Concept
Hostile and Adverse Witnesses
Form of questions
Hostile and Adverse Witnesses
Direct examination ordinarily proceeds by nonleading questions.1 Rule 611(c) codifies that default: leading questions should not be used on direct examination except as necessary to develop the witness's testimony, but the rule then lists situations in which the court should ordinarily allow them.2 One of those situations is the witness who will not cooperate. The court should ordinarily allow leading when a party calls a hostile witness, an adverse party, or a witness identified with an adverse party.3
The reason is practical. When a witness refuses to cooperate, the trial lawyer needs a little coercive power to get at what the witness knows, and leading questions let the lawyer press and may be the only way to obtain real answers.4 Adverse parties and their agents or associates are likely to fall in the same category, as are others the rule calls hostile.5
The three labels do not call for the same proof. A witness is hostile in fact when conduct on the stand shows unwillingness, so the judge must watch what the witness does. The adverse party and the witness identified with one are different. Counsel may treat the opponent as hostile from the outset, and the rule makes the same assumption for close associates of a party, so the judge need ask only where the witness stands in relation to the lawsuit.6 The analysis follows that order: first ask whether the witness is tied to the opponent, and only if not, ask whether the witness's own conduct has shown hostility.
One lookalike falls outside all three labels. Some witnesses answer poorly because they cannot easily comprehend or articulate their answers, not because they resist: children, the infirm, and the excessively timid. The court has discretion to allow leading for them, as the earlier discussion of children and communication difficulties explains, but the ground is inability rather than hostility.7
Witnesses Hostile in Fact
Hostile witnesses are those who make clear, for whatever reason, that they are unwilling to answer counsel's direct questions.8 The test is conduct. A witness who shows by demeanor or testimony that he or she is reticent, deceptive, hesitant, evasive, or uncooperative may be led.9 Because the label follows what the witness does, it can attach to anyone, including a stranger to the lawsuit. The words for whatever reason relieve the examiner of explaining why the witness resists. The examiner need show only that the witness does.
Hurting the calling party is not the same as resisting the calling party. The mere giving of damaging answers, in the absence of recalcitrance, does not permit counsel to lead.10 Parties call witnesses whose testimony turns out worse than expected, and if disappointment alone licensed leading, the exception would swallow the rule that direct examination proceeds by nonleading questions.11 Measuring hostility by manner keeps the exception tied to the behavior that defeats open questioning.
The calling lawyer should not simply begin leading a stranger to the lawsuit, because nothing about the witness's status makes hostility the default. Counsel should ordinarily ask the court's permission before examining by leading questions and explain the basis for the claim of hostility.12 The same request fits a witness who turns hostile partway through. A witness called without thorough preparation, perhaps because of schedule conflicts or an aversion to meeting with counsel, may take offense at the questions and appear hostile to the examiner, and the examiner again should ask the court for permission to lead.13
Once the court has declared the witness hostile to the calling party, it can tell the jury so when the witness is called. That advice can ameliorate, if not remove, the difficulties that accompany a witness's association with the party who called.14
Adverse Parties
An adverse party is the opponent in the lawsuit, such as the defendant whom a plaintiff summons to the stand, and Rule 611(c)(2) names the opponent separately because the opponent's hostility does not have to be shown.16 When a party calls the opponent to the stand, a hostile exchange is likely to follow. The general rule therefore lets the sponsoring lawyer treat the opponent as a hostile witness from the outset and conduct the examination by leading questions.17
For the adverse party, status settles the question. The lawyer need not ask open questions first, wait for an evasion, or build a record of hostility, as counsel must with a stranger whose hostility has to be shown.18 Requiring a showing would only delay an answer that the opponent's place in the lawsuit has already supplied.
The privilege covers the form of the questions and nothing more, because a calling party has no right to put the opponent on the stand at a moment of its own choosing. In one appeal, a plaintiff claimed an unfettered right to call the defendants during his case-in-chief. The court of appeals rejected the claim. Rule 611(a) places the mode and order of questioning in the trial court's discretion, and courtroom-management decisions are not disturbed unless they amount to an abuse of discretion that prejudices the appellant's case.19 The ruling cost the plaintiff little. The defendants promised to testify in their own case-in-chief, the court said he would have ample opportunity to cross-examine them then and would face no limits on the scope of that cross, and he made no further proffers and cross-examined the defendants vigorously as they presented their evidence.20 Leading is ordinarily allowed on cross-examination in any event.21
A stem in which a plaintiff calls the defendant therefore presents two questions that should be answered separately. On form, leading is ordinarily allowed from the first question, so an objection that the examiner has not shown hostility fails. On order, whether the plaintiff may call the defendant during the plaintiff's own case, and when and how that examination proceeds, lies with the judge under Rule 611(a). A student who answers the second question with the Rule 611(c)(2) presumption has confused a privilege about phrasing with a right about timing.
The privilege runs in one direction only. After the calling party finishes, the opponent's own lawyer questions the same witness, and that lawyer is the friendly questioner. The Advisory Committee explained that the word ordinarily lets the court deny leading when the cross-examination is cross-examination in form only, as when a party is questioned by his own counsel after being called by the opponent, an examination savoring more of redirect.22 The later section on friendly witnesses on cross-examination develops that limit.
Witnesses Identified With Adverse Parties
Rule 611(c)(2) reaches past the parties themselves to “a witness identified with an adverse party.”24 The phrase covers people whose ties to the opponent place them on the opponent's side of the lawsuit: co-conspirators and the party's relatives, friends, and co-workers,25 the party's agents and associates,26 and other close associates, as to whom the rule makes the same assumption of hostility that it makes for the adverse party.27 Like the opposing party, such a witness may be led without a showing of hostility in fact.
The category exists because the earlier federal practice drew its line too tightly. Civil Rule 43(b) had included only “an adverse party or an officer, director, or managing agent of a public or private corporation or of a partnership or association which is an adverse party.”28 The Advisory Committee called that limit, which confined the category virtually to persons whose statements would stand as admissions, an unduly narrow concept of those who may safely be regarded as hostile without further demonstration, and it chose the phrase “witness identified with” to enlarge the category of persons thus callable.29
The two tests ask different questions. An admissions test asks whether the witness's words may be charged to the party, which turns on the witness's authority to speak for the party. The leading-question rule asks whether the witness is aligned with the opponent, and alignment does not depend on authority. A relative or co-worker with no managerial role may stand as firmly on the opponent's side as an officer does.
A personal tie qualifies as readily as a business tie. A prosecutor's leading of the defendant's girlfriend, a witness identified with an adverse party, is the example the commentary offers from United States v. Hicks.30
A wrong ruling on this question does not guarantee a new trial. In one federal appeal the district court did not allow plaintiffs to lead two witnesses, Officer Calandra and Sergeant Holub, on direct examination. A decision of that kind will not be reversed absent a clear showing of prejudice to the complaining party, and the court of appeals found none. Plaintiffs had examined both witnesses at length without leading, neither witness was evasive or antagonistic, and defendants called Sergeant Holub as their own witness, which let plaintiffs lead him on cross-examination.31 Most important, plaintiffs never said what additional testimony leading would have drawn out, so any harm from the ruling was purely speculative.32
The lesson for an appellant is concrete: identify the testimony the ruling cost. The lesson for an exam answer has two parts, whether the trial judge ruled correctly and whether the ruling prejudiced the appellant. The later section on enforcement and appellate review returns to the second part.
A stem in which a party leads the opponent's employee, sibling, or girlfriend over an objection that no hostility has been shown is testing this clause, and the objection fails, because the clause looks to the witness's relationship to the opponent rather than to the witness's manner. The opposite trap is a bystander with no tie to either side who gives damaging testimony politely. That witness cannot be led merely because the testimony hurts.