Concept
Resale and Resale Damages
Aggrieved seller's remedies when the buyer breaches
Resale and Resale Damages
A buyer’s breach leaves the seller holding goods that were committed to a sale that no longer exists, and Section 2-703(d) lets the seller sell them again: the aggrieved seller may “resell and recover damages as hereafter provided (Section 2-706).”1 That clause does two things. It authorizes a sale to someone other than the breaching buyer, and it attaches a damages claim against that buyer, leaving the details of both to Section 2-706. Like every other item on the Section 2-703 menu, the remedy opens only when the buyer wrongfully rejects or revokes acceptance, fails to make a payment due on or before delivery, or repudiates. It then reaches the goods directly affected by the breach and, if the breach goes to the whole contract, the undelivered balance.2
The substitute sale gives the seller’s loss a concrete figure. The seller does not have to estimate what the goods were worth, because it sells them, and the gap between what the contract promised and what the resale brought becomes the claim against the first buyer.
The seller may resell but need not. A seller is not required to resell after a buyer’s breach,3 and a seller who prefers another path, such as damages for nonacceptance or, in a proper case, an action for the price, keeps those remedies on the menu; later sections take them up.4 A seller who does resell controls the sale, while the buyer pays the difference. For that reason the statute conditions the remedy on how the sale is conducted. The first subsection below takes up those conditions, and the second works through the damages a conforming resale yields.
Conducting a Proper Resale
Section 2-706 attaches conditions to the privilege that Section 2-703(d) grants.5 The central one sits in Section 2-706(1): where the resale is made “in good faith and in a commercially reasonable manner,” the seller may recover the difference between the resale price and the contract price, plus incidental damages, less expenses saved because of the buyer’s breach.6 A resale that meets that standard fixes the seller’s recovery, a calculation the next subsection works through. The question here comes first: what must a resale look like before it supports any recovery at all? The statute answers with three conditions, which are good faith, commercial reasonableness in every aspect of the sale, and notice to the buyer.
Each condition answers a different danger. The seller controls every feature of the sale, while the absent buyer pays the difference between the contract price and whatever the sale brings. A seller indifferent to the outcome could dump the goods cheaply, perhaps to a friendly purchaser, and bill the buyer for the seller’s own carelessness. Good faith and commercial reasonableness answer that danger, and they double as a mitigation rule, because a seller held to those standards must make reasonable attempts to keep the loss down.7 Notice answers a different danger. A buyer who learns of the resale in advance can protest the plan, point the seller toward a better purchaser, or, at a public sale, attend and bid, and each of those steps can hold down the sum the buyer will owe. The standards stay flexible by design, since the remedy is meant to be free of legalistic restrictions and to let the seller follow reasonable commercial practice in realizing as high a price as the circumstances allow.8
Steps three and four decide most disputes, and they behave differently. Commercial reasonableness reaches the method, manner, time, place, and terms of the sale alike, and the resale may be either public, as at an auction, or private.13 The standard carries no stopwatch. An official comment explains that a reasonable time for resale “depends upon the nature of the goods, the condition of the market and the other circumstances of the case; its length cannot be measured by any legal yardstick.”14 One court found thirty days from the breach a commercially reasonable time to resell securities, but a fast-spoiling commodity may call for a sale within days and a one-of-a-kind object may justify months of patience. A student who memorizes a fixed number of days has memorized a rule that does not exist.
Notice is the condition a seller can most easily lose, and the statute sorts resales into two kinds for this purpose. If the resale is private, such as a negotiated sale to a single purchaser, the seller must give the buyer reasonable notification of its intention to resell. If the resale is public, the buyer must receive reasonable notice of the time and place of the sale.15 The difference tracks what each kind of sale lets the buyer do. A buyer told that a private sale is coming can object or propose a purchaser, and a buyer told the time and place of an auction can attend and bid. The dispute between Foxco and Fabric World shows what skipping the step costs. After Fabric World’s breach, Foxco privately sold some of the goods without notice to Fabric World, and the court agreed that Foxco could not invoke Section 2-706. Foxco was limited to the remedies of Sections 2-708 and 2-709.16
A seller that handles the process carefully shows the other side of the line. In Sotheby’s, Inc. v. Nature Morte LLC, the defendants did not pay for a work bought at auction, and the auction house resold it. The court recited the rule that a seller must give reasonable notice of its intention to resell when the resale is private. It then found that the buyer received notice of the resale, that he offered no expert evidence against the conclusion on the work’s fair market value at the time of resale, and that the defendants had up to five months after the auction to meet their payment obligations. On those facts the court held that Sotheby’s resold with reasonable notice and in a commercially reasonable manner.17 Each fact lines up against one of the dangers above: the notice and the long wait gave the buyer every chance to object or pay, and the unrebutted valuation answered any claim that the price reflected a careless sale.
A resale that fails the notice condition cannot support recovery under Section 2-706, but the seller’s other remedies survive. In Foxco’s case the fallback was the market-price and price measures, which later sections develop.18 A seller who intends to resell should therefore settle the notice question before the sale and not after it.
Measuring Resale Damages
Once a resale satisfies the conditions above, Section 2-706 fixes the seller’s recovery at the difference between the contract price and the resale price, together with incidental damages, less the expenses the seller saved because of the buyer’s breach.20 The statute words the first term as the difference between the resale price and the contract price, and in the ordinary case the contract price is the larger figure, so the working calculation subtracts the resale price from the contract price.21 Each of the three terms has its own job, and together they aim at one result: the seller should end up roughly where full performance would have left it.
Performance would have brought the seller the contract price. After a proper resale the seller already holds the resale price from the second buyer, so the gap between the two figures is the part of the bargain still missing, and charging that gap to the breaching buyer closes it. Incidental damages cover costs the breach added to the seller’s side of the ledger, such as the reasonable charges for caring for and keeping the goods after the buyer’s breach.22 Those costs would never have arisen had the buyer taken delivery, so leaving them with the seller would put the seller below performance. The last term runs the other way. A seller incurs some costs, such as freight to the buyer’s door, only by performing, and a seller spared them by the breach is better off than performance would have left it. The statute subtracts those savings, and without the subtraction the formula would overcompensate.
The simplest illustration uses a $1,000 contract. The buyer repudiates, the seller resells the goods for $800, and the seller recovers the $200 difference plus incidental damages, less any expenses saved because of the breach.23 The two adjustments change the answer once real costs enter the picture.
Real cases apply the same arithmetic at larger scale. In Sotheby’s v. Nature Morte, the contract price was $6,537,500 and the resale, which the court found proper, brought $4,400,000. The court awarded $1,508,750, which is the $2,137,500 gap less $628,750 for a profit-share payment obligation that the resale eliminated.24 The opinion treats that deduction as its own item, but its logic resembles the saved-expenses term. A cost the completed sale would have placed on the seller, and that the resale removed, is a benefit the breach conferred, and leaving it with the seller would put the seller ahead of performance.
The formula also leaves out what the seller paid for the goods. In Apex v. Sharing World, the court stated that a seller who resells under Section 2-706, claims market-price damages, or sues for the price does not have to prove its own cost for the goods.25 The reason lies in the structure of the formula. Resale damages compare a price fixed by the contract with a price fixed by the resale, and the seller’s acquisition cost appears in neither. The contract price already states what the seller bargained to receive, so a seller who bought cheaply and one who bought dearly have the same claim for the same price gap. The lost-profit measure taken up in a later section works differently, because it is built on the seller’s profit and expressly allows for costs the seller reasonably incurred.26
A resale above the contract price produces no resale damages and no accounting to the buyer. Section 2-706(6) provides that the seller is not accountable to the buyer for any profit made on a resale.27 In the formula, a resale price above the contract price leaves no shortfall to charge to the buyer, and the buyer has no claim on the surplus. In the dispute between Hessel and Christie’s, the court drew that consequence in the auction house’s favor, noting that Christie’s was not accountable to Hessel for any profit made on a resale.28 In Peace River Seed Co-operative v. Proseeds Marketing, the court applied Oregon’s version of the same rule. It noted that a seller who resold for $0.03 per pound above the contract price would come out that far ahead, a result the UCC explicitly allows.29 The explanation is that the resale is the seller’s own transaction. The comments describe the seller as reselling “in his own behalf, for his own benefit and for the purpose of fixing his damages.”30 A buyer who refused the goods has no claim to what the seller later does with them, and the measure asks only what the breach cost the seller.
The formula applies only if the seller chooses resale, and once the seller does, the measure follows that choice. In Modern Machinery v. Flathead County, the trial court instructed the jury that it “may award any of the following” measures of damages. On appeal the instruction was held to misstate the UCC, because the Code’s measures are mandatory and state the amount recoverable according to the remedy the seller has pursued.31 The Oregon court in Peace River added that the duty to mitigate does not force a seller who never resold into the resale measure. A seller that resold may also look to market-price damages, a question the sections on damages for nonacceptance take up.32