Concept
Certainty Under the UCC
Certainty of damages
Certainty Under the UCC
The Uniform Commercial Code carries the common-law certainty limit into sales of goods and loosens how exactly a buyer must meet it. A buyer who sues for consequential damages, most often lost profit on a resale that the seller's breach prevented, faces a hurdle that sits on top of foreseeability. Even a buyer who shows that the loss was reasonably foreseeable at the time of contracting recovers nothing for it unless the buyer also proves its amount with reasonable certainty.1 The Restatement likewise treats certainty as a requirement distinct from foreseeability.2
Comment 4 to § 2-715 says what the Code means by certainty. The burden of proving the extent of consequential loss is on the buyer, but the Code's section on liberal administration of remedies “rejects any doctrine of certainty which requires almost mathematical precision in the proof of loss. Loss may be determined in any manner which is reasonable under the circumstances.”3 The seller keeps its defense, because a seller can still defeat a lost-profits claim by showing that the profits are too speculative or uncertain.4
The liberal-administration section is § 1-305 in the current numbering. Its commentary under the earlier number, § 1-106, explains that damages need not be calculable with mathematical accuracy, are at best approximate, and “have to be proved with whatever definiteness and accuracy the facts permit, but no more.”5 The section's basic command is to put the plaintiff in the position that performance would have produced, and the relaxed standard of proof serves that command.6
The Code therefore changes how exact the proof must be and leaves two things in place. The buyer still carries the burden, and the buyer must still reach reasonable certainty. The Restatement's § 352 (loss “beyond an amount that the evidence permits to be established with reasonable certainty”), the Code's comment, and UNIDROIT art. 7.4.3 (“a reasonable degree of certainty”) all use that vocabulary, and under each the injured party carries a heavier burden than the ordinary preponderance requirement.7
Consider a hypothetical. A hardware wholesaler contracts to buy a shipment of goods for resale to its regular customers, and the seller fails to deliver. The wholesaler's lost profit is the profit it would have realized on resale, and a subcontract or the wholesaler's normal markup readily supplies that figure.8 If the goods were a commodity, the proof is easier still, because the buyer can invoke the resale market price at the time of intended resale.9 Each method starts from a number that existed independently of the lawsuit: a signed price, a habitual markup, or a quoted market. The factfinder computes from a recorded figure and has little left to guess.
Testimony with nothing behind it falls on the other side of the line. A defendant is “not liable for one million dollars merely because the plaintiff testifies: ‘If this machine hadn't broken down, I might have made a million dollars last year,’” a point the court made in Gerwin v. Southeastern California Ass'n of Seventh Day Adventists.10 Such testimony offers no price, markup, or record that anyone can test, so it does not show the extent of the loss with reasonable certainty.
The “new business rule” shows that the line turns on the evidence rather than on the age of the business. Under that rule, defendants argue that a new business's lost profits are too remote and speculative to recover. The Third Circuit pared the rule back in In re Merritt Logan, Inc., reasoning that a grocery store that had operated for a year and a half fell outside it.11 Most courts do not apply the rule rigidly, and where a reasonable basis exists, even a new business can recover lost profits. Some new ventures remain so speculative that their prospects cannot be estimated in any reasonable way.12
Certainty is one of four hurdles a buyer faces on consequential damages. The buyer must establish causation, foreseeability, reasonable certainty as to amount, and that mitigation doctrines do not bar the claim.13 Special or consequential damages must ordinarily be pleaded as well as proved, and these limits usually have little direct application to general damages, which are normally foreseeable and therefore often easier to recover.14 The hurdles can be hard to tell apart in a reported opinion, because certainty is bound up with how much evidence the claimant offered. Many cases cited for it could as easily be described as a failure to prove damages or to prove causation.15 When a consequential-loss claim fails, ask which of the four hurdles stopped it.