Concept
Selecting the Right Remedies
Aggrieved seller's remedies when the buyer breaches
Selecting the Right Remedies
Section 2-703 is both the gateway to the seller's remedies and an index of them. Its lead-in opens the menu to a seller whose buyer has wrongfully rejected or revoked acceptance, failed to make a payment due on or before delivery, or repudiated. It limits the remedies to the goods directly affected, and it reaches the whole undelivered balance only when the breach is of the whole contract.1 Six remedies follow: withholding delivery,2 stopping delivery by a bailee,3 proceeding as to goods still unidentified to the contract,4 reselling and recovering damages,5 recovering damages for nonacceptance or, in a proper case, the price,6 and cancelling.7 The earlier sections taught each remedy with its own conditions. This section shows how to move through them on a set of facts.
The questions run in the order of what the seller can know. The first concern facts fixed at the moment of breach: which breach occurred, how much of the contract it reaches, and where the goods are. The later ones depend on events that may not have happened yet, such as whether a resale will succeed or whether anyone will buy the goods at all. A seller often cannot answer those on the day the buyer defaults, so the seller needs a structure that keeps several remedies in play while the facts develop.
The first two steps decide whether any remedy exists and which self-help remedy the goods allow. The middle steps choose among the money measures, and each answers the question the one before it leaves open. A seller that fails step three moves to step four, and a seller whose market differential undercompensates moves to step five.
The sequence asks questions in order; it does not force an election among the six items. The point matters because older law ran the other way. An Oregon court noted that, before Oregon adopted the UCC, an aggrieved seller had to elect between remedies, and a seller who resold was treated as having elected resale and could recover only resale-price damages, not market-price damages.8 The Code rejects that approach. As the court quoted the comments, the sales chapter “reject[s] any doctrine of election of remedy as a fundamental policy and thus the remedies are essentially cumulative in nature and include all of the available remedies for breach,” and “[w]hether the pursuit of one remedy bars another depends entirely on the facts of the individual case.”9 The text points the same way. The buyer's index joins cover and damages for nondelivery with “or,” while the seller's index lists its remedies with no limiting conjunction, so it does not bar a seller who resells from seeking market-price damages.10 The cumulative design also lets the remedies work together. In a dispute over a Koons and a Basquiat, the court held the buyer, Hessel, in breach and held that Christie's could cancel the sale and resell the two works at auction.11
Cumulative in design does not mean every route stays open. Each remedy carries its own conditions, and a seller who skips one loses that route and falls back to another. In Foxco Industries, Ltd. v. Fabric World, Inc., the seller privately sold some of the goods after the buyer's breach without giving the buyer notice. The court held that it could not invoke the resale section and was left with Sections 2-708 and 2-709, and it left the jury to decide which fit the facts.12 Sotheby's shows the other side of the ledger. It gave the defendants ten days' notice of its intent to resell the work, and it later offered an expert appraisal of the work's fair market value at $4,400,000 as of October 13, 2017.13 The difference between the two sellers is notice, and it decided which routes each could use.
Single facts also decide whether the price or lost profit is the right measure. One seller had made a custom glass tabletop to the buyer's exact dimensions. The court found it impracticable to locate another consumer with a table of those dimensions, observed that the buyer had made a pattern of the table's unique shape and had not rebutted the lack of a resale market, and held the seller entitled to the $584.33 owed on the contract.14 In another case the plaintiff was a middleman, and the court applied Section 2-708(2), which measures damages by the profit the seller would have earned, including reasonable overhead.15 The ordinary differential could not measure either claim, for opposite reasons. The tabletop could not be sold again, so the seller held something worthless to anyone else and only the price restored the bargain. The middleman could sell the goods again, but a middleman who can supply every customer gains no new sale from a breach, so the second sale replaced nothing and the loss was the profit on the sale that failed.
One caution keeps the walk-through honest: Section 2-703 is an index, not a complete catalogue. Its caption reads “Seller's remedies in general,” the buyer's counterpart is captioned the same way, and Section 1-107 makes captions part of the UCC. Even so, a student should not infer that the two sections are exhaustive, because they omit some remedies that appear in associated sections of Article 2.16