Concept
Judge and Jury Basics
Roles of judge and jury
Judge and Jury Roles
Judge and Jury Basics
A jury trial divides the work of deciding between judge and jury. Under Rule 104(a), the court must decide any preliminary question about whether a witness is qualified, whether a privilege exists, or whether evidence is admissible.1 Those questions ask how the rules of evidence apply, so they are legal ones. The jury then takes what the judge admits and decides the questions of fact, including which witnesses to believe.2
Neither the judge nor the jury chooses the evidence. Each litigant, not the judge, largely determines what evidence she presents: the parties gather and offer it, and the judge rules on admissibility when an opponent objects that an item violates an evidentiary rule. A party also shapes the record by objecting to what an opponent offers.3 This chapter assumes a jury trial throughout. The next three sections sharpen the division of labor between the two decision-makers.
Admissibility Versus Weight
Admissibility and weight are separate questions, asked at different times of different people. Admissibility asks whether the jury may consider an item at all, and the judge answers it before the jury relies on the item. Weight asks how much an admitted item deserves to be believed, and the jury answers that during deliberation. A ruling that admits evidence therefore means only that the trier may consider it along with all the other evidence. The jury remains free to decide that it proves little or nothing.4
A ruling to exclude works differently. Had the judge sustained the objection, the jury would never have heard the account, however persuasive it might have been, and no one could weigh it. Admission leaves the jury a choice; exclusion removes it. An argument that a witness is unreliable therefore goes to the jury as an argument about weight, and an argument that a rule of evidence bars the testimony goes to the judge.
Taking Issues From the Jury
The jury's fact-finding role has a limit. When no reasonable dispute remains about the pertinent facts, the judge may use an instruction, judgment as a matter of law, or a similar device to keep the jury from reaching a finding that contradicts overwhelming evidence. In a civil case the judge can take a single issue from the jury or the whole case.6
In a criminal case the power runs in one direction only. The judge may enter a judgment of acquittal in whole or in part, but the judge cannot prevent the jury from acquitting and cannot direct a verdict for the government, however strong its evidence. A directed guilty verdict would violate the accused's Sixth Amendment right to a jury trial.7 A civil plaintiff holding undisputed proof on every element can win judgment as a matter of law. A prosecutor holding equally overwhelming proof must still obtain a guilty verdict from the jury itself.
Standards and Mixed Questions
The slogan that law belongs to the judge and fact to the jury is only roughly accurate, but it describes the core allocation. For the federal courts, Sparf v. United States settled the point: the judge declares the law, and the jury applies it.9 Whether a defendant owed the plaintiff a duty of care in a negligence case is a legal question of this kind, so the judge answers it.
The complication lies in the application. Many cases present mixed questions of law and fact. Whether a defendant was negligent in particular circumstances involves applying a legal standard to facts the jury must decide, and the jury does both, finding the facts and measuring them against the standard of reasonable care.10 Whether a party breached a contract can turn on the meaning the parties attached to a particular term, and a jury may have to decide that meaning.11 A single negligence case thus sends two questions to two decision-makers: the judge decides what duty the law imposes, and the jury decides whether the defendant, on the facts the jury finds, met it.
Some issues are split inside a single case. In Markman v. Westview Instruments, Inc., the Supreme Court reaffirmed that whether a defendant has infringed a patent is a jury question under the Seventh Amendment. It held, however, that interpreting the meaning of the patent's claims is an issue of law for the judge.12 The allocation, then, is made issue by issue and not case by case.
One more complication drives the rest of this chapter. Some admissibility rulings turn on a disputed fact. Take a hearsay exception that depends on whether the declarant, say Peter, remained under a continuous state of excitement between a crash and his statement about it. The judge decides that factual question, even though it closely relates to the events being litigated: the crash, its cause, and the results.14 A judge who resolves such a fact appears to be doing the jury's work. The assignment is deliberate, because it would be impractical and unwise to give these preliminary facts to the jury. The typical juror is uninterested in the technicalities of the rules of evidence and their underlying policies, and the preliminary facts are often so closely linked to the disputed evidence that deciding them requires considering that evidence.15
Rule 104(b) covers a different situation. When the relevance of evidence depends on whether a fact exists, the proponent must introduce proof sufficient to support a finding that the fact does exist, and the court may admit the evidence on the condition that the proof be introduced later.16 The next sections sort out which fact questions go to the judge under Rule 104(a), which fall under Rule 104(b), and by what standard each is decided.