Concept
Jurors as Witnesses
Roles of judge and jury
Jurors as Witnesses
A juror may not testify as a witness before the other jurors at the trial, and if a juror is called to testify, the court must give a party an opportunity to object outside the jury's presence.1 Rule 606(a) is the jury-box counterpart to Rule 605, which keeps the presiding judge from testifying, and it rests on the same premise: a person may not serve as both witness and juror.2
The problem seldom arises. A prospective juror who discloses personal knowledge of the dispute would undoubtedly be excused during jury selection, so the chance that a juror will be called to testify in the very case he is sitting on is extremely small.3 The rule covers the leftover case, a seated juror who turns out to hold evidence. A juror cannot testify in a case he or she will be deciding.4
The rule works through an objection, and the objection is heard where the jury cannot hear it. When a juror is called, the opposing party must be given the chance to object out of the presence of the jury.5 The party can make that objection without the jury's knowledge.6
That requirement sets jurors apart from judges. The ban on the presiding judge's testimony needs no objection to preserve the issue.7 It can be enforced even if the prejudiced party never objects, and the only person to whom an objection could be addressed is the judge who is violating the rule by testifying.8 Rule 606(a) is different: it calls for an objection, though one made outside the jury's presence.9 A party who wants a called juror's testimony excluded must therefore object, and the self-enforcing character of Rule 605 does not carry over.
The rule's reach stops at testimony before the other jurors at the trial. The words before that jury make clear that it does not prevent the judge or counsel from questioning prospective jurors during selection, and that questioning is the process that screens out most jurors who hold relevant knowledge.10 Rule 606 reaches a second topic as well: what jurors may say after the verdict about how it was reached. That question belongs to Rule 606(b), which comes next. Jurors may not testify, and affidavits from jurors may not be accepted, about any juror's mental processes or statements or anything else concerning how the jury reached its conclusion. The exceptions are extraneous prejudicial information, outside influences, and mistakes on the verdict form.11