Concept
The Rule 601 Presumption
Competency of witnesses
The Rule 601 Presumption
The common-law lists of disqualified witnesses have no counterpart in the Federal Rules. Rule 601 replaces them with a single presumption: every person is competent to be a witness unless the rules provide otherwise.1 A prospective witness therefore starts out able to testify, and a party who wants the witness kept off the stand must point to a rule that disqualifies the witness.2 Complaints that the witness is unreliable, unstable, biased, or a liar do not meet that burden, because none of them is a ground the rules recognize.3
The word 'competence' has changed meaning, and the older sense can mislead a reader of old cases. In older opinions, proof was 'competent' if it should be allowed into evidence, so the word was a synonym for admissibility. Today the word describes witnesses: a witness is competent if he or she is allowed to testify. This chapter uses the modern sense.4
In a case governed by federal law, Rule 601 eliminates every ground of incompetency except those the Federal Rules specifically recognize. The grounds it does not recognize include age, religious belief, mental incapacity, color of skin, moral incapacity, conviction of a crime, marital relationship, and connection with the litigation as a party, attorney, or interested person.5 Courts long ago treated each of these as a reason to disqualify, and in most instances each now survives only as an avenue of impeachment. In the great majority of respects, the rule simply reflects the common law as it had already developed.6
The law of witnesses depends on keeping two questions apart. Competence asks whether a person may testify at all, and credibility asks how much of the testimony the jury should believe.7 Many of the old bases for disqualification are now grounds for attacking credibility. A criminal conviction or a financial interest in the outcome, for example, is often admissible to impeach the witness.8 Conviction of a serious crime was once a basis for incompetence, and it is now a basis for impeaching the witness's testimony.9
Impeachment reaches beyond status to the circumstances of the testimony itself. A cross-examiner may try to show that the witness could not see the event clearly, that his memory has dimmed, or that he was under the influence of an intoxicating substance when he observed it. Such an attack does not imply that the witness is lying. Its thrust is that, sincere or not, the witness is wrong or mistaken.10 Whether that is so is a question for the factfinder. A jury that hears the witness can discount what deserves discounting, while a judge who bars the witness leaves the jury nothing to weigh.11
The opening sentence of Rule 601 qualifies the presumption with the words 'unless these rules provide otherwise,' and a few rules do. Rule 602 requires personal knowledge,12 and Rule 603 requires every witness to give an oath or affirmation to testify truthfully, in a form designed to impress that duty on the witness's conscience.13 Other rules keep particular people off the stand. A juror may not testify as a witness before the other jurors at the trial,14 and the presiding judge faces a comparable limit, taken up with jurors later in this chapter. Each of these rules has its own section below, but the order of inquiry can be set out now.
Steps two and three are where mental impairment can still matter. Mental incapacity is not itself a ground of incompetency, but the testimony of a witness whose capacity has been seriously questioned may be excluded when no reasonable juror could possibly believe that the witness has personal knowledge, or that the witness understands the difference between the truth and a lie or fantasy and the duty to tell the truth.19 Short of that point, the impairment goes to weight. Suppose a defense witness suffers delusions, but his physician testifies that he remembers the events, understands the oath, and can describe what he saw. Neither the personal-knowledge rule nor the oath rule gives the objector a ground, and a court that bars him without even examining him has no rule on which to rest the exclusion. The standard for those cases is taught in detail later in this chapter.
Two limits on the presumption reach beyond the rules just listed, and each has its own section. The second sentence of Rule 601 makes state law govern a witness's competency in a civil case on a claim or defense for which state law supplies the rule of decision, so a state rule that disqualifies a witness can still bind a federal court.20 In a criminal case, the Constitution also protects the defendant's right to testify, a limit on exclusionary rules that Rock v. Arkansas illustrates and that is developed below.