Concept
The Rule Against Punitive Damages
Punitive Damages for Breach of Contract
Punitive Damages in Contract
The Rule Against Punitive Damages
Contract law's basic remedy compensates. The injured party recovers money damages for the loss of the benefits it would have received had the contract been properly performed.1 Restitution protects a further interest the law recognizes within a bargained-for exchange.2 Punitive damages serve neither purpose; they exist to punish the wrongdoer rather than to repay the plaintiff. The law therefore withholds them from contract claims, subject to one condition.
The Restatement (Second) of Contracts states that condition: punitive damages are not recoverable for a breach of contract unless the conduct constituting the breach is also a tort for which punitive damages are recoverable.3 The common law rule is firmly established, and the Uniform Commercial Code follows it except where punitive damages are specifically authorized.4
Because the condition asks whether the breach is also a tort, the inquiry turns on the source of the duty, not on how serious the breach was. As Applied Equipment frames it, conduct amounting to a breach of contract becomes tortious only when it also violates an independent duty arising from tort law: the duty every person owes, without any contract, not to injure another's person or property or infringe another's rights.5
A deliberate breach does not meet that test merely because it is deliberate. The bar holds even when the breach is willful or malicious, so long as the breach does not amount to an independent tort.6 Suppose a contractor abandons a half-built house because a larger job came along, and says so to the homeowner. The breach is intentional and profit-driven, but it is only a breach, and the homeowner recovers compensation and nothing more. Change one fact: the contractor won the job by lying about a license the homeowner required. If that lie amounts to fraud, the homeowner has a tort claim as well, and if the jurisdiction allows punitive damages for that tort, the condition in the rule is met. Willfulness does not separate the two cases; the independent tort does.
The tort must be pleaded and proved as a claim in its own right. Punitive damages are not a free-standing cause of action but a remedy available on any properly pleaded cause of action when the jurisdiction's standard for that remedy is met.7 For that reason the tort route is better understood as no exception at all to the general rule. It recognizes that one course of conduct can give rise to alternative or cumulative claims in contract and in tort, and some courts have recently shown more willingness to find tortious conduct accompanying a breach sufficient to support punitive damages.8 Pleading the right claim matters because remedies follow the claim, not just the facts. A fiduciary-duty claim can support emotional distress damages that a breach of contract claim cannot, though the plaintiff must still prove that the harm flowed from that breach and not from some other wrong.9
The sections that follow test the line from both sides. Patton v. Mid-Continent Systems presents a deliberate breach undertaken for gain, and shows why willfulness alone is not enough.10 America's Directories, Inc. v. Stellhorn One-Hour Photo, Inc. sits on the other side, where the conduct is a tort as well as a breach. Later sections explain why the law excludes punishment from contract and which torts open the door.