Concept
Limits on Rescission
Rescission
Limits on Rescission
Proving a ground for rescission begins a rescission case without finishing it. A party who shows mistake, misrepresentation, or another ground has shown a reason to unmake the contract. Rescission is distinct from the restitution that follows it, and the restitution is what matters remedially.1 Three limits decide whether the unmaking goes forward. The first concerns time and conduct: a party who learns of the defect and then waits, or acts as though the contract stands, may lose the right to rescind. The second is equity's own question, whether the remedy is justified, which a court may answer no even where a significant mistake exists. The third is practical, because rescission needs both sides to be able to give back what they received.
Delay and Affirmance
A plaintiff with a ground for rescission often holds a choice of remedies, such as a choice between rescission and damages.2 The law is slow to hold a plaintiff to that choice. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 378 provides that a manifestation of a choice of one remedy, by bringing suit or otherwise, is no bar to another remedy unless the remedies are inconsistent and the other party materially changes position in reliance on the manifestation.3
Both conditions apply with force to a party who keeps performing after learning of a defect. Rescission avoids the contract, so it is inconsistent with holding the other side to it, and a party who goes on performing acts as though the contract stands. The words 'or otherwise' in § 378 reach that conduct, so no lawsuit is needed to make a choice. When the other side then materially changes position in reliance, the choice binds. A party who only waits meets a separate bar. Commentary on the tort action for damages lists both results: a plaintiff may be barred from rescission by delay, or may have so far committed himself that he has lost the remedy by an election.4
Delay carries its own requirement. Any claim for rescission is subject to the requirement that the purchaser take prompt action if she wishes to avoid the contract.5 The requirement fits the remedy. Rescission aims to put both sides back where they began, so the longer the purchaser waits, the more the other side may have done in reliance on the contract, and the more the purchaser looks like someone waiting to see whether the deal pays.
Students tend to find the misrepresentation and stop, as though a ground settled the matter. The ground opens the door; the buyer's conduct after discovery decides whether the door stays open.
Equitable Discretion
Even a plaintiff who proves a significant mistake may leave court without rescission. In a case involving Mr. and Mrs. Pickles, the court acknowledged the significance of the mistake the parties made and still reversed the Court of Appeals, because it concluded that equity did not justify the remedy the Pickleses sought.9 The court began from the premise that rescission is an equitable remedy,10 and that premise explains the result: a court asked for an equitable remedy decides whether equity justifies it on the facts before it.
A rescission claim therefore poses two questions in sequence. The first is whether a ground exists, which the earlier sections of this chapter address. The second is whether equity justifies unwinding this transaction, and a yes to the first does not answer it.
The general law of remedies shows the same restraint. Courts have a general preference for the damages remedy and may limit a plaintiff to damages even when the plaintiff would benefit from, and would prefer, a coercive remedy such as specific performance.11 The passage uses specific performance as its example, but its lesson carries over: a plaintiff's preference does not settle which remedy a court will give.
The plaintiff's own care at formation enters at this stage, and the rule is forgiving. A failure to investigate thoroughly before signing does not preclude rescission where the risk of the mistake was not allocated among the parties and the mistake is material and relates to a basic assumption on which the contract was made.12 A footnote in one decision states the rule in a dispute over a water supply and rests it on Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 152 comment a. The rule is conditional. The claimant must show that the risk was not allocated, that the mistake is material, and that it goes to a basic assumption. Where the parties did allocate the risk, the rule does not by its terms protect the claimant.
Inability to Restore
A defrauded party who cannot return the property received from the wrongdoer may be denied rescission. If the property has passed to a third person, for example, rescission may not be allowed, as Restatement (Third) of Restitution and Unjust Enrichment § 66 recognizes.15 The limit follows from the way the remedy works. Both sides give back whatever they received from the other, to the extent a return is feasible, so rescission requires that a reasonably complete restoration of performance be possible between both parties.16
The requirement protects the defendant. A refund of the price without a return of the property would leave the defendant worse off than before the deal, and the return of the property is what keeps rescission even-handed.
The standard is reasonable completeness, not perfection, so a shortfall does not always end the claim. Restoration can be supplemented by awards of incidental damages that make up for value that cannot be fully returned, or that reflect costs the defrauded party incurred in reliance on the transaction.17 A buyer deceived about a house who still holds it can hand it back, so both sides can be restored and rescission stays open. A buyer who has conveyed the house to a stranger has nothing to hand back, and a court may refuse to unwind the deal.
When restoration is the obstacle, damages often fit better. The tort action lets the plaintiff keep what was received and recover damages, and the commentary identifies the cases in which that advantage is greatest: when the plaintiff cannot restore what he received in its original condition, has made improvements and prefers to keep the property, is barred from rescission by delay or election, or faces a defendant whose change of position makes restitution unavailable. The commentary adds that damages may even suit the defendant, since the transaction stands and is not upset at a later date.18 The two remedies do not track each other perfectly, for a party may sometimes obtain rescission even though a tort remedy would be unavailable.19
The standard illustration involves Blackacre. The defendant innocently misrepresents facts about it, and on the strength of those statements the plaintiff buys Blackacre for $100,000, though it is worth only $90,000. Rescission would have the plaintiff give back Blackacre and take back $100,000, which leaves each party where the transaction began: the plaintiff with $100,000, the defendant with a house worth $90,000. If rescission is inappropriate for any reason, the plaintiff should usually be permitted to claim the financial equivalent, $10,000 in cash.20 The arithmetic shows why. The plaintiff keeps a house worth $90,000, collects $10,000, and holds the $100,000 that rescission would have restored, while the defendant, having received $100,000 and paid out $10,000, holds $90,000. Traditional tort law allowed damages for misrepresentation only on proof of scienter, so an innocent misrepresentation could support rescission but not damages. The Blackacre measure works because some measures of damages closely approximate rescission by leaving the parties with the same asset values.21 The money award replaces the unwinding and does not add to it, since a plaintiff may combine remedies only so long as the total gives no more than one complete compensation or restitution.22
A buyer in this position has often announced rescission before learning that restoration is impossible. Rescission can be accomplished by the buyer's own declaration, with a suit following only to recover what is owed,23 so the announcement may precede any court filing. Section 378 then decides whether the announcement forecloses the money remedy: a manifestation of a choice, by suit or otherwise, bars another remedy only if the remedies are inconsistent and the other party materially changes position in reliance.24 Rescission upsets the transaction and damages let it stand,25 so the remedies are inconsistent, and the question becomes reliance. A seller who has done nothing since the announcement has lost nothing, and the buyer may turn to damages. A seller who acted in reliance, say by committing funds elsewhere in expectation of the property's return, may block the switch. The election discussion that follows develops the § 378 rule in full.