Concept
After a Valid Assignment
Assignment of rights
After a Valid Assignment
A valid assignment does two things at once: it extinguishes the assignor’s right to the obligor’s performance, in whole or in part, and it gives the assignee a right to that performance (Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 317(1)).1 An assignment gets that far only if it clears the limits studied above. A contractual right can be assigned unless one of them applies,2 and a party generally has the power to transfer its rights unless the contract forbids it, the transfer would impair the other party’s reasonable expectations, or public policy bars it.3 In this unit, the assignor is the obligee who transfers the right, the assignee is the transferee, and the obligor is the party who owes the performance.4
The obligor chose none of this, and two questions follow. Whom must the obligor pay, and what happens if it pays the assignor before it learns of the transfer? And what may the obligor say to an assignee who demands performance? The first is a question of notice and discharge, the second of defenses.
Notice and Discharge
Because the assignor can transfer a right without the obligor’s participation, the obligor may go on dealing with the creditor it knows and never hear of the change. The law therefore ties the obligor’s duty to the assignee to notice. Until the obligor receives notice of the assignment, it may discharge its duty by paying the assignor, even if it pays before the money is due. Discharge means the duty ends, and the assignee has no claim against the obligor for that payment. Once the obligor receives notice and a request to pay the assignee, it must pay only the assignee.5 UCC § 9-406(a) states the same rule for the payment rights Article 9 covers. The account debtor may discharge its obligation by paying the assignor only until it receives notification that the amount due has been assigned and that payment is to be made to the assignee, and afterward only by paying the assignee.6
Each half of the rule protects a different party. Before notice, an obligor that keeps paying the creditor it knows is doing what its contract requires, and making it pay twice would punish the one party with no way to learn of the change. After notice, the obligor knows who owns the right and the assignor has given up its claim to payment. If a payment to the assignor still discharged the obligor, the assignee would have to trust the assignor to hand over whatever it collected. The rule thus splits the risk of silence: until the obligor is told, the assignee bears it, and once the obligor is told, the obligor bears it. Under Article 9, either the assignor or the assignee may end the assignee’s risk by sending the notification, and the assignee, whose money is at stake, has every reason to send it at once.
Notice must do a specific job. Under Article 9, a notification must be authenticated by the assignor or the assignee, and it must state that the amount due or to become due has been assigned and that payment is to be made to the assignee.7 A message that does not tell the obligor which amount to pay, and to whom, gives it nothing to act on. The obligor, for its part, may insist on reasonable proof that the assignment was actually made, which protects it from a stranger who simply demands payment.8
The plainest case of discharge involves no notice at all. A lender sells its right to repayment of a $10,000 loan to a finance company, and no one tells the borrower. When the debt falls due, the borrower pays the lender. The payment discharges the borrower’s duty, and the finance company, which has no claim against the borrower, must look to the lender for the money.9
Knowledge produces the opposite result. In Herzog v. Irace, Gary Jones owed a doctor fees for treating his shoulder and instructed his lawyers to pay the doctor out of the proceeds of his injury settlement. Jones later changed his mind and told the lawyers to pay the settlement to him, and they did so, although they knew of the assignment. When the doctor sued, the lawyers argued that they had an ethical duty to follow their client’s instructions. The court rejected that defense. Jones no longer had a right to the proceeds, so he could not validly revoke his instruction to pay the doctor.10 The countermand failed for the reason § 317(1) gives: once the assignment is made, the assignor’s right is extinguished, and an assignor with no right left has nothing to redirect.11 The borrower and the lawyers both paid the assignor, and what separates them is whether they knew of the assignment when they paid.
Notice fixes whom the obligor must pay, but it does not always freeze the contract. Under UCC § 9-405(a), a good-faith modification of an assigned contract binds the assignee to the extent that the right to payment has not been fully earned or notification of the assignment has not been given. The assignee acquires corresponding rights under the modified contract, and the modification may breach the assignor’s agreement with the assignee.12 The Code thus departs from the common law. Even after notification, the original parties may modify or substitute the contract in good faith and in accordance with reasonable commercial standards, provided the assigned right has not been earned by full performance. The assignee is bound by the change but takes rights under the contract as modified.13 The reason is practical. Modifications are customary in government and construction contracts, and a rule that barred every change after notice would make those contracts harder to perform and so less worth assigning.14
Suppose a contractor agrees to build a warehouse for $900,000 and assigns its right to the payments to a bank, which notifies the owner. Midway through the job, the owner and contractor agree in good faith to drop the loading dock and cut the price to $850,000. The bank is bound and collects under the modified contract, and it may have a claim against the contractor if the change breaches their agreement. If the contractor had already finished the warehouse and earned the full $900,000, a reduction agreed after notice would not bind the bank, because the right was fully earned and notice had been given.
Step 2 decides most problems, because the same payment to the assignor either ends the obligor’s duty or exposes it to a second payment, depending only on whether notice had arrived.
Defenses Against the Assignee
An assignee takes the right in the condition the assignor held it. Under UCC § 9-404(a), an assignee of an account generally takes subject to the account debtor’s defenses and claims.16 The same is true of contract rights generally: the obligor may assert against the assignee any defense it could assert against the assignor. Courts say that an assignee “stands in the shoes” of the assignor and has no better rights, even if the assignee is a good-faith purchaser for value.17 The Latin maxim says the same thing: nemo dat qui non habet, no one may transfer more than he owns.18 The preceding subsection asked whom the obligor must pay after notice. This one asks what the obligor may say when the assignee demands payment.
The rule follows from what an assignment is, because the assignee acquires the assignor’s right to the performance the contract calls for and nothing more.19 It also allocates risk sensibly. The obligor’s duty came from a bargain with the assignor, and a transfer that it neither joined nor could stop should leave it no worse off. The assignee, by contrast, can read the contract before it pays for the right, price the risk of a defense into what it pays, and look to the assignor if a defense succeeds.
The obligor’s defenses fall into two groups, and the calendar sorts them.
- Defenses that arise from the assigned contract itself, such as defective formation, an unsatisfied condition, the assignor’s breach, or impracticability, are good against the assignee whenever they arise.
- Claims against the assignor that come from some unrelated transaction may be set off only if they accrued before the obligor received notice.
The first group consists of defects in the assigned contract. If the contract was invalid when formed, or became unenforceable because of impracticability, public policy, nonoccurrence of a condition, or the other party’s breach, the obligor may assert that defense against the assignee.20 Under § 9-404(a)(1), it makes no difference whether such a defense accrues before or after the account debtor is notified of the assignment.21 These defenses belong to the bargain the assignee acquired. Notice tells the obligor whom to pay, but it does not change what the assignor owed in return.
Taylor’s claim against Alice rests entirely on the assignment, because without it he would have no rights against her.22 Since he took only what the worker had, Alice may plead the worker’s breach against him as she could against the worker.23 The breach operates only as a defense, however. Alice may set the damages against Taylor’s claim and reduce it to nothing, but Taylor has no liability for the damage beyond that offset.24 He received a right to payment, not a promise to mow well. A claim against Taylor for the bad mowing would require that he take over the worker’s duty, and that is a delegation, a different transaction subject to greater restrictions than an assignment.25
The second group follows a different clock. Suppose X agrees to paint Y’s house for $6,000 and assigns the right to payment to a bank, which notifies Y and demands payment. Y may assert against the bank that X never painted the house, painted it improperly, was an unlicensed contractor, or misrepresented facts on which Y relied, because each of these arises under the painting contract.26 Y may also deduct damages for a tort X committed by backing into Y’s car before notice, and a debt X owed Y that was already due before notice. Y may not deduct damages for a collision that happened after notice, or a debt that did not come due until after notice.27 A claim accrues when it has become due and owing. It is not enough that the claim arises from another contract that already existed when notice arrived.28 The usual mistake is to treat notice as the dividing line for every defense, when it divides only these unrelated claims.
The cutoff at notice protects the obligor as far as possible without discouraging assignments. Defenses tied to the assigned contract stay available at every point, because they protect the performance the obligor bargained for. Unrelated claims are cut off after notice because an obligor who could keep collecting fresh set-offs against the assignor after learning of the transfer would make every assigned right unreliable. Before notice, the obligor has no reason to know the assignee exists, so claims that accrue then remain usable.
The Minnesota commission dispute in the Article 9 materials shows the maxim at work. Thurman had assigned his real estate commissions to CE, and CE sued for the commission on the Keller Lake property. The court found that Thurman was not entitled to a commission at the time of that closing, and it held that CE could not obtain a greater right in the commission than Thurman had.29 Notice dates played no part, because CE’s claim was only as good as the right it received.
An assignee whose claim is defeated is not left without recourse. Unless the assignment shows a contrary intent, the assignor impliedly warrants that the right is valid and free of defenses, so the assignee may sue the assignor for breach of that warranty.30 The warranty moves the loss to the party whose breach or flawed contract weakened the right, which is also why the assignee can fairly be made to take the right subject to the obligor’s defenses in the first place.