Concept
Partial Assignments
Assignment of rights
Partial Assignments
An obligee who is owed a single performance may want to transfer only part of it. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 326(1) permits that: an assignment of a part of a right, whether the part is specified as a fraction, as an amount, or otherwise, is operative as to that part to the same extent and in the same manner as if the part had been a separate right.1 The definition of assignment already pointed this way, because it says the assignor's right to performance is extinguished “in whole or in part” and that the assignee acquires a right to the performance transferred.2 A partial assignment divides one right: the assignee takes a piece, and the assignor keeps the rest.
Division creates a difficulty that a whole assignment never does. After a whole assignment, the obligor answers to one claimant. After a partial one, two people hold claims on a single promise, and an obligor that agreed to one performance must work out who is owed what and may face more than one suit. The Restatement answers with two protections. Subsection (2) conditions enforcement on joinder of the interested parties, and the limit on assignments that materially burden the obligor applies to a part as it does to a whole.3 The first subsection below teaches the rule that a part is a separate right; the second teaches those protections.
Part Treated as Separate Right
Section 326(1) measures a partial assignment by two standards. Operating “to the same extent” means the carved-out piece does what a whole assignment does: the assignor's right to that piece ends, and the assignee acquires it.4 Operating “in the same manner” means the piece must meet the requirements for any assignment, so the obligee must still manifest an intention to transfer it, and the piece stays subject to the limits on assignability taught earlier.5 The words “or otherwise” widen the ways of describing the part, but the description must still tell the obligor what was transferred.
The rule seems natural today, yet early common law reached the opposite result. An obligor could ignore a partial assignment, for two reasons that reinforced each other: the rule against splitting a cause of action treated a single claim as one to be litigated once, and procedure at law limited a suit to two parties.6 If the assignor and the assignee each held a piece of one right, the obligor would have to defend a separate suit against each over a single transaction, though it had bargained to answer one claimant for one performance.7 Because the protection belonged to the obligor, its assent was what made a partial assignment effective.8
Equity found a way around the difficulty. A court of equity could bring every holder of a piece of the right into one proceeding, so the obligor answered once, and equity enforced partial assignments on that footing.9 Modern joinder rules then carried the solution into actions at law: an obligor can now force everyone who holds a piece of the same right, including the assignor if the assignor kept part of it, into a single action.10 With the procedural obstacle gone, many courts enforce partial assignments as they would a whole one.11 The majority lets the partial assignee sue at law once the interested parties are joined, or once procedural rules dispense with joinder because proceeding without it is fair under the circumstances.12 The old objection was a problem of procedure, and procedure solved it.
Herzog v. Irace shows a partial assignment enforced. Jones's letter asked his lawyers to pay Dr. Herzog, who had treated his shoulder injury, out of the funds they held. The court saw no reason in the word “request” to doubt Jones's intent to complete the assignment, and although no amount was stated, the parties did not dispute that Herzog's charges were reasonable and necessary to the treatment.13 The lawyers held enough to pay every creditor, Herzog included, with money left over for Jones himself, so the assignment took only part of the fund and Jones kept the rest.14 The part was fixed not by a fraction or a stated sum but by a measurable standard, the reasonable charges for treating that injury, which is the kind of specification “or otherwise” leaves room for.
A worked problem isolates the question of burden. Claire is owed $100,000 from a fund her lawyer, Lex, holds. She writes Lex authorizing payment from the fund to Finance Co., and the letter is read as an assignment to Finance Co. of $50,000. Read for its reasonable import, the letter was an assignment rather than a mere authorization to pay, the distinction the earlier section on present transfer draws. A partial assignment is permissible so long as splitting the right imposes no substantial risk or burden on the obligor, and a payment out of a fund imposes none.15 Lex's task is arithmetic: the fund exists, the total is known, and the assigned part is stated, so he can pay Finance Co. its share and Claire the balance without estimating what either is owed. Once Lex has notice, the assignment binds him, and he can discharge his duty only by paying Finance Co. what belongs to it.16 The notice rules come later in this chapter, but the example already shows the piece behaving like a whole assignment.
Even where partial assignments are welcome, one that materially burdens the obligor can fail. Splitting a right into many partial assignments could impose a material adverse burden on the obligor and so be ruled ineffective.17 A single payment out of an existing fund sits at the harmless end of that range; a right cut into many pieces is where the danger lies.
Some jurisdictions have not moved at all, and the older rule survives as a minority approach. Illinois is the standard example: Cincinnati Insurance Co. v. American Hardware Manufacturers Ass'n is cited for the proposition that, although the rationale for the rule against partial assignments has been questioned, Illinois still applies it to deny enforcement of a partial assignment made without the obligor's consent.18 In such a jurisdiction the obligor's consent is the dividing line, as it was at common law.
Because the answer depends on the shape of the assigned part and on the jurisdiction's rule, a partial assignment problem is best run in a fixed order.
Step five matters because a student who remembers only the modern rule will overlook a jurisdiction that withholds enforcement until the obligor consents.
Joinder and Burden Limits
Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 326(2) gives the obligor its protection. If the obligor has not contracted to perform separately the assigned part of a right, neither the assignor nor the assignee may maintain a legal proceeding against the obligor over its objection unless all the persons entitled to the promised performance are joined, or unless joinder is not feasible and it is equitable to proceed without it.20 The previous subsection showed that an assigned part operates as a separate right.21 Left alone, that result would cost the obligor something, because the obligor made one promise to one person and now answers to two or more. Two devices absorb the cost. A procedural rule gathers every holder of a piece of the right into one proceeding, and the material-effect limit invalidates a division too burdensome to enforce.
The opening condition of § 326(2) decides when joinder matters. It applies when the obligor has not contracted to perform the assigned part separately. The ordinary obligor promised a single performance, such as one payment of a stated sum, and an assignment of part of that sum leaves the assignor holding some of the claim and the assignee holding the rest. Each holder could sue, and a court hearing only one of them cannot be sure what the other is owed. The obligor could be made to defend more than one suit over a single transaction. The rule ends that exposure by letting the obligor insist that everyone entitled to the performance appear together, so that one proceeding fixes each holder's share. Because the requirement operates over the obligor's objection, it is a protection the obligor may invoke or leave unused.
The history shows why joinder is the chosen tool. Before procedure permitted liberal joinder of parties, an obligor could ignore a partial assignment altogether, because honoring it could force the obligor to defend more than one suit arising out of one transaction.22 Partial assignments are now permitted, and the obligor is protected by being able to force into one action all persons holding partial assignments of the same right, including the assignor if the assignor reserved some portion.23 The majority view carries that practice into actions at law: a partial assignee may sue if all interested parties are joined, or if procedural rules dispense with joinder because proceeding without the others is fair under the circumstances.24 The second clause of § 326(2) is the Restatement's version of that exception. Joinder is excused when it is not feasible and proceeding without the missing holder is equitable.
Joinder settles who must be in the courtroom. It does not settle how much each holder is owed or what it costs the obligor to deal with a divided right before any suit is filed. Those concerns belong to the material-effect limit, which bars an assignment that would materially increase the burden or risk the obligor's contract imposes on it.25 Two features of a partial assignment can trigger that limit: a portion too vague to measure, and a right broken into many pieces.
The vague portion appears in Allstate Insurance Co. v. Medical Lien Management, Inc., where the assignment covered an ill-defined portion of a claim. The Colorado court held it invalid, because the assignment materially increased the obligor's burden by making it determine the amount assigned, possibly through litigation.26 Joining the parties would not have supplied the missing figure. An assignment that names a fraction or a stated sum hands the obligor the number, so the obligor does arithmetic where a vague description forces it to estimate or litigate.
The second feature is fragmentation. Splitting a right into many partial assignments could impose a material adverse burden on the obligor and so be ruled ineffective.27 Each additional holder is another claimant to identify, pay, and answer, and joinder consolidates the lawsuit without reducing the number of people the obligor must deal with day to day.
The two protections do different work, and confusing them is the usual error. Section 326(2) conditions a proceeding on joinder and leaves the partial assignment valid, so reading it as making partial assignments ineffective is a mistake. The material-effect limit goes to validity, and where it applies the assignment fails. The first protects the obligor from multiple suits. The second protects it from a division it never agreed to administer.