Concept
Cancellation and Price Refund
Aggrieved buyer's remedies when the seller breaches
Cancellation and Price Refund
Section 2-711(1) gives the buyer two remedies the moment a trigger occurs. After nondelivery, repudiation, rightful rejection, or justifiable revocation, the buyer “may cancel and whether or not he has done so may in addition to recovering so much of the price as has been paid” cover or recover damages for nondelivery.1 The damages remedies get their own sections. This one covers the two that come first: ending the contract and recovering the money already paid.
Two phrases organize what follows. “Whether or not he has done so” means the damages remedies do not wait on a cancellation. “In addition” means the refund sits beneath those remedies and does not replace them. A buyer that prepaid for goods it never received gets its money back, but the refund restores only what the buyer put in. It does not pay for the substitute goods the buyer now must buy at a higher price. How the remedies combine without paying the buyer twice for one loss is taken up once each remedy has been taught.
Cancelling the Contract
Cancellation is a right the buyer holds once a trigger has occurred; the statute says the buyer “may cancel.”2 The Code defines the act in § 2-106(4). A party cancels when it puts an end to the contract for the other side’s breach, and the effect is the same as termination, except that the cancelling party also retains any remedy for breach of the whole contract or for an unperformed balance.3 Termination discharges every obligation still executory on both sides, but any right based on prior breach or prior performance survives.4
Take a seller that repudiates a twelve-month supply contract after delivering two monthly shipments. If the buyer cancels, it need no longer accept or pay for the later shipments, and the seller need no longer deliver them. The buyer’s claims for the breach stay alive, and they reach the whole contract and the unperformed balance, not just the shipments already tendered. Walking away from the contract and being compensated for the breach are two separate steps, and taking the first does not forfeit the second.
The statute’s “whether or not” language replaces a choice that earlier law forced on the buyer. Under prior law, a buyer who rescinded and either refused the goods or returned them recovered the price paid and no more, while a buyer who wanted damages had to affirm the agreement and keep the goods. The Code rejects that election of remedies: regardless of whether the buyer cancels, it may recover money damages in addition to the price paid.5 The seller’s side shows a parallel layering. Although sellers are not entitled to consequential damages, a seller may recover lost profits on the contract and reasonable overhead when the ordinary measure under § 2-708(1) is “inadequate to put the seller in as good a position as performance.”6
McGinnis v. Wentworth Chevrolet Co. applied the same reading to a buyer who justifiably revoked acceptance: cancellation and a refund were not the end of that buyer’s remedies. The damages that remain come in two forms, and they are alternatives to each other. The buyer may cover in good faith and without unreasonable delay and recover the difference between the cost of cover and the contract price. Or it may recover the difference between the market price when it learned of the breach and the contract price, a measure that applies only when and to the extent the buyer does not cover.7
Cancelling also changes the buyer’s position in a way that waiting does not. Until a repudiating seller’s next performance is due, it can retract the repudiation unless the buyer has since cancelled, materially changed its position, or otherwise indicated that it considers the repudiation final.8 Cancellation therefore ends the seller’s power to retract, and the buyer need no longer wait to learn whether the seller will change course.
Cancelling is not a way out of any purchase the buyer regrets. The right belongs to a buyer that one of the four triggers has hit, and a buyer with none of them has nothing to cancel under § 2-711.9
Recovering Price Paid
The second remedy in § 2-711(1) is the refund. After any of the four triggers, the buyer may recover “so much of the price as has been paid,” and the statute gives it that right whether or not the buyer cancels.12 The measure is money actually handed over, whether a deposit, an advance payment, or the whole price. A balance the buyer still owes is not part of the refund; cancellation instead frees the buyer from paying it.
Buyers often pay before they know whether the seller will perform. They send a deposit to hold the goods, prepay against an invoice, or pay before they can inspect. If the seller then fails to deliver, or the buyer rightfully rejects or justifiably revokes, the seller holds money for a performance it never rendered. The refund returns that money.
The refund matters most in three payment patterns:13
- The buyer paid before delivery, and the seller then failed to deliver or repudiated.
- The buyer paid before inspecting the goods, and then rightfully rejected them.
- The buyer paid first, and later justifiably revoked its acceptance of the goods.
How much comes back follows what the buyer paid. In Riley v. Ken Wilson Ford, Inc., the court put it this way: on revocation of acceptance, the buyer may recover the full purchase price if the goods have been fully paid for, and other reasonable expenses.14 A buyer that has paid nothing has no refund to claim and relies on cancellation and damages instead.
The refund is the first layer of a buyer’s recovery, and the other remedies stack on it. In Atlan Indus., Inc. v. O.E.M., Inc., the buyer had paid $794.75 for a sample of Noryl FN 215 shipped for a molding test, and the court held the buyer entitled to a refund of that sum as the first element of its damages.15 The damages remedies taught in the next sections supply the other elements.
Physical possession of the goods does not close off the buyer’s remedies. In Gawlick v. American Builders Supply, Inc., the seller argued that nondelivery damages could not be awarded because the buyer had taken delivery of the vehicle and used it. The court answered that the revocation statute does not condition revocation on whether the buyer physically received the goods; a buyer who revokes “has the same rights and duties with regard to the goods involved as if he had rejected them.”16
A buyer that paid in full, kept the goods, and now wants its money back is asking to hold both sides of the exchange. Michiana Mack states the limit plainly: “The remedy of recapture of the purchase price is clearly dependent upon the buyer’s rejection or revocation of the goods.”17 The price paid is the buyer’s payment for the goods, so the refund fits when the goods never arrive or go back. A buyer that keeps accepted goods looks to damages for the nonconformity instead.
The refund has a companion protection when the buyer holds the goods. On rightful rejection or justifiable revocation, the buyer has a security interest in goods in its possession or control for payments made on the price and for reasonable expenses of inspection, receipt, transportation, care, and custody, and it may hold and resell them as an aggrieved seller.18 A buyer whose seller never delivered or repudiated holds no goods, so nothing it holds secures its claim for the sums paid.19
Paying by note changes the picture. Consumer representatives pressed for a limit on the holder in due course doctrine because a consumer who received shoddy house siding and signed a negotiable note or a retail installment contract with a waiver-of-defense clause was often left holding the bag. The paper could be transferred quickly to a legitimate lender, who then insisted on full payment.20 A refund claim against the seller does not answer that exposure.