Concept
The Default Rule of Delegability
Delegation of duties
The Default Rule of Delegability
An obligor may hand the performance of a duty to someone else unless the delegation is contrary to public policy or to the terms of the obligor's own promise.1 The law starts from permission, so the party who resists a delegation must supply the reason. The delegate did not make the contract and is a third party to it in the ordinary sense.2 Even so, the delegate may perform, as long as the obligee, the party to whom the duty is owed, receives the substantial benefit of the bargain.3
The Uniform Commercial Code states the same default for sales of goods in its own words. A party may perform through a delegate unless the parties agreed otherwise or the other party has a substantial interest in having the original promisor perform or control the acts the contract requires.4 The Restatement reaches the same place in two steps. It first states the default with its exceptions for public policy and the terms of the promise. It then adds that, unless otherwise agreed, a promise requires performance by a particular person only to the extent the obligee has a substantial interest in having that person perform or control the acts promised.5 The UCC adds that no delegation of performance relieves the delegating party of any duty to perform or any liability for breach.6
The exceptions fall into two groups, and each rests on a different reason. The first group comes from the parties' agreement and from public policy: an obligor may not delegate in the face of a promise not to, or in a way the law forbids. The second group comes from the obligee's substantial interest in a particular performer. Contracts to teach, to sing, or to paint a portrait are obviously too personal to delegate, and any promise for personal services, or one that otherwise calls for the obligor's skill and discretion, will likely be found too personal as well.7 Later sections develop each group. Here it is enough to see that both exist and that both are exceptions to a rule of permission.
One ice-cream case shows the default giving way. The court held the rights and duties of the contract so personal that Frederick's rights could not be assigned nor his duties delegated without defeating the intention of the parties.8 When Frederick went out of the business of making ice cream, his personal action and qualifications, on which the other side had relied, dropped out of a contract that presupposed their continuance, and the court treated his course as a repudiation.9
The obligee can also remove the problem. Any delegation is proper if made with the consent of the person to whom the duty is owed, so the analysis ends once consent appears, and even a contract to teach or sing becomes delegable when the parties agree to permit it.10
Because the rule is only a default, it yields to what the parties say. An obligee who cares who performs can write that into the promise, and a delegation contrary to the terms of the promise is improper.11 The presumption favoring delegation is also weaker than the one favoring assignment of rights. A duty is not the obligor's property, so the freedom to delegate does not rest on a right to transfer property, and a change in who performs can affect the obligee more than a change in who holds the right to receive performance. Delegation is therefore usually possible but subject to greater restrictions than assignment.12
The two owners differ only in what their contracts say, and that difference decides the result. An owner who objects to subcontracting needs a reason, and a clause is one of the reasons the law recognizes. Without a clause, an owner would have to show a statute or public policy against the delegation, or a substantial interest in having Harlan perform or control the work.
The first three steps usually resolve quickly on the facts of a problem. Most real disputes are fought at the fourth, where the question becomes how much the identity of the performer matters to what the obligee receives. The sections that follow take up the clause and policy limits before turning to that test.