Concept
The Timing Requirement
Discharge of repudiation damages by later impracticability or frustration
The Timing Requirement
Section 254(2) closes with a clause about timing. The repudiator is discharged only if the later event shows that the repudiated duty would have been discharged by impracticability or frustration “before any breach by non-performance.”1 That phrase involves two different breaches, and they fall at different points on the calendar. A repudiation comes first: a party manifests, before the time for performance, that it will not perform when the date arrives. A breach by non-performance comes only after the time for performance has arrived and the party fails to perform.2
Take a lease under which a security deposit is due July 15 and possession is due August 1. A lessee that tells the lessor on July 2 that it no longer intends to lease the premises has repudiated. Yet the lessee cannot be in breach for failing to pay the deposit before July 15, and the lessor cannot be in breach for withholding possession before August 1.3 Every repudiation therefore precedes the due date, and the due date is the earliest moment at which a breach by non-performance can occur. The clause asks one question: did the excusing event land before that moment?
The answer matters because of what each branch leaves standing. An event that lands before the due date discharges the repudiated duty before it could be breached. It also discharges the other party, because the excused performance will not be forthcoming.4 The damages claim for that performance falls with the duty. An event that lands after the due date finds the promisor already at the point of performing or defaulting, and a default there is a breach by non-performance that the later event does not excuse.
The second branch of the illustration finds support in the law of contributory fault. A seller who is to deliver specific goods on February 1 and fails without good cause to do so cannot invoke impracticability when the goods are destroyed afterward.5 The sequence is the one the clause screens out: a due performance left undone, then an excusing event.
A continuing contract, which calls for performance over a span of time, applies the comparison one performance at a time. Suppose a disc jockey is engaged to play at a Las Vegas casino for 2019 and 2020. Near the end of 2019 the casino goes out of business and repudiates its 2020 obligation. It concedes the breach but denies liability for damages from March 2020 forward. The governor issued a shutdown order that month because of the Covid pandemic, and the contract's force majeure clause relieved both parties of damages liability if performance was “rendered impossible.”6 A court facing similar facts in 2021 did not decide the issue outright. It denied the disc jockey's motion for summary judgment, reasoning that a jury could find that the shutdown order triggered the clause, and it applied the Restatement (Second) rule that a repudiator's damages duty is discharged if it appears after the repudiation that the duty would have been discharged. On the assumption that the casino paid for 2019 and that the clause would excuse it as of March 2020, it would owe no 2020 damages beyond that date.7
The qualifier “beyond that date” carries the timing rule. A performance that would have fallen due after the shutdown would have been discharged before any breach by non-performance could occur. A performance that would have fallen due earlier in 2020 came due while the casino's duty still stood, so the order arrives too late to reach it. The next section takes up the damages cutoff.
Students often read the clause to say that any earlier breach defeats the excuse: a repudiator has breached, so a repudiator can never rely on a later event. The text refutes that reading. The rule begins from a total breach by repudiation and then allows discharge, which would be impossible if repudiation alone barred it.8 What blocks the excuse is a breach by non-performance, a failure to render a duty that had already fallen due. A repudiation announces that such a failure is coming, and the damages claim for it looks ahead to that failure. A later event showing that the failure could never have occurred corrects the forecast. A missed due date is different. Once a duty that was due goes unperformed, the breach is complete, and the later destruction of the goods does not excuse it.9