 and 611(a).11
The objection also protects the line between evidence and argument. Witnesses supply evidence through their answers, and the lawyers argue the inferences to the jury in summation. A question that asks for no fact and demands only agreement with the examiner’s conclusion brings argument into the evidence stage, because a cross-examiner who becomes argumentative is in effect previewing her summation.12 The witness has nothing to add. The answer the examiner wants is a concession, and any other answer is a quarrel.
The objection can arise on direct when a party calls an adverse party or a hostile witness, but lawyers lodge it far more often on cross-examination.13 Cross invites it for a reason. The court should ordinarily allow leading questions there, and the witness is commonly assumed to be more or less uncooperative, so the examiner can make assertions on the record and force the witness to assent.14 An examiner who has built the record fact by fact may then press for the conclusion those facts support. Sustaining the objection costs her little, since she will have ample opportunity to argue the inference in summation.15 The trial judge has a wide range of discretion in enforcing the rule, and it is certainly fair for judges to enforce it on cross, where such questions are more common.16
The hard part on an exam is separating an argumentative question from a pointed leading question, and the two differ in what the examiner is after. A leading question puts a fact to the witness. An argumentative question demands that the witness concede an inference.
The three questions share a witness, a confrontational tone, and a leading form. They differ in what an answer could contribute. The witness can confirm or correct a fact in either direction, but the third question allows only agreement with the prosecutor’s conclusion or a protest against it. A pointed question that seeks a fact remains a proper leading question on cross, and the witness’s discomfort or resentment does not make it argumentative.
Because the objection targets form, a sustained objection ordinarily produces an instruction to rephrase or to move along.17 The examiner can then ask for the facts one at a time and save the inference for closing. A stem that shows a sharp question on cross therefore calls for a sorting step before any ruling: does the question seek information, or does it ask the witness to concede what the examiner wants the jury to infer? Calling the question leading does not answer that, because leading on cross is ordinarily allowed.18
Assuming Facts Not in Evidence
Leading questions are ordinarily allowed on cross-examination, and that permission makes this form problem possible.20 Under the guise of asking questions, a cross-examiner can make factual assertions on the record and force the witness to assent, so that she virtually testifies for the witness.21 The usual check is the witness’s presumed unfriendliness, which makes it unlikely that the witness will acquiesce in the examiner’s suggestions.22 That check can fail. Counsel may word a question so that it assumes as true a matter that no witness has yet testified to and that the parties dispute, and opposing counsel then usually objects that the question “is misleading” or “assumes facts not in evidence.”23 The judge enforces the objection in discretion under Rules 403 and 611(a).24
The objection answers two separate dangers. The first is familiar from the leading-question material earlier in this chapter. When the examiner puts such a question to a friendly witness, reciting the assumed fact inside the question may itself be leading, because it suggests the desired answer.25 The second danger exists whether the witness is friendly or hostile, because the answer can mislead. The witness deserves a fair opportunity to affirm or deny the assumed fact, and an inattentive witness may answer without identifying the assumption. The factfinder may then be unable to tell whether the witness affirmed the fact or simply ignored it.26
The objection reaches only assumptions that are both unproven and disputed.27 An assumption already in the record leaves nothing for the witness to ignore, and an assumption no one contests leaves nothing for the answer to distort. That limit keeps the objection from swallowing ordinary cross-examination, which routinely builds each question on the answers before it.
A second requirement attaches to the examiner’s own assertions. Counsel who states a fact inside a question on cross-examination needs a good faith, reasonable basis in fact for believing it true.28 Counsel may not ask a witness, Bob, “Isn’t it true that Piagano’s is located on Birch?” without a reasonable basis for believing that Piagano’s is on Birch and not on Apple. Counsel likewise may not ask Bob whether his wife was related to the plaintiff without a good faith basis for the suggestion.29 Since the cross-examiner can virtually testify for the witness,30 the requirement ties that power to facts counsel has reason to believe.
The requirement applies only when the cross-examiner is effectively asserting, in the form of a question, the truth of a factual statement included within it. If she is merely inquiring whether something is or is not true, no good faith basis is required.31 The glasses pair shows where the line falls. “Your glasses were being repaired at the time of the accident, weren’t they?” requires a good faith basis, while “Were you wearing your glasses at the time of the accident?” does not.32 The first question supplies the fact that the glasses were in the shop and invites the witness to agree, so counsel needs something in hand that makes the repair believable. The second leaves the fact to the witness, and counsel has stated nothing for the jury to take as true. The same principle governs the foundation for impeachment by prior inconsistent statement, where the examiner must also have the intent and ability to introduce extrinsic evidence of the statement, on a non-collateral matter, if the witness does not admit making it.33
A question that asserts a disputed, unproven fact without support commits both faults at once. The assumption exposes the witness and the record to confusion, and the unsupported assertion exposes the jury to a fact that may not exist. On an exam, the form of the question decides which objection to name. Because leading is ordinarily allowed on cross, a leading objection to a question that merely recites what the witness already said will fail. The objection that succeeds names the defect: the question assumes a disputed fact that is not in evidence, so the answer will not show whether the assumption was admitted. The ordinary remedy is a rephrased question that separates the premise from the follow-up, which gives the witness the fair opportunity to affirm or deny that the rule protects.34 Where the facts show counsel asserting something with no stated source, the issue is the good faith basis, which applies to assertions and not to genuine inquiries.
Vague and Compound Questions
Questions are sometimes objectionable because they are too broad or indefinite, and the objection can arise on direct or on cross.36 In some cases it is really a relevancy objection under another label.37 The compound question belongs to the same family, because it too leaves the witness, the opponent, and the jury unsure what exactly is being asked.38 Like the other form objections in this section, none is codified by name, and the judge enforces them in discretion under Rules 403 and 611(a).39 Indefinite cross-examination questions about a witness’s personal background are the most dangerous, so they come first.
An indefinite background question hands the choice of content to the witness. A cross-examiner who asks whether a witness has had any “troubles,” “contacts,” “brushes,” “encounters,” “problems,” “difficulties,” or “run-ins with the law” has named no particular event, so the witness decides what the words cover.40 The witness may mention a conviction admissible for impeachment, but the witness may as easily mention other misconduct that is both prejudicial and inadmissible, and the answer could violate the restrictions on credibility or character evidence.41 A precise question announces its content, so the opponent can object before any answer and the judge can rule while the jury has heard nothing. A vague question keeps its content inside the witness’s head, and the opponent learns what to object to only when the answer is out.
The second prosecutor’s question is leading, and that is no defect. The court should ordinarily allow leading questions on cross-examination,42 and narrowly phrased leading questions are the cross-examiner’s tool for confining the witness to the facts she chose.43 The vague background question gives up exactly that control. A student who meets a sharp question on cross and reaches for a leading objection has chosen the wrong ground. The objection that fits the first prosecutor’s question is that it is indefinite, and the reason is its breadth, which has nothing to do with suggestion.
Legalistic words add a second source of ambiguity, because the meaning of a legal term may differ from the popular meaning of the same expression.44 The ordinary witness answers in everyday vocabulary, while the examiner may be asking in the vocabulary of the courthouse.
Compound and repetitive questions need only short treatment, because both appear among the trial objections that target the form of a question.45 A compound question bundles several questions into one, so a single yes or no cannot show which part the witness is affirming, which is the same unclear-record problem the vague question creates. The eyewitness hypothetical that opened this discussion of form objections shows the standard form, and the cure is to ask each matter separately. A repetitive question returns to what the witness has already answered, which wastes time, and Rule 611(a) directs the court to avoid wasted time and to protect witnesses from harassment.46 A cross-examiner who rephrases a question to get past an evasive answer is pursuing information, while one who repeats a question only because she disliked the answer is not.
The cure for each defect is a better question. The court’s usual response is to tell counsel to rephrase or to lay more foundation,47 and the examiner satisfies it by naming one event, using ordinary words, and asking about one matter at a time.