Concept
One Satisfaction Only
Creditor-beneficiary remedies
One Satisfaction Only
A creditor beneficiary who may sue both the promisee and the promisor could seem to hold two claims on one debt. The second sentence of Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 310(1) rules that out. After allowing judgment against the promisee, the promisor, or both, it provides that satisfaction "in whole or in part" of either duty, or of a judgment on it, "satisfies to that extent the other duty or judgment."1 Satisfaction means the obligation has actually been discharged, ordinarily by payment. "To that extent" makes the rule proportionate: paying part of the debt reduces both duties by that part and leaves the rest standing. In the running example, Debtor and Buyer stand behind one $200,000 debt, and whatever Creditor actually collects from either one comes off what both owe.
The two duties are two routes to one debt, not two debts. Debtor arranged for Buyer's price to flow to Creditor in order to settle what Debtor owed, so a dollar Buyer delivers is a dollar of the sum Creditor was owed all along. If each duty were an independent fund, a Creditor with a $200,000 claim against each defendant could collect $400,000 on a $200,000 loan. Creditor may obtain judgment against both but is entitled to only one satisfaction.2 The limit also protects the defendants, because neither is exposed to paying Creditor a dollar the other has already paid.
The balance fell on every line at once. Buyer's $120,000 reduced Buyer's duty, Debtor's duty, and both judgments, because the rule reaches judgments as well as duties, and Debtor's $50,000 reduced all four again. Payment triggered each reduction. A judgment against Buyer that sits unpaid leaves Debtor's duty where it was, which fits the point of the previous section: taking judgment against one defendant surrenders nothing against the other.
The reduction also reaches Debtor's own contract with Buyer. Debtor keeps the right to enforce Buyer's promise, but Buyer need not perform that promise twice. Debtor's right against Buyer is discharged to the extent that Buyer performs in favor of Creditor, and if full performance is not rendered, Debtor may enforce the balance.3 This matches Debtor's position as surety: Debtor remains liable to Creditor only for the outstanding, undischarged amount. After the $120,000 payment, Debtor's claim to have Buyer pay Creditor has shrunk to $80,000, the same figure Creditor can still collect. The debt, Buyer's promise to Creditor, and Buyer's promise to Debtor shrink together because each measures the same unpaid sum.
Two $200,000 judgments in an exam fact pattern tempt students to add them. Both figures describe one debt. The rule caps what Creditor may collect and leaves untouched the number of defendants Creditor may sue.
Satisfaction by the promisee closes Creditor's claim without closing the account between Debtor and Buyer. A Debtor who pays Creditor $50,000 has paid money that Buyer promised to pay, and the sentence of § 310(1) that limits Creditor to one satisfaction ends by making the reduction "subject to the promisee's right of subrogation."4 Debtor is surety and Buyer principal, so a Debtor compelled to pay may proceed against Buyer for reimbursement.5 The next section takes up how that recourse works.