Concept
Obligor Breach Versus Obligee Breach
Remedies when the obligee breaches an accord
Obligor Breach Versus Obligee Breach
An accord can fail from either side, and Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 281 gives each failure its own rule. When the obligor breaches the accord in a way that discharges the obligee's new duty to accept the substitute, the obligee may enforce either the original duty or any duty under the accord.1 When the obligee breaches, the original duty is not discharged, and the obligor may sue for specific performance of the accord in addition to any claim for damages for partial breach.2 The two rules mirror each other, so the first question in a failed-accord problem is not which remedy fits but who failed to do what the accord required.
The obligor-breach rule follows from the suspension described earlier. Until the accord is performed, the original duty is suspended, and the obligee must take the substitute when it comes. That arrangement presupposes that the substitute will come. Once the obligor's default is serious enough to discharge the obligee's duty to accept it, the suspension ends and the original duty is available again.3 Contract law supports this result with a rebuttable presumption that the parties intended the obligee to be able to pursue the original amount, because an obligee would not accept a mere promise of $425 in place of an existing promise of $450. The obligee gives up the right to $450 only for an actual payment of $425.4 Because the presumption is rebuttable, the parties' actual intent can displace it.
Brandt, not Okafor, chooses between the two duties. That choice opens only when the default is serious. Short of a breach that discharges the obligee's duty to accept the substitute, the original duty stays suspended and the obligee remains bound to take the performance.5 The general law of breach supplies a measuring stick. A total breach discharges the nonbreaching party, who may refuse to perform and may recover future damages as well as accrued ones. A partial breach leaves the nonbreaching party bound and yields damages only for harm already suffered.6 Those definitions come from breach doctrine generally, not from the accord rule, but they frame the argument: is the obligor's default serious enough that the obligee should no longer have to accept the substitute?
The obligee-breach rule runs the other way. When the obligee breaches the accord, the original duty is not discharged, and the obligor may sue for specific performance of the accord and add a claim for damages for partial breach.7
The remedies differ because each side bargained for something different. The original duty is a burden on the obligor and a right in the obligee, so reviving it helps only the obligee. An obligee whose obligor never pays agreed to set the original right aside only in exchange for a performance that never came, and the original right returns. An obligor whose obligee refuses to accept has no use for a revived burden. That obligor lacks the release the accord promised, and specific performance of the accord supplies it. Each remedy protects what its holder bargained for: the obligee's original claim against an obligor who does not pay, and the obligor's release against an obligee who will not accept.
Do not skip the second step. An unpaid debt after the due date says nothing about who broke the accord. The same unpaid $450 falls under § 281(2) if the obligor withheld payment and under § 281(3) if the obligee refused to take it.