Concept
When State Law Governs
State law governing the effect of a presumption (Rule 302)
When State Law Governs
Rule 302 sends the effect of a presumption to state law, but only in a civil case and only for a claim or defense for which state law supplies the rule of decision.1 The rule is a conditional. State law takes over when every condition is met, and the conditions can come out differently on the same facts. A federal courtroom holds many presumptions, and Rule 302 reaches only some of them, so the task here is to mark its boundary.
The rule's words pose three questions, and this section takes them in order:
- Is the case civil?
- Does state law supply the rule of decision for the claim or defense on which the presumption bears?
- Is the presumed fact an element of that claim or defense, or a point of lesser weight?
Each question draws on a different source. The nature of the proceeding answers the first, the law that creates the claim or defense answers the second, and the substance of the presumed fact answers the third. Keeping them apart matters, because a presumption can satisfy two conditions and fail the third, and a student who runs them together loses track of which one decided the case.
A negative answer ends the inquiry but does not erase the presumption. In a civil case that fails the second or third question, the court applies the federal default of Rule 301: the party against whom the presumption is directed must produce evidence to rebut it, and the burden of persuasion stays where it began, unless a federal statute or the rules provide otherwise.2 A federal statutory claim, for example, fails the second question because federal law supplies its rule of decision. In a criminal case neither rule applies at all, a point the next subsection develops. Because the civil-case requirement is the broadest cut, it comes first.
Civil Cases Only
Rule 302 opens with three words that set its first limit: "In a civil case."3 Rule 301 opens the same way, so together the two rules speak to presumptions in civil proceedings and to nothing else.4 A student who meets a presumption in a federal courtroom should therefore ask what kind of case it is before asking anything about state law.
The Federal Rules make no provision for presumptions in criminal cases.5 Two reasons explain the silence. When the Rules were adopted, criminal presumptions were being considered in connection with a revision of the federal criminal code, which was never enacted. More important, there was concern about the constitutionality of presumptions in criminal cases.6 That second reason shows why the civil rules could not simply be stretched to cover them. Rule 302 settles a civil question by deferring to the state that created the claim. Whether a presumption may operate against an accused is a constitutional question, and a rule that merely chose between a federal and a state effect would not answer it. The Supreme Court has addressed the issue as a matter of constitutional law, and that doctrine is studied apart from Rules 301 and 302.7
The second scene shows only that the first gate has been passed. A civil case is necessary for Rule 302 but not sufficient, since the presumption must still regard a claim or defense for which state law supplies the rule of decision. A federal civil case on a federal statutory claim is civil and still falls under Rule 301 rather than Rule 302. The civil-case condition screens out the criminal case entirely, and the next condition screens civil cases by the source of their law.
State Rule of Decision
The phrase "for which state law supplies the rule of decision" is the trigger that decides whether state law takes over at all.9 The rule of decision for a claim or defense is the body of law that defines it, meaning the source of the elements a plaintiff must establish and the defenses a defendant may raise. A negligence claim created by state law has a state rule of decision, and a claim created by a federal statute has a federal one. The question is which of those describes the claim or defense on which the presumption bears. The same question fixes the burdens, because where state law supplies the rule of decision, the burdens of production and persuasion on an element of the claim or defense are determined by state law.10
The trigger follows the source of law because Rule 302 prefers identical results in state and federal court where a presumption can decide a state-created claim.11 A state that attaches a presumption to an element of its own cause of action has decided who bears the risk of unresolved doubt on that element, and a federal court that substituted its own treatment would alter the right the state created. Where federal law supplies the rule of decision, no state judgment is at stake, so Rule 301 governs unless Congress has specifically given the presumption another effect.12
State-law claims reach federal court by more than one route, and the route does not change the answer. Diversity is the usual setting, and a state-law claim heard under supplemental jurisdiction beside a federal claim stands in the same position, because in each the state supplies the substantive law of the claim. The inquiry runs issue by issue, so the jurisdictional label on the case is only a starting point. Rule 501 on privilege works the same way. It depends on the rule of decision for a particular issue in a particular case and cannot be resolved mechanically from the basis of jurisdiction, since state law is sometimes consulted in federal-question cases and federal law sometimes controls an issue in a diversity case.13
Four diversity decisions show the trigger being met. In Foradori v. Harris, a plaintiff who claimed more than $1.5 million in past medical expenses testified that his injuries caused the charges and offered his bills. A Mississippi statute made the bills prima facie evidence and raised a presumption that they were necessary and reasonable, and the defendant objected under the federal hearsay and authentication rules. The Fifth Circuit rejected the objection. The incurrence of the expenses was a fact that is an element of the plaintiff's claim, Mississippi law supplied the rule of decision for that claim, and Rule 302 therefore made Mississippi law, not federal law, determine the effect of the presumption.14 The court reasoned in two steps: it located the element the presumption concerned, and it then asked which law supplied the rule of decision for that element.
Rudisill v. Ford Motor Co. shows the question being asked one issue at a time inside a single lawsuit. An employee's intentional-tort claim turned on an Ohio statute that presumes intent to injure when an employer deliberately removes an equipment safety guard. The Sixth Circuit stated that Ohio law governed the effect of the presumption, citing Rule 302, and added that federal law governed the separate procedural question whether summary judgment was appropriate.15 One case thus drew on two sources: state law for what the presumption did on the intent element, and federal law for the standard that tests whether a trial is needed.
Burton v. R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co. and Tafoya v. Sears, Roebuck & Co. show that the rule is neutral about who benefits, since both involved state product statutes that favored the seller. In Burton, a Kansas statute deems a product not defective by reason of its warnings when it complies with regulatory standards on warnings, unless the claimant proves that a reasonably prudent seller could and would have taken additional precautions, and the Tenth Circuit stated that state law determines the effect of any presumptions in a diversity action.16 In Tafoya, a Colorado statute created a presumption favoring a tractor-mower first sold ten or more years before the injury, and the Tenth Circuit said the trial court correctly looked to Colorado law, including the Colorado Jury Instructions, citing Rule 302.17 The presumptions in Foradori and Rudisill helped a plaintiff, and those in Burton and Tafoya helped a defendant. The text of Rule 302, which speaks of a "claim or defense," explains why the result is the same either way.
When federal law supplies the rule of decision, the analysis runs the other way. In a federal bankruptcy appeal, a creditor's claim had been expunged on the strength of the presumption that a mailed notice of a hearing was received, and a witness testified that the notice never arrived. The reviewing court explained that receipt was an element of a claim or defense governed by federal bankruptcy law, not state law, so federal law determined the presumption's effect, and it reversed because the bankruptcy court had relied on the presumption instead of weighing all the evidence on receipt.18 A federal rule of decision does not always produce Rule 301's treatment, however, because Rule 301 yields when a federal statute provides otherwise. In Plough, Inc. v. Mason & Dixon Lines, the Sixth Circuit held that Rule 301 left untouched the Carmack Amendment's allocation, under which a shipper who shows delivery in good condition, arrival in damaged condition, and the amount of damages makes a prima facie case and the burden of persuasion then rests on the carrier.19
An exam fact pattern that places a presumption in a federal courtroom is therefore asking what law creates the claim or defense on which the presumption bears. The words "diversity" or "federal court" in the stem do not answer that question alone. The answer chooses between Rule 302 and Rule 301 before any question about the presumption's effect arises, and that effect is the subject of a later section.
Elements of Claims or Defenses
The third question concerns the presumed fact itself. Rule 302 does not send every presumption in a civil case to state law, because it speaks only of a presumption "regarding a claim or defense for which state law supplies the rule of decision."21 The rule defers to state law only as to presumed facts that constitute an element of a claim or defense. Presumptions of lesser impact remain under the Thayer approach of Rule 301, even in a diversity case where state law governs the claim.22 The words "claim or defense" therefore filter presumptions by what the presumed fact is, in addition to the source of law that creates the claim.
An element is a fact that the substantive law makes consequential to the decision: offer, acceptance, and consideration in a contract dispute, or duty, breach, causation, and damage in a negligence action. The law allocates the elements between the parties, so that a plaintiff recovers by establishing certain selected elements that make up a claim for relief unless the defendant establishes another element, called an affirmative defense.23 A presumed fact is thus an element when the substantive law makes it something one side must prove to win or to avoid losing. That definition explains why the rule says "claim or defense" and reaches a presumption that helps either party.
The reason for the filter lies in what Erie protects. A presumption attached to an element can decide who wins. If a federal court gave such a presumption an effect of its own, the same claim on the same proof could come out differently in federal and state court, and the state's judgment about who bears the risk of doubt on its own element would be lost. A presumption on a lesser aspect of the case, called a tactical presumption, stands differently, because its effect on the outcome is no greater than that of a rule admitting or excluding a single item of evidence.24 Federal courts already apply their own rules to such evidentiary rulings. A fixed federal rule for tactical presumptions therefore gives federal trials a uniform procedure, and that benefit outweighs the small gain in matching the state court's result.
The decisions that apply Rule 302 each involve a presumed fact the substantive law makes decisive. Foradori turned on exactly this point. The defendant's objection came dressed as an evidence-rule problem, but the answer depended on what the presumed fact was. The plaintiff's incurrence of more than $1.5 million in past medical expenses was a fact that is an element of his claim, for which Mississippi law supplied the rule of decision, so the label on the objection could not move the presumption out of Rule 302.25
Rudisill reaches the same result for a different element. The element on which the employee's claim turned was the employer's intent to injure, and the Sixth Circuit looked to Ohio law for the effect of the presumption on it while treating the summary judgment question as one for federal law.26 The rule's deference does not guarantee a burden shift. It guarantees only that the state's treatment applies, whatever that treatment is, once the presumed fact is an element.
A third example comes with a caution about its setting. In Melville v. American Home Assurance Co., the court supported its conclusion that state substantive law, under Erie, rather than federal procedural law supplies the rule by observing that the presumption against suicide respects a fact which supplies an element of a claim or defense, which is Rule 302's own description.27 The case illustrates the element analysis but does not apply the rule directly. Whether a death was a suicide or an accident can decide a claim or a defense, and the presumption exists to resolve that question when the facts leave it in doubt. In all three decisions the presumed fact is one the substantive law makes consequential to the result, and none is a step toward admitting an exhibit.
What does a tactical presumption look like on an exam? The facts below show one, set beside a state presumption that does reach an element.
The tactical category rests on the rule's wording and the logic just described. One commentator observes that no reported case had specifically drawn the distinction the rule contemplates, though the reasoning is sound.28 The line also rarely decides a case in practice, since the state presumptions that produce litigation tend to attach to facts the substantive law makes decisive. The safe habit is to name the element the presumption serves before applying Rule 302.