Concept
Remedies Against the Goods
Aggrieved seller's remedies when the buyer breaches
Remedies Against the Goods
The first three items on the Section 2-703 menu act on the goods themselves. After a qualifying buyer breach, the aggrieved seller may withhold delivery of the affected goods, stop delivery by a bailee (a carrier or warehouse that holds goods for someone else), and proceed under the next section respecting goods still unidentified to the contract.1 Each is a step the seller takes on its own initiative, with no judgment to win first. The damages and price remedies that follow turn the broken deal into a money claim; these three change what happens to the goods before any claim is made.
All three assume that the seller still has some control over the goods, so the first question in any problem is where the goods are. A seller can withhold only what it holds, can stop only what a bailee holds, and can deal with unidentified goods only while they remain unfinished or uncommitted to this buyer. The subsections below follow the goods in that order: in the seller's hands, in a carrier's hands, and not yet made or not yet tied to the contract.
The reason for these self-help powers lies in what a buyer's breach does to the seller's exposure. A buyer who has refused to take or pay for goods has shown that further performance is a risk. Delivering to that buyer, or manufacturing more goods for that buyer, adds to what the seller stands to lose. Each remedy stops that exposure from growing and keeps the goods within the seller's reach, which preserves later choices such as resale.
Withholding delivery comes first because it is the simplest of the three and the one most often combined with the others. The next two subsections follow the goods out of the seller's hands and back toward the production floor.
Withholding Delivery
Section 2-703(a) of the Uniform Commercial Code gives the aggrieved seller the simplest remedy on the menu: the seller may “withhold delivery of such goods.”2 “Such goods” reaches back to the lead-in of Section 2-703, which covers the goods directly affected by the buyer's breach and, when the breach is of the whole contract, the whole undelivered balance.3 The lead-in also fixes the trigger. The buyer must have wrongfully rejected or revoked acceptance, failed to make a payment due on or before delivery, or repudiated. A seller who holds goods back from a buyer who has done none of those things has no remedy to point to, and the refusal may itself be a breach.
Delivery trades the goods for a promise. A seller who delivers to a buyer in default gives up the goods and keeps only a claim for payment, while a seller who withholds keeps the goods available for resale, damages, or any later step. The cost is the burden of holding them. The remedy also asks nothing of the buyer, because the seller need only stop performing.
In Robert C. Eldred Co. v. Acevedo, a telephone bidder won two watercolors and sent a check, then stopped payment on it when he learned that the auctioneer would hold the pictures until the check cleared. The auctioneer shipped them anyway. The bidder refused delivery and argued that the hold had been a breach of contract.4 The court disagreed, noting that a jury could find the postponement consistent with both the terms of sale and common practice in auction sales.5 The case shows a hold from the buyer's side: a buyer who has not made good on payment cannot recast the seller's patience as the seller's breach.
In Hessel v. Christie's, Inc., the buyer had not paid in full. The court held that he did not have title to the paintings and was in breach, and that under its conditions of sale Christie's could charge reasonable interest, cancel the sale, and resell.6 Hessel shows where an unpaid buyer's default can lead once the seller moves past the hold to the remedies that follow.
Two things separate the yard's two positions: when the payment fell due and where the boards were. Withholding is a remedy for goods the seller still controls, so a seller whose goods have been delivered and accepted must turn to the action for the price or to damages, which later subsections take up.
Withholding seldom ends a dispute. The held goods still belong to a broken contract, so the seller usually goes on to resell and recover damages, to recover damages for nonacceptance or in a proper case the price, or to cancel.7 Withholding holds the seller's position while the seller chooses among them.
Stopping Delivery by a Bailee
Section 2-703(b) gives the aggrieved seller the next item on the menu, the power to “stop delivery by any bailee as hereafter provided (Section 2-705).”9 A bailee is a third party that holds goods for someone else, such as a carrier moving them or a warehouse storing them. The remedy shares the lead-in of every other item in Section 2-703, so it opens only after a qualifying buyer breach and reaches the goods directly affected by that breach and, when the breach is of the whole contract, the whole undelivered balance.10
The remedy follows the goods wherever they happen to be. Withholding assumes that the seller holds the goods, but a seller who has handed them to a carrier no longer does, even though they have not reached the buyer. In that gap the seller cannot keep the goods and the buyer does not yet have them. Stopping delivery carries the protection of withholding across the gap. The exposure that justifies withholding is delivery to a party who has already failed to perform, and that exposure lasts until the goods arrive. Without this remedy, a seller's position would turn on whether the truck left the dock before or after the buyer defaulted, although both sellers face the same defaulting buyer.
The grant does not stop at the words of Subsection (b). It adds “as hereafter provided” and points to Section 2-705, which assigns the conditions and procedure for stopping goods, and this unit does not set that section out. Because the bailee is a third party to the sale, the mechanics of reaching it get their own section. What Section 2-703(b) establishes is the seller's entitlement, which depends on a qualifying breach and on a bailee holding the goods. On an exam, state the remedy, tie it to the breach, and note that its mechanics come from the cross-referenced section.11
The location of the goods when the seller acts therefore sorts the first two remedies. A seller holding the goods withholds them. A seller whose goods sit with a carrier or warehouse stops delivery. A seller whose goods have reached the buyer has neither option. Like withholding, stopping delivery is a stopgap: it keeps the goods from reaching a buyer who has broken the contract and leaves the seller free to choose among the remaining remedies.
Identifying Goods to the Contract
Section 2-703(c) gives the aggrieved seller a third remedy aimed at the goods, and it works by cross-reference: the seller may “proceed under the next section respecting goods still unidentified to the contract.”13 Goods are identified to a contract when they have been designated as the particular goods that contract covers. Until then, a seller's inventory, raw materials, and work in progress remain available to any buyer. The next section is Section 2-704, and it supplies the substance of the remedy. It lets a seller whose buyer has broken the contract keep acting on the goods, so that they end up in a condition the later remedies can reach instead of freezing at the moment of breach.14
For finished goods the rule is direct. The aggrieved seller may identify to the contract any conforming finished goods in its possession or control, regardless of their resalability.15 The closing phrase removes an obstacle the seller might otherwise face, because the seller need not show that a second buyer exists before treating the goods as the contract's goods. The reason is sequence. Identification makes the goods available for resale and keeps open the action for the price if resale fails. Whether the goods can in fact be resold is a question the later remedies answer: an action for the price can be sustained only after a reasonable effort to resell at a reasonable price has actually been made, or where the circumstances reasonably indicate that the effort would be unavailing.16 A rule that made identification wait on that answer would ask the seller to know, at the moment of breach, something it can learn only by trying.
The identification rule also departs from the approach that came before it. Under the Uniform Sales Act, a repudiating buyer was liable for no greater damages than the seller would have suffered by doing nothing toward carrying out the contract after notice of the repudiation.17 That position rested on the seller's duty to mitigate, and in practice it pushed a seller to stop work the moment the buyer backed out. A seller holding nearly finished goods could be penalized for finishing them, which was unfair and economically wasteful. Section 2-704 removes that pressure. It lets the seller identify or complete the goods and then asks whether the seller acted reasonably.
Unfinished goods call for judgment, and the statute supplies a standard. In the exercise of reasonable commercial judgment, for the purposes of avoiding loss and of effective realization, the seller may take any of three courses: complete the manufacture and wholly identify the goods to the contract, cease manufacture and resell for scrap or salvage value, or proceed in any other reasonable manner.18 The first two sit at opposite ends. Completion makes sense when the work is largely done and the finished goods will bring more than the partial goods, while salvage makes sense when finishing would only add cost. The third course lets the seller adopt another commercially sensible approach that neither describes. The seller has an express power to complete the goods unless reasonable commercial judgment, on the facts as they appear when the seller learns of the breach, makes it clear that completion will materially increase the damages.19 The test looks to the facts at that moment, so the seller is judged on what it knew then and not on hindsight. The same test restrains the seller, who cannot run up the buyer's liability by finishing goods that plainly should have been stopped.
In Foxco Industries, Ltd. v. Fabric World, Inc., the jury found that Foxco acted in a commercially reasonable manner when it decided to process to a conclusion the manufacture of the already substantially completed Fabric World order, and Foxco was then entitled to the appropriate seller's breach-of-contract remedy.20 The same opinion repeats the limit on the price remedy: an action for the price can be sustained only after a reasonable effort to resell at a reasonable price has actually been made, or where the circumstances reasonably indicate that the effort would be unavailing.21 The case shows how identification and completion feed the money remedies that come next.
The fabric seller and the cabinet shop faced the same repudiation, and the fact that separates them is how much work remained. Where manufacture was substantially complete, finishing protected the value already invested. Where it had barely begun, finishing would only have enlarged the loss. The exam question is therefore never whether the seller may finish in the abstract. It is whether finishing was reasonable on the facts known when the seller learned of the breach.
Identification also sets the stage for what follows. Once the seller has identified finished goods or completed unfinished ones, the seller is positioned to recover money damages from the buyer.22 The goods are available for resale and, if resale proves impracticable, for the action for the price.