Concept
The Federal Default Rule
State law governing the effect of a presumption (Rule 302)
State Law and Presumptions
The Federal Default Rule
When federal law supplies the rule of decision in a civil case, a presumption does one modest thing: it requires the party against whom it is directed to come forward with evidence to rebut it.1 Rule 301 states that default. It applies in civil actions where federal law provides the rule of decision, except for statutory presumptions to which Congress has given some other effect.2 Rule 302 reassigns the question to state law whenever state law supplies the rule of decision, and it is best understood against this baseline.3
A presumption connects a basic fact to a presumed fact. In the standard illustration, the basic fact is that a letter was properly mailed, and the presumed fact is that the addressee received it. Under the Rules, proof of the basic fact shifts to the opponent the burden of going forward with evidence to rebut or meet the presumption.4
The whole subject turns on the difference between two burdens. A party with the burden of production who offers no evidence on the issue loses to a directed verdict. A party with the burden of persuasion loses if the jury finds the evidence evenly balanced, because the jury is instructed to decide against the party who bore that burden.5 Rule 301 moves only the first burden. The burden of persuasion stays with the party who had it originally.6 In doing so, the rule adopts the Thayer bursting-bubble theory instead of the Morgan shifting-burden theory that the Advisory Committee had recommended.7
The bubble bursts as soon as the opponent introduces evidence sufficient to support a finding contrary to the presumed fact. At that point the presumption is rebutted and has no further function at trial, and the judge, not the jury, decides whether the threshold has been met under Rule 104(a).8 Absent a federal statute saying otherwise, the presumption never touches the burden of persuasion.
A rebutted presumption leaves the courtroom, but the jury is not necessarily left without guidance. Under Rule 301 a jury should not be instructed in terms of a presumption. Where the interests of justice demand it, however, the court may instruct the jury on the existence of the natural inference.9
The default yields in two ways. Congress may enact a particular statutory presumption and specify its effect, for instance by providing that it persists until rebutted by clear and convincing evidence or that it shifts the burden of persuasion. Federal courts have also occasionally upheld certain presumptions with early statutory or common-law origins that have consistently been construed as shifting the burden of persuasion.10
Rule 301 also has a boundary of its own. It governs where federal law supplies the rule of decision. Where state law supplies the rule of decision for a fact that is an element of a claim or defense, the effect of a presumption about that fact is determined by state law.11 A presumption can therefore do more in a federal courtroom than Rule 301 would allow, if the governing state law gives it more.
The two scenes show why Rule 301 is only a default: the source of the rule of decision determines how a presumption works. Rule 302 makes that allocation for state-law claims and defenses, and the sections that follow take up its reach, its rationale, and the conditions that trigger it.