Concept
Presumptions Defined
Effect of civil presumptions (Rule 301)
Civil Presumptions Under Rule 301
Presumptions Defined
Rule 301 tells a court what a presumption does at trial, yet it never says what a presumption is. In a civil case, unless a federal statute or another rule provides otherwise, the party against whom a presumption is directed must produce evidence to rebut it, and the burden of persuasion stays with the party who had it originally.1 Applying that command requires the vocabulary it assumes. A presumption is a procedural device that ties two facts together: when the proponent establishes the basic fact, the existence of the presumed fact is taken as established unless and until a specified condition is fulfilled.2 In practice the opponent must produce evidence to rebut the presumed fact. If the opponent does not, then, depending on the nature of the presumed fact, either a verdict is directed on the issue or the jury is instructed to find the presumed fact.3 The terms basic fact and presumed fact run through the rest of this chapter, because every later question about burdens and jury instructions asks what happens to the link between those two facts.
Basic Fact and Presumed Fact
The properly mailed letter is the standard illustration. The basic fact is that the letter was correctly addressed and mailed, and the presumed fact is that the addressee received it.4 If the sender's evidence of mailing is adequate to support a finding that the letter was mailed, then unless the addressee presents evidence of not having received it, the judge instructs the jury to find receipt.5 Two considerations explain why proof of mailing carries so much weight. Common experience says that properly mailed letters ordinarily arrive.6 And presumptions of this kind also reflect the fact that one side, here the addressee, has superior knowledge of the evidence or easier access to it.7
The presumption of death from long absence has the same two-fact structure. When a person has been absent for seven years without explanation or any communication with family or friends, and inquiries have been unavailing, the absentee is presumed deceased.8 Policies favoring the settlement of estates help explain the rule.9
Two features mark the true civil presumption, and both appear in these examples. The presumption is rebuttable, because the opponent may answer it with evidence tending to show that the presumed fact is false. And it operates only once the basic fact has been sufficiently established; a sender who cannot prove that the letter was addressed and mailed has nothing from which receipt can be presumed.10 Whether a presumption can do more than force the opponent to produce evidence is a separate dispute, taken up later in this chapter.
Permissive Inferences
A permissive inference is the weakest device in the family, and strictly speaking it is not a presumption at all. Call the basic fact A and the presumed fact B. The fact finder may, but need not, find B from evidence of A alone, without any evidence of B.11 Because the jury is never required to draw the inference, the opponent faces no obligation to respond to it.
Labels are an unreliable guide here, because what one jurisdiction calls a presumption another may classify as an inference.12 The sounder test asks what the law requires of the jury and of the opponent, whatever word the court happens to use.
Conclusive Presumptions
A conclusive, or irrebuttable, presumption cannot be rebutted with evidence tending to show that the presumed fact does not exist. It simply substitutes proof of the basic fact for proof of the presumed fact. If proof of a gun in the car mandates a finding that the car's occupant possessed the gun, evidence that the occupant never touched it is beside the point.13 Such a device is really a rule of substantive law and not a presumption at all.14
Arranged by strength, the three devices form a spectrum. A permissive inference lets the jury find B from A. A true presumption requires the opponent to produce evidence against B or else treats B as established.15 A conclusive presumption makes B follow from A whatever the evidence shows. A question that describes a device allowing no contrary evidence is therefore testing substantive law, and Rule 301 has nothing to regulate there.
Where Presumptions Come From
Rule 301 neither defines nor lists presumptions; it states only their function and probative effect.16 It also speaks only to civil cases, because the Federal Rules make no provision for presumptions in criminal cases.17 The presumptions themselves arise for different reasons. Many reflect common experience, such as the presumption that a person driving a car has the owner's authorization or that a properly mailed letter reaches its addressee. Others are established by statute to further social policy, such as the presumption that a child born to a married woman is the child of that woman and her husband.18
There are dozens of presumptions, so no short list is complete, but the standard examples all pair a basic fact with a presumed fact. A vehicle lawfully stopped and struck in the rear leads to a presumption that the second driver was negligent. Goods delivered to a bailee in good condition and returned damaged lead to a presumption that the bailee was negligent. A will that cannot be found leads to a presumption that the testator revoked it.19 This division of labor structures the analysis. A source outside Rule 301 supplies the presumption and its two linked facts, and Rule 301 then prescribes what the presumption does at trial. The next section asks why lawmakers create presumptions in the first place.