Concept
Action for the Price
Aggrieved seller's remedies when the buyer breaches
Action for the Price
Section 2-703(e) gives the aggrieved seller two money remedies after a qualifying buyer breach: damages for nonacceptance under Section 2-708 or, “in a proper case,” the price under Section 2-709.1 The preceding section covered damages, measured by the market price or by the seller’s lost profit. The price is a different kind of claim, and the qualifier “in a proper case” warns that it is not available whenever damages are. Section 2-703 places it on the seller’s menu after a qualifying buyer breach and confines it, like the other remedies, to the goods that breach directly affected.2
The price is exceptional because it asks the buyer to pay the whole contract sum and subtracts nothing. Damages start from the contract price and deduct what the goods are worth in the seller’s hands, so they measure the seller’s actual loss. That deduction has no object only when the buyer already holds the goods or no one else will buy them. A seller who could still sell the goods and also collect the price would end up with both the money and the merchandise, better off than performance would have left it. Section 2-709 therefore confines the action to specified cases and is intended to be exhaustive in listing them.3
The listed cases fall into two groups: goods the buyer accepted, and goods identified to the contract that the seller cannot resell. A third topic completes the picture: what the seller must do with goods it still controls once it sues, and what it recovers if the price claim fails. On a problem, begin with damages and reach for the price only after the facts fit one of the listed cases.
Price of Accepted Goods
The first proper case covers goods the buyer has taken. When the buyer fails to pay the price as it becomes due, the seller may recover the price, with incidental damages, “of goods accepted or of conforming goods lost or damaged within a commercially reasonable time after risk of their loss has passed to the buyer.”4 The accepted-goods branch has two conditions: the buyer accepted the goods, and the price came due and went unpaid.
Acceptance supports the price because the buyer has taken the goods as its own. Damages would deduct the goods’ value in the seller’s hands, and the goods are not in the seller’s hands. Forcing the seller to retrieve them, resell them, and sue for the shortfall would undo a delivery the buyer chose to keep. The ordinary credit sale shows the point: a buyer who accepts goods on thirty-day terms and does not pay when the thirty days run owes the price, and the seller sues for it.
The statute’s second alternative reaches conforming goods that are lost or damaged within a commercially reasonable time after risk of loss has passed to the buyer. By then the risk has fallen on the buyer, so the goods’ destruction does not relieve the buyer of the price.5 Problems more often turn on the first alternative, because it depends on the rules of rejection.
Acceptance depends on rejection. Section 2-606 defines acceptance as “failure to make an effective rejection,” and it points to Section 2-602(1), which requires a rejection “within a reasonable time after their delivery or tender” and makes it “ineffective unless the buyer seasonably notifies the seller.”6 A buyer who rejects in time and gives seasonable notice has rejected effectively, so no acceptance has occurred and the accepted-goods ground has nothing to attach to. A buyer who rejects late, or without notice, has rejected ineffectively and is treated as having accepted. Integrated Circuits Unlimited, Inc. v. E.F. Johnson Co. puts the consequence plainly: “the remedy for an ineffective rejection — one which is procedurally defective under § 2-602(1) — is an action for the price.”7
Wrongfulness and effectiveness measure different things. A rejection is wrongful when the buyer had no legitimate ground for refusing, as when the goods conform. It is ineffective when the buyer missed the procedure of timely rejection and seasonable notice. A buyer can therefore reject conforming goods wrongfully and still reject effectively, and an effective rejection prevents acceptance. Section 2-602(3) places the remedies for wrongful rejection in Section 2-703, which sends the seller to damages under Section 2-708 or, “in a proper case,” the price under Section 2-709. A seller whose goods were wrongfully rejected thus recovers the price on this route only if that measure is proper because the rejection was also procedurally ineffective.8
The official commentary to Section 2-602 supports the separation. It explains that subsection (3), on wrongful rejections, was included only to emphasize the “sharp distinction” between the rules governing an effective rightful rejection and those governing “non-acceptance which is a breach,” meaning a procedurally effective rejection that is wrongful.9 The court also cited Blue Sky Forest Products, Inc. v. New Hampshire Doors Co. for the same point: a wrongful rejection is not by that fact an acceptance, although an ineffective one may be.
The line puts the cost of careless procedure on the buyer. A buyer who rejects in time and gives notice lets the seller retrieve the goods and deal with them, so damages measure the real loss, and the price would pay the seller twice, once in money and once in goods. A buyer who stays silent lets the sale look complete, and the Code treats that buyer as having accepted, which makes the full price the right measure. An effective rejection still leaves one route to the price, the unresalable-goods ground that follows.
When a problem says the buyer “wrongfully rejected” goods and asks about the price, check the procedure first: did the rejection come within a reasonable time, with seasonable notice? If it did, the rejection was effective, no acceptance occurred, and the seller’s measure is damages for nonacceptance unless the goods are unresalable. If it did not, the rejection operates as an acceptance, and the seller may recover the price once the buyer fails to pay when it is due.
Price of Unresalable Goods
The second proper case reaches goods the buyer never took. Under Section 2-709(1)(b), when the buyer fails to pay as the price comes due, the seller may recover the price of “goods identified to the contract if the seller is unable after reasonable effort to resell them at a reasonable price or the circumstances reasonably indicate that such effort will be unavailing.”11 A buyer who rejected effectively or refused delivery falls outside the accepted-goods ground and ordinarily leaves the seller with damages. This ground is the seller’s other route to the price, and it supplies the “proper case” that Section 2-703(e) promises.12
Resale remains the seller’s first resort, and the price is for the case in which an effort to resell has failed or would plainly fail. The reason is the one that governs the whole section: a seller who could resell the goods and also collect the full price would hold both the money and the merchandise. The test that separates the two situations is objective. The commentary explains that the Code replaced the former “not readily resalable” standard with an objective one, and that an action for the price under subsection (1)(b) “can be sustained only after a ‘reasonable effort to resell’ the goods ‘at reasonable price’ has actually been made or where the circumstances ‘reasonably indicate’ that such an effort will be unavailing.”13 The seller’s own conviction that nobody wants the goods therefore counts for nothing without a real effort or circumstances that make one pointless.
The statute attaches “reasonable” to the price as well as to the effort. A seller must show that it could not resell at a reasonable price, so a resale that would merely bring less than the contract price does not qualify, because that shortfall is exactly what damages cover. The requirement that the goods be identified to the contract ties the price to particular goods set aside for this buyer, which is where the earlier remedy of identifying finished goods or completing unfinished ones feeds into this one.
The standard illustration is a product made to one buyer’s specifications. In Precision Mirror & Glass v. Nelms, the seller had a glass tabletop made to the dimensions of the buyer’s table, and the buyer had created a pattern that captured the table’s exact shape. The court found it impracticable for the seller to locate another consumer who owned a table of those dimensions, noted that the buyer had not rebutted the absence of a resale market, and held that the seller had credibly established its right to recover the $584.33 owed on the contract.14 That is the circumstances branch of the statute at work: because the goods fit only one buyer, an effort to resell would be futile. The seller carries the burden of proving the lack of a resale market, since only the seller knows what market it faced and a remedy that departs from the damages rule should be proved by the party who invokes it.
Foxco Industries v. Fabric World shows who decides the question. The seller sued under both Section 2-708 and Section 2-709 for fabric the buyer had refused, and the district court left the jury to choose which measure fit the facts.15 The court of appeals observed that the statute’s test turns on reasonableness at every step, reasonable effort, reasonable price, and what the circumstances reasonably indicate, and it said it would reverse only if, as a matter of law, the jury could not have found that the seller was unable after reasonable effort to resell at a reasonable price or that an effort to resell would have been fruitless.16 A seller with some evidence of unresalability therefore ordinarily reaches the jury, and the jury’s answer stands unless the evidence is legally insufficient.
The fans and the tabletop differ in the one respect that matters: whether the goods fit only one buyer. A seller cannot substitute a different showing for that one. French v. Sotheby & Co. rejected the argument that title controls. Oklahoma’s earlier statute had let a seller recover the price once title passed to the buyer even though the seller kept the goods, and the court held that this was not the meaning or purpose of Section 2-709, which makes the passing of title immaterial and is intended to be exhaustive in listing the cases in which the price lies.17 The reason is practical. Title says who owns the goods, while the statute asks whether the seller who holds them has any realistic way to resell. A seller stuck with goods nobody else will buy is in the position the statute addresses even if title never moved, and a seller holding marketable goods can resell them even if title did move. A seller who sues for the price must therefore fit the facts into one of the two enumerated grounds, accepted goods or unresalable goods, and an argument that the buyer owns the goods supplies neither.
Holding Goods and Fallback Damages
Once a seller sues for the price, Section 2-709(2) governs what happens to the goods. The seller “must hold for the buyer any goods which have been identified to the contract and are still in his control,” except that if resale becomes possible it may resell them “at any time prior to the collection of the judgment.”19 The net proceeds of any such resale must be credited to the buyer, and payment of the judgment entitles the buyer to any goods not resold.20
The duty to hold exists because a price judgment asks the buyer for the whole contract sum and deducts nothing for the goods. A seller who collected that sum and also kept the goods would be paid twice for one performance. The commentary describes the section as making “the goods available for resale under the resale section, the seller’s primary remedy,” and, “in the special case in which resale is not practicable,” allowing “the action for the price which would then be necessary to give the seller the value of his contract.”21 Even where the price is a proper case, then, the judgment pays for goods the seller still controls, so those goods belong to the buyer who pays it. A seller that disposed of them in the meantime would break the exchange the judgment is meant to complete.
The exception for resale follows from what the price action assumed when it was brought. The unresalable-goods ground rests on a judgment made at one moment: that a reasonable effort to resell has failed or would be futile. Markets change, and a customer who could not be found at the time of suit may appear later. Rather than leave the goods idle while the buyer owes their full price, the statute lets the seller resell at any time before the judgment is collected, which includes the period after the judgment has been entered, and it protects the buyer with a credit for the net proceeds. The seller ends where performance would have left it, with the contract price in hand and no goods left over.
The duty to hold reaches only goods that are identified to the contract and still in the seller’s control. Goods the buyer has accepted sit in the buyer’s hands, so on the accepted-goods ground there is nothing for the seller to hold, and the duty matters chiefly where the seller claims the price of goods it could not resell.
Section 2-709(3) protects the seller whose price claim fails. After the buyer has wrongfully rejected or revoked acceptance of the goods, failed to make a payment due, or repudiated, a seller who is held not entitled to the price “shall nevertheless be awarded damages for nonacceptance” under Section 2-708.22 The qualifying breaches mirror the triggers that open the Section 2-703 menu, and Section 2-703(e) had already paired damages for nonacceptance with the price “in a proper case.”23 The fallback matters because whether a case is proper often turns on reasonableness questions that a trier of fact decides after the seller has chosen its theory. Without subsection (3), a seller who sued for the price and lost on resalability could forfeit a claim for a real loss. With it, a claim for the price is a bid for more than damages and costs the seller nothing it would otherwise have recovered.
Foxco, discussed above, shows both measures traveling together and shows that losing one does not close the other. The seller there had privately resold some of the goods without notice to the buyer, so it could not invoke the resale section and was limited to its remedies under Section 2-703(e), either Section 2-708 or Section 2-709.24 The buyer conceded that a Section 2-708 instruction was warranted, so the appeal asked only whether the evidence supported the price instruction.25 A footnote in the same opinion distinguishes French v. Sotheby & Co. on the ground that the Foxco seller, unlike the seller in French, had presented evidence permitting a finding that the tests of Section 2-709(1)(b) were met.26 A defective resale thus costs the seller the resale measure and leaves the price claim to be decided on the evidence of unresalability.