Concept
The Personal Knowledge Floor
Competency of witnesses
The Personal Knowledge Floor
Rule 601 makes every person presumptively competent to testify unless the rules provide otherwise, but two requirements survive that presumption: the witness must have personal knowledge of what the witness describes, and the witness must give an oath or affirmation.1 Rule 602 supplies the first. It allows a witness to testify to a matter only if evidence is sufficient to support a finding that the witness has personal knowledge of it.2 Personal knowledge has two parts. The witness must have had the capacity to observe, receive, and record impressions through any of the senses, and must now be able to recollect and narrate them; and the witness must actually have observed the matter.3 The oath follows in the next section. This section is about the shape of Rule 602, which screens testimony one matter at a time.
Most competency doctrines go to a person's capacity to testify at all. Rule 602 does not. It goes to the witness's capacity to testify to a particular matter and leaves the witness's fundamental competence to be a witness untouched.4 The expert-qualification doctrine, which governs inferences and opinions in matters requiring special knowledge or skill, works the same way.5 A witness who lacks knowledge of one fact can therefore still testify to every fact the witness did perceive.
Brennan's exclusion followed the topic. The ruling removed his version of the collision and left him able to describe the skid marks, because Rule 602 asks its question again for each matter the witness is asked to describe. Alvarez cleared the floor on her own account of where she stood and what she watched.
When the existence of knowledge is genuinely disputed, the judge does not decide the dispute alone. In the competency setting, a judge sitting with a jury ordinarily keeps a disputed foundational fact for herself. If an objection to a spouse's testimony turns on whether the party and the witness are validly married, for example, the judge follows Rule 104(a). The solitary exception is personal knowledge, which the judge handles under the conditional relevance procedure of Rule 104(b).6 Once a prima facie showing is made, the jury considers the supporting evidence together with whatever contrary evidence the opponent produces.7 Doubts raised on cross-examination, such as poor lighting or a missing pair of glasses, therefore go to the jury unless the record changes. If, after all the evidence is in, the jury could no longer reasonably find that the witness perceived the matter, the court instructs the jury to disregard the testimony.8
The timing of the objection shows how Rule 602 differs from the oath requirement. An objection under Rule 602 comes after the witness takes the oath and before the witness answers a question about a fact the witness may not know firsthand.9 Because the objection targets a particular fact, it cannot be framed until a question calls for one. Rule 603 operates on the person instead: before testifying, every witness must give an oath or affirmation to testify truthfully, in a form designed to impress that duty on the witness's conscience.10 The opponent cannot object before the oath is given, and an objection is usually appropriate only after the person refuses to take it.11 A witness who refuses to swear or affirm therefore cannot testify on any topic, while a witness who lacks knowledge of one topic is limited on that topic alone.