Concept
Beneficiary's Own Conduct
Defenses against the beneficiary
Beneficiary's Own Conduct
Every defense covered so far traces to the contract between promisor and promisee, whether a flaw present at formation or a later event that stripped the contract of its force. One defense has a different source: the beneficiary. Under Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 309(4), a beneficiary's right against the promisor is subject to any claim or defense arising from the beneficiary's own conduct or agreement.1 The promisor points to something the beneficiary did, such as signing a release, making a separate agreement, or engaging in misconduct, and the only question is whether that act answers the suit.
The rule treats the beneficiary as an actor in the beneficiary's own right, not as a passive recipient of someone else's bargain. The earlier defenses protect a promisor from paying on a contract that never bound or later failed. This one protects the promisor from a claimant whose own act undercuts the claim.
A stem that reports deception of the promisor raises a sorting question: who did the deceiving? If Mary lied to Dan about Joe's qualifications to induce Dan to sign, the misconduct is hers, and Dan may raise it against her claim under the beneficiary's-own-conduct rule.2 If Joe told the lie, the defense comes from the contract instead. Joe's fraud leaves the Dan-Joe contract voidable at formation, and the beneficiary's right is subject to that infirmity.3 Dan may raise the fraud against Mary, but Mary bears no liability for it. By accepting the benefit, she does not assume responsibility for the promisee's wrongful conduct, and Dan's recourse for any loss runs against Joe.4
The classification therefore turns on whose conduct creates the defense. The beneficiary's own act brings the own-conduct rule, and the beneficiary answers for it. The promisee's wrongdoing is a defense under the contract-based rules, and it never becomes a personal debt of the beneficiary. Blurring the two produces opposite errors: treating an innocent beneficiary's claim as immune from the promisee's fraud, and holding the beneficiary liable for the promisee's breach.