Concept
When Profits Cannot Be Proved
Certainty of damages
When Profits Cannot Be Proved
A claimant who cannot prove lost profits has lost one measure of damages, not the lawsuit. Section 352 of the Restatement (Second) of Contracts bars recovery for loss beyond the amount that the evidence permits to be established with reasonable certainty, and the bar bites hardest on lost profits.1 A venture with no operating history, an income that depends on public taste, a figure that rests on a chain of later events: any of these can leave a claimant with a real grievance and no proof of what the contract would have earned. Yet the bar is narrower than it first appears. It “merely excludes those elements of loss that cannot be proved with reasonable certainty,” and it does not require the claimant to establish the total amount of the loss.2
Two tempting responses to an unprovable profit claim are both unacceptable. Dismissal would let the breacher gain from the vagueness of the loss it caused, since a party who has forced the injured party to seek damages “should not be allowed to profit from his breach where it is established that a significant loss has occurred.”3 Letting the factfinder choose a figure would defeat § 352, and one older opinion warned that leaving damages to “the unbridled discretion of the jury” for a loss the parties never contemplated could bring ruin on the party in default. The cure it pointed to was contractual: parties may liquidate the amount when damages cannot otherwise be ascertained.4
The law therefore offers two substitutes, in descending order. The first is recovery of what the claimant spent in reliance on the contract, which rests on money already laid out and requires no forecast. The second is a token award, which applies when even the outlays cannot be proved. An exam stem in which the profit proof collapses is asking which state of the record its facts reach.
Reliance Damages as Substitute
When expectation damages cannot be proved with reasonable certainty, the claimant’s usual fall-back is to seek reliance damages, the money spent on the strength of the contract.5 Comment a to § 352 explains why the fall-back works. The certainty requirement governs reliance claims too, but there is “usually little difficulty in proving the amount that the injured party has actually spent in reliance on the contract, even if it is impossible to prove the amount of profit that he would have made,” and in that case the injured party recovers on the reliance interest instead of the expectation interest.6 Section 349 governs that alternative.
The difference in provability comes from what each figure is. Lost profit is a forecast: it requires prices, costs, demand, and the claimant’s own effort for a period that never occurred. Money spent is a historical fact, recorded in invoices, payroll, and bank statements that exist whether or not anyone sues. The factfinder adds up what happened and need not predict what did not. Recovering outlays also answers the objection that a nominal award would let the breacher gain from the vagueness of the venture it ended.
Illustration 2 shows the fall-back in its simplest form. A buyer plans an outdoor drive-in theatre on a tract of land, the seller breaks the contract by selling the land to someone else, and the theatre is never built. Because the enterprise is new and speculative, the evidence does not permit the buyer’s lost profits to be estimated with reasonable certainty, so recovery is limited to expenses incurred in reliance or, if none can be proved with reasonable certainty, to nominal damages.7 Illustration 3 adds a condition. A builder agrees to construct a building of radical new design for $5,000,000, spends $3,000,000, and is ordered off the site when the owner repudiates. If the evidence does not permit the builder’s lost profits to be estimated with reasonable certainty, the builder recovers the $3,000,000 spent in reliance, but only after proving that amount with reasonable certainty.8
Reliance recovery therefore relocates the certainty requirement; it does not suspend it. The claimant needs records of the outlays and also evidence tying them to the breach. In L. Albert & Son v. Armstrong Rubber Co., a buyer of rubber-reconditioning machines was denied damages for its investment in a rubber-reclaiming department and for the cost of scrap rubber, because the showing was that the seller’s delay was only one of several possible causes of the loss.9 A receipt proves that money left the claimant’s account; it does not prove that the breach wasted it.
Courts invoke the substitute for the new-venture claims that dominate this chapter. In Hollywood Fantasy Corp. v. Gabor, a promoter of “fantasy vacations” for movie fans could not prove the lost profits of a new venture after a celebrity breached, and the Fifth Circuit allowed recovery of the promoter’s out-of-pocket expenses.10 Anglia Television Ltd. v. Reed shows the same mismatch from the English side: a producer whose leading man repudiated abandoned the film and sought the money it had already spent, a provable sum, in place of the unprovable earnings of a film never made. Failed negotiations produce the same gap. Parties to a complex transaction often negotiate at length and record preliminary understandings before they reach a final contract,11 and when a breach occurs in that setting, the gain from a final contract that may never have been made is far harder to prove than the money already spent in pursuing it.
Outlays that are ancillary to the contract, which the cited treatise calls incidental reliance, carry added limits. The limits protect the breacher from liability for expenses it could not fairly have expected or that were not incurred reasonably. Such outlays are recoverable only if the breacher foresaw or reasonably should have foreseen the possibility of the expenditure, and both its amount and its nature were reasonable. The mitigation principle applies as well, so the claimant must take reasonable steps to recoup whatever is salvageable, and the expense must be proved with reasonable certainty.12
The substitute carries its own limit. Under Restatement (Second) § 349, reliance recovery is offset by “any loss that the party in breach can prove with reasonable certainty the injured party would have suffered had the contract been performed.”13 The reason lies in what the measure promises. A contract that would have cost more to perform than it paid is a losing contract, and reimbursing every dollar spent on it would leave the claimant better off than performance would have, so the breach would become a source of profit for the party it injured.
The breaching party carries the burden of showing that the contract would have been a losing one for the plaintiff.14 The allocation fits the structure of the case: the claimant’s profit proof failed because the breach ended the venture before it could produce a record, and the party who created that silence bears the cost of it. The burden can be carried, however. In one reported case, a defendant used expert testimony to prove that even without its breach of a contract to convey real property, the projected development could not have been completed and generated enough revenue to recoup the plaintiff’s reliance costs. In St. Lawrence Factory Stores v. Ogdensburg Bridge and Port Auth., the appellate court had earlier ruled that the plaintiff could go to trial on its reliance claim, the trial court then denied recovery, and the denial was upheld, because the defendant had only to show with “reasonable certainty” that the plaintiff could not have recouped its expenditures even without a breach.15 The standard that defeated the claimant’s profit evidence now binds the defendant as well, so a bare claim that ventures of this kind often fail does not reduce the award.
An exam stem that pairs a failed profit claim with a stack of receipts is testing a sequence. The profit element fails under § 352, the claimant turns to reliance, the claimant proves the outlays and their link to the breach with reasonable certainty, and the defendant then has the chance to reduce the award by proving a losing contract. A new-venture owner who offers no receipts and no profit evidence has nothing for either measure, and the next part takes up the small award that remains for her.
Nominal Damages
When neither profits nor outlays can be proved, the claimant is left with nominal damages. Where a plaintiff establishes the violation of a right but fails to show damages with the appropriate degree of certainty, the trier of fact may limit the award to nominal damages.18 The award is a token. It marks the broken promise and measures nothing the claimant lost. Dismissing the claim would treat the breach as though it never happened, and awarding a guessed sum would defy § 352, so the token award occupies the space between those two outcomes.19
Nominal damages come last because the law first looks for any measure the evidence can support. Illustration 2 places the award at the end of that sequence: the drive-in buyer’s recovery is limited to expenses incurred in reliance “or, if none can be proved with reasonable certainty, to nominal damages.”20 The token sum appears only in the “if none” branch. A buyer who can document outlays collects them, and only a buyer who cannot document even those is left with the small sum. Illustration 1 reaches the bottom by a different path. A publisher repudiates a contract to publish a novel, the evidence cannot estimate the author’s lost royalties and reputation with reasonable certainty, and the author “cannot recover damages for that loss, although he can recover nominal damages.”21
The principle behind the floor is old and blunt. Newsome v. Western Union Telegraph Co. states that “damages are not to be based upon mere conjectural probability of future loss or gain,” and that “[s]omething more than a possible result must appear.”22 A claimed profit that rests on a chain of later events, each of which might or might not have occurred, is a possible result and nothing more.
The three outcomes appear side by side when claimants with different records sue over the same breach.
Imprecision about amount is a different problem from absence of proof, and it does not send a claimant to the floor. Damages need not be calculable with mathematical accuracy and are often at best approximate. Once a significant loss is established, doubts are generally resolved against the breacher, and a court may weigh all the circumstances of the breach, including willfulness, in deciding whether to require a lesser degree of certainty.23 Courts have also grown more receptive to sophisticated economic and financial data and to expert opinion, which makes the requirement easier to meet.24 Nominal damages answer a record that proves no loss at all, and a record that proves some loss supports an award of that loss.
Two errors recur. Some students award nominal damages as soon as the profit proof looks weak and skip reliance, though comment a describes outlays as usually easy to prove.25 Others treat a failed profit claim as a failed lawsuit, when the breach still supports a claim and only the amount of recovery shrinks.