Concept
Voidable Contracts
Restitution interest
Voidable Contracts
A voidable contract is one that a party may undo by exercising a power of avoidance, and the party who does so is entitled to restitution for any benefit conferred on the other side by part performance or reliance. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 376 names the grounds: lack of capacity, mistake, misrepresentation, duress, undue influence, and abuse of a fiduciary relation.1 Restitution is most commonly sought in this setting, and in the statute-of-frauds setting of the preceding section, because the contract is avoided or unenforceable and not because a fully enforceable contract was breached. The party who performed may claim the benefits or their value even though she may not enforce the contract.2 Avoidance differs from the Statute of Frauds cases in how it arises: the party holding the power undoes the agreement because of something that went wrong in forming it, such as a minor's lack of capacity, deception or pressure, or a basic mistake.
This section assumes the avoidance is valid. Whether a particular minor, mistaken party, or coerced party has a good ground belongs to the formation defenses, and the question here is what follows once the contract has been avoided. Two questions organize the rest: what the avoiding party may recover and must give back, and how a court resolves doubt about the size of the benefit when the other side's own misconduct produced the avoidance. The dollar measure of a restitution award is the work of the measuring section later in this chapter.
Restoring Benefits on Avoidance
Avoidance removes the reason either side had to keep what the other delivered. While the contract stood, it explained why each party could hold the other's performance. Once a party with a valid ground avoids, that explanation is gone, and each side holds the other's performance with nothing in the agreement to justify it. Restitution answers that situation. The comment to § 376 applies the rule to avoidance on any ground, so the listed grounds are examples and the remedy does not change with the ground the avoiding party proves.3 The claim does not require misconduct by the recipient, because a defendant is generally liable to restore a benefit that would be unjust for him to keep even if he gained it honestly.4
The benefit that counts is wider than the item or sum first delivered. The comment says the benefit from part performance includes what results from the other party's use of whatever it received, measured up to the time the thing is returned on avoidance.5 A party who delivered goods or land and then avoids can therefore reach the value the other side drew from them in the meantime.
Recovery runs in both directions, because avoidance undoes the exchange for both sides. Under § 384, as the comment explains, a party seeking restitution must generally return any benefit that party received.6 Restoring only one side would leave the avoiding party holding both the other's performance and the price paid, which is the double recovery restitution exists to prevent. Courts state the idea in the maxim that he who seeks equity must do equity.7 The Restatement's illustration of an infant buyer shows the mechanism. An infant buys an automobile for $2,000, takes delivery, and pays, then disaffirms on the ground of infancy, tenders the automobile back, and recovers the $2,000.8 The tender makes the recovery fair. An infant who disaffirmed yet kept the car would hold both the vehicle and the seller's money, while the infant who hands the car back leaves each side where it started. The comment qualifies the return requirement with the word generally and notes that other sections supplement the rule for mental incompetency and for mistake.9
Mistake produces the same result on different facts. In the Restatement's timber illustration, a seller conveys a tract for $100,000 and the buyer pays, both believing the timber that gave the land its value was still standing when fire had destroyed it. The buyer discovers the mistake, disaffirms, tenders a deed back, and recovers the $100,000.10 Recovery of the price and tender of the land are two halves of one unwinding. Services differ only in what is handed back. A contractor submits a $150,000 bid after inadvertently omitting $50,000 from a column of figures, and the owner had reason to know of the error because the other bids ran from $180,000 to $200,000. The contractor discovers the mistake after doing part of the work, disaffirms, and recovers the reasonable value of the performance, with the cost of the work under the next-lowest bid as evidence of that value.11 Labor cannot be returned, so the recovery takes the form of money measured by the benefit the owner received.
The mutual-restoration condition does its most detailed work when the avoiding party received land and improved it. The comment says such a party, on avoidance and return of the land, may recover the reasonable value of the improvements under § 371(b), which looks to the extent that the other party's property has been increased in value.12 A decision on a rescinded land sale shows how the pieces fit. Buyers rescinded because of a mistake and sought both their down payment and the $229,649.84 they had spent developing the land. The court held they could rescind and recover restitution, but it set out a specific accounting and refused the full development outlay.13 The accounting can be run in order:
Each term of that arithmetic has its own reason. The down payment returns money paid for a performance the sellers can no longer keep. The enhancement term applies because the sellers get back land worth more than the land they conveyed, and keeping that increase without paying for it would enrich them at the buyers' expense. The rental deduction applies because a buyer who recovers the whole price while keeping a free period of occupancy has profited from a transaction that was supposed to be undone. The fifth step is the one students most often miss. The court refused the $229,649.84 because awarding it would shift the entire risk of the mistake onto the sellers, which is incompatible with equitable rescission.14 Rescission unwinds a bargain that went wrong through mistake. It does not make the other party the insurer of everything the claimant spent, and restitution reaches only the extent to which a benefit was actually conferred.15
The infant and the land buyers stand under the same rule but reach different arithmetic, and the difference lies in what each did with the thing received. The infant returned the automobile as delivered and recovered the price alone. The land buyers returned land they had both occupied and improved, so the accounting had to add the improvement the sellers now hold and subtract the occupancy the buyers enjoyed. When the thing comes back as it went out, the award is the price; when the avoiding party has changed or used it, the award adjusts for the change. The next subsection takes up what changes when the other side's own misconduct caused the avoidance.
Misconduct and Uncertain Measurement
The comment to § 376 adds a rule about proof: uncertainties in measuring the benefit are more likely to be resolved in favor of the party seeking restitution when the other party engaged in misconduct, as in cases of fraudulent misrepresentation, duress, or undue influence.17 The preceding subsection settled what an avoiding party recovers and what it must give back. This rule operates afterward, when a court has to put a dollar figure on a benefit. Few benefits conferred under a failed contract can be priced exactly, because the value of services, of a period of occupancy, or of an improvement is an estimate, and every estimate leaves a range from which the court must pick a number. The comment tells the court which way to lean within that range when the recipient is the party who did wrong.
Someone must carry the risk that the chosen figure is off, and the rule allocates that risk to the party whose misconduct produced the avoidance. The rule has a counterpart on the other side of a fraudulent deal. The perpetrator's own restitutionary rights are limited: any doubts about the value of the perpetrator's performance are resolved against the perpetrator, and the victim need not return property or its value to the extent that it was worthless when received or deteriorated because of its own defects.18 Where the recipient did nothing wrong, as when both sides share an honest mistake, the rule supplies no ground for leaning on the recipient, so the court measures the benefit conferred and stops there.
The Restatement's farming illustration shows that misconduct can affect more than the estimate. A fraudulently induces B to sell a tract of land for $100,000. After B has conveyed and A has paid, A farms the land at a net profit of $10,000. B discovers the fraud, disaffirms for misrepresentation, tenders back the $100,000, and sues for specific restitution plus the profit, and B recovers the land and the $10,000.19 The $10,000 is what A made from the land, and the illustration does not measure it by any loss to B. Courts of equity have long required wrongdoers to restore ill-gotten gains so that they do not profit by their wrongdoing.20 The recovery remains a return of gain and never becomes a penalty. Equity is not punitive, so the measure of recovery is limited to the benefits received, and punitive damages, which a court may award on a tort claim for fraudulent inducement, are generally unavailable in equity through restitution.21
The timber illustration from the previous subsection supplies the contrast. There the buyer avoids and recovers the $100,000 price, and both sides had believed the timber was still standing.22 Each who avoids recovers what was conferred and gives back what was received, so the defrauded seller and the mistaken buyer stand under one rule. No one in the timber sale did wrong, however, so a court has no reason to lean against the seller, and there is no wrongdoer's profit for restitution to reach. The court measures the benefit conferred with no thumb on the scale.
The lean toward the claimant concerns doubt about the size of a benefit, and the benefit requirement itself stays in place. Restitution is available only to the extent that the claimant conferred a benefit by part performance or reliance, and the rule on misconduct does not enlarge that category.23 The Restatement's improvement illustration shows the ordinary measure still working in a fraud case. A fraudulently induces B to buy a tract for $100,000, and B improves the land with work of a reasonable value of $20,000. B discovers the fraud, disaffirms, tenders a deed, and sues for $100,000 plus $20,000, less $5,000, the value to B of the use of the land, and B recovers $115,000.24 Fraud did not strip A of credit for B's use of the land, because avoidance still undoes the exchange in both directions. Suppose the evidence left it unclear whether B's work added $14,000 or $20,000 to the land's value. A's misconduct would make the higher figure the more likely finding. If the work added nothing, no lean toward the claimant can create a benefit that A never received.