Concept
The Rule 301 Command
Effect of civil presumptions (Rule 301)
The Rule 301 Command
Rule 301 gives a presumption one job: it forces the opposing party to answer with evidence. The rule provides that “the party against whom a presumption is directed has the burden of producing evidence to rebut the presumption,” and it adds that the rule “does not shift the burden of persuasion, which remains on the party who had it originally.”1 Two phrases at the edges limit that command: the rule applies “in a civil case,” and it gives way when “a federal statute or these rules provide otherwise.”2 The paragraphs below take each part in turn, beginning with the first limit.
The rule speaks only to civil cases. The Federal Rules make no provision for presumptions in criminal cases, largely because of a pending revision of the federal criminal code and, more importantly, concern about the constitutionality of such presumptions.3 A presumption in a criminal prosecution therefore raises a constitutional question that Rule 301 does not answer, and the later section on where the rule yields returns to it.
The party against whom a presumption is directed is the party who must respond to it. A presumption helps whoever needs the presumed fact, so it is directed against the opponent of that fact, the party who would lose the point if the presumed fact were treated as established. In the mailed-letter example, the sender needs to prove receipt and proves proper mailing, so the addressee is the party against whom the presumption is directed.4 The lawsuit's caption does not decide the matter, because a defendant can be the one who needs the presumed fact.
The phrase “producing evidence to rebut the presumption” describes a burden of production and nothing larger.5 The opponent must put something into the record, but need not convince anyone. Silence is costly, as the retiree learned: if the proponent offers evidence adequate to support a finding of the basic fact and the opponent offers nothing on the presumed fact, the proponent is entitled to a directed verdict on that fact.6
Rule 301 does not say in terms how much evidence rebuts a presumption. Most courts and commentators nonetheless read it as adopting Thayer's measure in full: the opponent's evidence must be sufficient to permit a reasonable trier of fact to find that the presumed fact does not exist.7 Once such evidence comes in, the presumption is rebutted and has no further function at trial, and the court, not the jury, decides under Rule 104(a) whether the evidence suffices.8 The judge asks only whether the evidence could support the contrary finding, so the presumption drops out whether or not the jury would believe that evidence.9 A judge who weighed credibility at this stage would be doing the jury's work, which is why the test is sufficiency and not believability.
The rule's second sentence keeps the presumption from doing more. The burden of persuasion stays where it began, with the party who bore it before the presumption arose.10 Courts place that burden originally for reasons such as caution and convenience, which often charge the party seeking change, and policy, which may encourage or discourage a kind of litigation.11 When the evidence on an issue is evenly balanced, the party who bears the burden of persuasion loses. A presumption can therefore win its proponent the point when the opponent stays silent, yet a tie on the evidence still falls on the party who always had to prove the fact.
The rule's two sentences work as a pair. The first gives the presumption its force, because the opponent must answer it or lose the point. The second caps that force, because answering the presumption does not make the opponent the party who must win the issue. A presumption compels a response, but it never reverses who bears the risk of an evidentiary tie. Because a rebutted presumption simply vanishes, Thayer's approach, which Rule 301 adopts, is called the bursting bubble theory.12 The next section sets that theory beside the competing Morgan theory, and a later section follows the bubble through each state of the evidence.
The opening qualifier, “unless a federal statute or these rules provide otherwise,” makes Rule 301 a default and not an absolute.13 Congress may enact a presumption and specify its effect, for example by requiring rebuttal with clear and convincing evidence or by shifting the burden of persuasion.14 Rule 302 separately sends the effect of a presumption to state law when state law supplies the rule of decision for the claim or defense.15 Both exceptions get their own treatment in the section on where Rule 301 yields, but any presumption problem should first prompt the question whether one of them is in play.
Rule 301 governs the effect of a presumption, and the presumption itself must come from somewhere else. The Rules neither define nor enumerate presumptions; they state only a presumption's function and probative effect.16 A party cannot invoke Rule 301 to create a presumption from nothing, so a defendant's superior access to the evidence, standing alone, does not produce one. The recognized presumption must come from case law, a statute, or another rule.