Concept
Security Interest in Rejected Goods
Aggrieved buyer's remedies when the seller breaches
Security Interest in Rejected Goods
A buyer who prepays, receives nonconforming goods, and rejects them ends up holding the goods while the seller holds the money. Section 2-711(3) gives that buyer a right in the goods themselves. On rightful rejection or justifiable revocation of acceptance, the buyer has a security interest in goods in its possession or control for any payments made on their price and any expenses reasonably incurred in their inspection, receipt, transportation, care, and custody, and it may hold the goods and resell them in like manner as an aggrieved seller under § 2-706.1 The court in Cardwell v. International Housing, Inc. grounded the buyer's security interest in this same subsection, quoting Pennsylvania's codification at 12A P.S. § 2-711(3).2
The provision matters because of what a refund claim lacks. The refund remedy gives the buyer a claim for the prepaid money, but a claim depends on a seller that has already failed to perform and may resist payment or be unable to make it. A security interest, which is a right in particular property that lets a creditor look to that property for what it is owed, backs the claim with goods the buyer already controls. The seller is not unfairly burdened, because the interest reaches only the sums that the seller's nonconforming tender put at risk.
Two conditions must be met together. The first is a trigger, either rightful rejection or justifiable revocation of acceptance, and the statute names both.3 Rejection rests on the buyer's right to refuse goods or a tender of delivery that fail to conform to the contract.4 The second condition is that the goods be in the buyer's possession or control. That condition limits the remedy to a buyer who actually holds the goods. When the seller fails to deliver or repudiates, the buyer has no goods in hand to secure its right to recover sums paid, and it relies on the refund and damages remedies instead.5 The statute draws the same line between its subsections. Subsection (2) serves the buyer whose seller failed to deliver or repudiated, and subsection (3) serves the buyer holding rejected goods.6
The interest secures two kinds of sums. The first is any payment made on the price, which ties the interest to the refund, so whatever the buyer prepaid or deposited is what the goods stand behind. The second is expenses reasonably incurred in inspecting, receiving, transporting, caring for, and keeping the goods, which are costs the buyer bears only because a nonconforming tender left it holding goods it did not want.7 Only reasonable expenses count, so a buyer cannot enlarge its security by spending freely on the goods. The statute names only these two categories. It does not secure damages, so a student who treats the goods as security for cover costs or a market differential is reading more into the provision than it says.
The statute gives the buyer two powers over the goods. Holding them keeps them in the buyer's hands as leverage until the secured sums are paid. Reselling them turns the goods into cash from which the buyer can pay itself, and the resale follows the manner of an aggrieved seller under § 2-706.8 The buyer must also account for any excess over the amount of its security interest.9 That duty follows from the purpose of the interest, which is to protect what the buyer is owed. Once the buyer has been paid, anything further the goods bring belongs to the seller whose goods were sold. A buyer allowed to keep the surplus would recover its loss and then earn a bonus from goods it had no right to keep.
A buyer who revokes acceptance sometimes keeps using the goods while the dispute plays out. In one mobile-home case, the buyers successfully revoked their acceptance and occupied the home in the meantime. The court observed that the defendant suffered no loss from the occupancy, because the trial court had awarded the defendant an offset for the home's rental value during that period.10 The case shows how the law handles a revoking buyer who stays in possession. The value of any use is accounted for through an offset against the buyer's recovery, so the seller is not left bearing it.
Two buyers with equally good grievances can still lack the interest, for different reasons, and a remedies problem often tests which reason applies.
The first buyer lacks the goods, and the second lacks anything for the goods to secure. Either way, the interest has no work to do.
A buyer who is a merchant faces a further duty under § 2-603, which sits just outside § 2-711(3). In one decision, a merchant buyer rejected nonconforming trees in New York City, where the sellers had no agent or place of business. After rejection, the buyer had to follow the sellers' reasonable instructions and, absent instructions, make reasonable efforts to sell the trees for the sellers' account. The buyer's expenses in doing so included rent for a selling site and wages for salesmen and a night watchman. Under § 2-603(2), those expenses were recoverable in addition to incidental and consequential damages.11 That resale differs from the one in § 2-711(3). There the buyer sells to pay itself what it is owed, while here the merchant buyer sells on the seller's behalf.