Concept
Incidental and Consequential Damages
Aggrieved buyer's remedies when the seller breaches
Incidental and Consequential Damages
Section 2-711 gives the buyer two damages measures but computes neither: it sends the buyer to cover damages under § 2-712 and to damages for nondelivery under § 2-713.1 Cover damages equal the cost of the substitute goods minus the contract price, provided the buyer covers in good faith and without unreasonable delay. Nondelivery damages equal the market price when the buyer learned of the breach minus the contract price, and they apply only when and to the extent the buyer does not cover.2
Neither price gap makes the buyer whole. Each measures what the goods cost in a replacement purchase or on the market, and neither says anything about what the buyer spent dealing with the breach or lost because the goods never arrived. Section 2-715 closes those two gaps with incidental damages and consequential damages. A buyer who does not cover keeps its claims for both, because failure to cover bars neither remedy.3 The base measure can itself take unusual forms: one buyer sought to measure cover by the average cost of the gasoline it drew from its own inventory, 63.14 cents a gallon against a 60.4-cent contract price, although going to the market would have cost about 55 cents.4
Consequential damages also separate the buyer’s remedies from the seller’s. Cover, the buyer’s counterpart to resale, provides for consequential damages; the seller’s resale formula does not.5 A seller is not entitled to consequential damages at all. When the ordinary measure under § 2-708(1) is inadequate to put the seller in as good a position as performance, the seller recovers lost profits and reasonable overhead under § 2-708(2) instead.6 The two profit claims protect different profits: § 2-715 reaches what the buyer would have earned on a resale or other use of the goods in a deal with a third party, while § 2-708(2) reaches what the seller would have earned on the sale to the breaching buyer.7
Incidental Damages
Incidental damages reimburse the buyer for expenses that the seller’s breach, and not the buyer’s own plans, creates. Section 2-715(1) names three kinds of expense and ends with a catch-all for “any other reasonable expense incident to the delay or other breach.”8 The three clauses run in this order:
- Expenses reasonably incurred in inspecting, receiving, transporting, and caring for goods the buyer has rightfully rejected.
- Commercially reasonable charges, expenses, or commissions connected with effecting cover.
- Any other reasonable expense incident to the delay or other breach.
The price-gap measures answer a single question, how far the replacement or market price rises above the contract price, and they ignore what the buyer spent to get there. An illustration shows the difference. Suppose Acme agrees to sell Wiley 500 anvils at $700 each under a destination contract, so Acme would bear the $5,000 freight. Acme breaches, and Wiley makes a reasonable cover contract with Road Runner at $750 per anvil. That is a shipment contract, so Wiley bears the $5,000 freight itself. (Assume the freight is included in neither price.) The price gap is $25,000, and Wiley is out another $5,000 that performance would never have cost it. Wiley’s damages are $30,000.9 Without the add-on for incidental expense, Wiley would finish $5,000 worse off than performance would have left it. The official comment states the purpose the same way: the buyer is reimbursed for the reasonable expenses of handling rightfully rejected goods, or goods whose acceptance it justifiably revokes, and of effecting cover where the breach is a nonconformity.10
Every clause demands that the expense be reasonable because the seller pays the bill, and a buyer whose costs are reimbursed has no private reason to economize. The requirement plays the role that good faith and the absence of unreasonable delay play for cover: it lets the seller challenge any charge that exceeds what a prudent buyer spending its own money would have paid.
Decided cases show what recoverable handling expenses look like. In Atlan Industries, Inc. v. O.E.M., Inc., the buyer spent 80 hours, valued at $10 an hour, inspecting nonconforming material and grinding it back to its original state so that it could be returned, and the court awarded the $800 as an incidental expense.11
A merchant buyer’s duties after rejection can generate expenses of a different kind. In Traynor v. Walters the buyer rejected cut Christmas trees, goods that perish or threaten to decline in value speedily. The sellers had no agent or place of business in New York City, so the buyer, a merchant, had to follow any reasonable instructions from the sellers and, absent instructions, make reasonable efforts to sell the trees for the sellers’ account.12 The expenses of caring for and selling the trees included rent for a selling site and wages for salesmen and a night watchman, and they fit the care-and-custody clause of § 2-715(1).13 Because the buyer never covered, its only damages claims were for incidental and consequential damages, and its failure to cover did not bar them.14
Testing costs can qualify as well. In the Kellers’ suit over a dehumidifier, the court affirmed incidental damages for one employee’s time gathering temperature and humidity data ($1,092), another employee’s time transporting water samples ($1,001), and additional testing ($700), with the employee time valued at each employee’s hourly rate. The expenses were reasonably incurred in inspecting the equipment to establish whether it conformed to the express warranty, and they were caused by the seller’s breach.15
The causal chain that supports recovery also marks its outer edge. As one court explained in terms of but-for causation, a buyer forced by the seller’s breach to revoke acceptance incurs expenses it would not otherwise have borne, and so may recover them; a buyer who keeps the goods incurs the expenses of keeping them only because it kept them, and so may not.16 Compare a buyer who returns defective material after 80 hours of grinding with a buyer who keeps a defective truck and pays insurance and interest on it. The first buyer’s outlay is the price of undoing the breach. The second buyer’s outlay is the ordinary cost of owning something it chose to keep.
Not every post-breach cost sorts so easily into a clause, and the label controls which rules apply. A buyer who revokes acceptance of a car and writes that she will store it, rent a substitute, and hold the dealer accountable for the costs raises the classification question in its plainest form, as the buyer did in McGinnis v. Wentworth Chevrolet Co.17 Is the rental car an expense of effecting cover, which § 2-715(1) treats as incidental? Or is it a loss that follows from the buyer’s continuing need for transportation, which § 2-715(2) governs? An incidental expense need only be reasonable and caused by the breach.18 A consequential loss must also arise from needs the seller had reason to know of at contracting, resist prevention by cover or other reasonable steps, and be proved with reasonable certainty.19 Those conditions come next.
Consequential Damages
Consequential damages compensate the losses that the price gap and the incidental expenses leave behind, and § 2-715(2) recognizes two kinds that rest on different conditions. The first is any loss resulting from the buyer’s general or particular requirements and needs, of which the seller had reason to know at the time of contracting, and which cover or other reasonable steps could not have prevented.22 The second is injury to person or property proximately resulting from any breach of warranty.23 The first kind asks about foreseeability and avoidability for losses that grow out of the buyer’s plans for the goods; the second asks only about causation for harm the goods themselves inflict.
Lost profit is the standard first-kind loss. Section 2-715 compensates the buyer for the profit it would have earned on a resale or other use of the contract goods in a transaction with a third party, a profit that the price gap alone does not capture.24 The Code pays for that loss only if the seller could have foreseen it. The Atlan court stated the rule in Hadley v. Baxendale terms: consequential damages must be foreseeable; the seller is liable for damages arising from circumstances it knew or had reason to know about, even if it did not consciously assume the risk; and the buyer must prove them with reasonable certainty.25
The statute measures the seller’s knowledge at the time of contracting, because that is when the seller sets its price and decides what risk to accept.26 A seller who knows that a missed delivery will cost the buyer a lucrative resale can charge for the risk, take extra care to perform, or decline the order. A seller who learns of the resale after the price is fixed has none of those choices, and recovery would let the buyer, the only party who knows its business, set the seller’s liability after the bargain closes.
The last clause of the first kind makes the buyer’s duty to limit its losses a condition of recovery, and it gives the word cover two jobs. As a measure of damages, cover is optional. As a way of minimizing consequential loss, it may be required if the buyer wants to be awarded consequential damages, and what counts as cover can differ depending on which job it is doing.27 A buyer that elects market damages and does nothing may therefore keep the price gap and lose the profits a reasonable replacement purchase would have saved.28 Without the condition, a buyer with a cheap, available substitute could leave its line idle and bill the seller for the idle time.
Turner v. NJN Cotton Co. shows how far a court expects cover to go. The seller, Turner, argued that the buyer, NJN, could have covered the cotton for about $564,000, and the court agreed with NJN that $564,000 is hardly a “trifling expense.” The undisputed testimony was also that no additional cotton was available, because all of it had been ginned and sold, and a witness testified she could not have managed such a cost.29 The seller lost on a failure of proof: the defendant bears the burden of proving failure to mitigate, and it must prove both lack of diligence and the amount by which that failure increased the damages.30 Section 2-715(2)(a) carries the same idea when it excludes losses that could reasonably have been prevented “by cover or otherwise.”31 A buyer need replace goods only where replacements exist at a cost within reason, and the seller must produce the evidence that they do.
The second kind runs on different logic: it asks nothing about what the seller knew and nothing about cover. It reaches “injury to person or property proximately resulting from any breach of warranty,” so the buyer needs a breach of warranty and proximate causation between that breach and the injury.32 A buyer can often replace missing goods or avoid idle time, but it cannot cover its way out of a fire that has already burned its property.
These conditions settle the classification question left open above. An expense of dealing with the breach itself, such as handling rejected goods or effecting cover, is incidental. A loss that traces to the buyer’s own needs for the goods, or to harm the goods caused, is consequential and must clear the conditions just described.33
Applying the knowledge and cover conditions to every consequential claim is the usual error. They govern only the first kind, so a buyer whose defective goods burned its property need not show that the seller knew the property was there, while a buyer claiming lost resale profit must clear both conditions.