Concept
What an Accord Is
Remedies when the obligee breaches an accord
Obligee's Breach of an Accord
What an Accord Is
An accord is a contract in which an obligee promises to accept a stated performance in satisfaction of the obligor's existing duty. When the accord is performed, the original duty is discharged.1 Two role labels carry the vocabulary. The obligor owes the existing duty, such as a debtor who owes $450. The obligee is the person to whom it is owed, such as the creditor waiting for that $450. This chapter holds those labels fixed.
Because an accord is a contract, it needs consideration like any other. A disputed debt supplies it easily. The obligor agrees to pay more than the obligor thinks is owed, the obligee agrees to take less than the obligee thinks is owed, and each side gives something up.2 The running example uses exactly that setting, a $450 debt settled for $425.
The July 1 agreement and the August 1 payment are separate events, and keeping them apart is the most important move in this chapter. The accord is the promise to accept a substitute. The satisfaction is the substitute actually rendered and accepted, and performance of the accord is what discharges the original duty.3 The word "executory" is sometimes added to the label to underscore that the accord itself does not discharge the duty.4 So between July 1 and August 1, Okafor's $450 duty remains undischarged. If Okafor delivers the check on August 1 and Brandt cashes it, the executory accord ripens into an accord and satisfaction. It is then too late for Brandt to change course and recover the extra $25, because the accord and satisfaction is a defense to that claim.5 The rest of this chapter asks what each party may do if the accord breaks down in the interval between those two dates.
The label "executory accord" also carries a trace of legal history. An older view held that an unperformed accord was no defense to an action on the underlying duty. That view is now generally rejected.6 The next section takes up what effect an unperformed accord does have.
Students often treat any talk of settlement as an accord, but an accord has two required features. The obligee must make a promise, and the promise must be to accept a stated performance in satisfaction of the duty. The test is whether the obligee actually promised something definite.