Concept
Proving Lost Profits
Certainty of damages
Proving Lost Profits
A claim for lost profits asks a factfinder to subtract one hypothetical number from another. Revenue depends on prices and demand that never materialized, and cost depends on inputs that were never bought, so the difference is a result in a world the breach prevented. The certainty requirement of § 352 therefore does most of its work in lost-profits cases.1 It does not demand perfection. The claimant need not prove the total amount of the loss; the rule excludes only those elements that cannot be proved with reasonable certainty.2
The burden stays with the claimant. A breach victim who cannot show the fact and extent of its loss by a preponderance of the evidence recovers nothing, and the reasonable-certainty limit restates that principle: the evidence must persuade the factfinder that the loss more likely occurred than not, and it must give the factfinder enough basis to calculate a monetary award.3 The two showings help each other. The more clearly a claimant proves that some loss occurred, the harder the factfinder works to fix a figure. With no plausible evidence of amount the claimant gets nothing, and with some helpful evidence the factfinder does its best to reach a justifiable sum.4
Two circumstances set the size of the claimant's evidentiary task. One is the claimant's track record: a business with years of recorded sales and costs can give the factfinder numbers to check, while a venture that never opened must borrow proof from elsewhere. The other is the shape of the transaction, because some contracts make the profit nearly a matter of arithmetic and others leave it hostage to third parties, distant years, or the claimant's own costs. The first two subsections take up the track record, established business first. The third takes up the transaction.
Established Businesses
An established business can often prove its lost profits because it has already produced the evidence. When a breach prevents the injured party from carrying on a well-established business, the resulting loss of profits can often be proved with sufficient certainty, since evidence of past performance forms the basis for a reasonable prediction about the future.5 A forecast is hardest to defend when nothing exists to test it against. A business that has operated for years recorded its sales, prices, and costs in the ordinary course, before anyone contemplated a suit, so the claimant's projection extends figures that the defendant can examine through the same records and through cross-examination of the people who kept them.
Illustration 5 shows the method at work. A contractor agrees to remodel an existing drive-in theatre by June 1 and finishes on September 1. The owner can prove the lost profits with reasonable certainty from records of the theatre's prior and subsequent operation, together with other evidence.6 The earlier records show what the theatre ordinarily earned, and the later ones show what it earned once open, so the factfinder estimates the lost summer by comparing the theatre with itself.
Courts state the rule the same way. In Evergreen Amusement Corp. v. Milstead, the court called loss of profit a definite element of damages in an action for breach of contract, or for harm to an established business, when the business has operated long enough to afford a basis for estimating the probable loss with some degree of certainty. It held, on the other side of the line, that profits of a business that has not gone into operation may not be recovered, because they are merely speculative.7 The court also quoted the Restatement of Contracts for the proposition that the profits prevented by a breach against a well-established business are often capable of proof with reasonable certainty.8 Both halves of the rule turn on history. The length of a business's operation decides whether anything exists from which a probable loss can be estimated.
A going business's earlier profits can also survive an attack on the history itself. In Stentor Elec. Mfg. Co. v. Klaxon Co., the defendant objected that the earlier profits could not serve as a criterion of damages because they came from Navy contracts that ended with the close of the World War. The court answered with evidence that other private business was available, which Stentor could not handle for want of capital, and that one motive for the agreement was Klaxon's ability to expand operations to capture it.9 The earlier profits remained a fair guide because other evidence bridged the gap between the ended wartime work and the business the contract would have opened.
A documented extrapolation can also be enough. In Benchmark Health Care Center, Inc. v. Cain, a one-year contract for rehabilitation therapy services was wrongfully terminated, and the provider's accountant projected the profit for the rest of the term from the profits earned in the months before termination. The court sustained the jury's award. A future estimate necessarily involves some speculation, but the accountant had documented and explained the method and had produced a realistic figure.
A defendant who faces good books therefore has one productive line of attack: whether the past results are a fair guide to the lost period. The answer depends on whether the conditions that produced the profits would have continued. Comment b makes the same point from the other side, noting that proof grows harder when a business is subject to great fluctuations in volume, costs, or prices.10
The shop and the Stentor plaintiff both kept accurate books and had a history of profit. They differ in the evidence that connects that history to the lost period, and the defendant's objection lands on that connection. An established business in a changing market does not lose automatically. It carries the added task of showing why the old profits predict the new period.
New Businesses
A business with no operating history faces the same ceiling as every other claimant, but it must reach that ceiling with different evidence.12 Comment b says proof is harder when the business is new, or speculative and subject to great fluctuations in volume, costs, or prices, yet damages may still be established with reasonable certainty through expert testimony, economic and financial data, market surveys and analyses, and business records of similar enterprises.13 An established business answers the question of what would have happened by opening its own books. A new business has no books to open, so it must borrow proof or go without.
The missing history causes trouble at two points. First, it clouds the fact of loss. Many new businesses never earn a profit, so without a history of profitable operation the wrong may have prevented future losses rather than caused them, and a claimant who cannot show that future profits were reasonably certain recovers no lost profits at all.14 Second, even a venture that probably would have profited has no record of how much, so the amount rests on projections of prices, costs, and demand that no operation has tested.
Evergreen shows the traditional response. The court held that profits of a business that has not gone into operation may not be recovered, because they are merely speculative and incapable of being ascertained with the requisite degree of certainty.15 It noted commentary describing a rule in some states that no new business can recover lost profits, and it declined to lay down a flat rule itself, though it observed that no case had permitted recovery in comparable circumstances. Among the authorities it examined was Abbott v. Gatch. The court also pointed to the Restatement of Contracts, under which damages may be measured by the rental value of the property when the evidence gives no sufficient basis for estimating profits.16
A categorical bar is overinclusive, and most courts now decline to apply it rigidly. It treats the absence of a history as proof of uncertainty, so it denies recovery to a claimant whose comparable-business data, market surveys, or expert analysis would give a factfinder a sound estimate, and it shelters the breacher most when the breach ended the venture before a history could form. Today most courts ask whether a reasonable basis of computation exists, and that basis can come from a modified version of the before-and-after method.17 In Alaska Rent-A-Car, Inc. v. Avis Budget Group, Inc., 709 F.3d 872 (9th Cir. 2013), for example, lost profits went to a new business venture on evidence of its past performance and prospects.18 What courts look for is a substitute for history, and comment b and its Illustration 6 name the usual substitutes:19
- records of the venture's later operation, if it opened late;
- records of similar enterprises in the same locality;
- economic and financial data;
- market surveys and analyses; and
- expert testimony.
Two of the Restatement's illustrations show how much of the answer lies in the evidence. In Illustration 2, a buyer plans an outdoor drive-in theatre on a tract of land, the seller breaks the contract by selling the land to someone else, and the theatre is never built. If, because of the speculative nature of the new enterprise, the evidence does not permit the lost profits to be estimated with reasonable certainty, recovery is limited to expenses incurred in reliance or, if none can be proved, to nominal damages.20 In Illustration 6, a contractor finishes a new drive-in theatre three months late, and even though the business is new, the owner may be able to prove lost profits from records of the theatre's later operation and of similar theatres in the same locality, along with market surveys and expert testimony.21 The new-business label appears in both and settles neither. The difference lies in the evidence each owner can reach: the late theatre opened and produced records that can be set beside those of similar theatres, while the buyer in Illustration 2 has no operating theatre to observe.
The flat bar fails in Fera v. Village Plaza, Inc. Lessees kept out of space they had leased for a book-and-bottle shop won a $200,000 jury verdict for lost profits after days of expert testimony from both sides.22 The court said that its earlier new-business decisions should not be read as a rule preventing every new business from recovering anticipated lost profits. The rule applies the doctrine that a plaintiff must lay a basis for a reasonable estimate of the harm in money, so the issue is sufficiency of proof, and a jury should not be allowed to speculate or guess about the amount.23 The verdict stood although the shop had no earnings history. That result fits comment a, under which damages need not be calculable with mathematical accuracy and doubts are generally resolved against the party in breach.24
Comparison evidence fails when the comparison is poor. In Blinds To Go (U.S.), Inc. v. Times Plaza Development, L.P., a chain with four existing stores sued after a lessor terminated the lease for a fifth, a Brooklyn store the chain had not yet opened. The chain offered expert evidence of the profits at three of its existing stores, and a jury awarded damages, but the appellate court set the award aside as against the weight of the evidence. Although the chain was no startup, the court treated the Brooklyn store as a new venture because it was an attempt to enter a new market. It found no reasonable certainty that the existing stores were comparable: they were more suburban, and their customers differed in demographics and median income. The court ordered a new trial on damages and suggested that testimony about the profitability of comparable Brooklyn stores might supply the missing certainty. Two points follow. An established business's history says little about a location in a different market, so an expansion can turn an established claimant into a new venture for purposes of the rule. And comparison evidence carries only as much weight as the likeness of the businesses compared.
Fera and Blinds To Go both began with a new enterprise and expert-backed projections, so the label decided neither. In Fera the profit question was fought out through experts on both sides and the verdict stood. In Blinds To Go the comparison rested on stores the court found unlike the lost one, and the verdict fell. The Third Circuit pared the rule back in In re Merritt Logan, Inc., holding that a grocery that had operated for a year and a half fell outside it, and most courts now apply the new-business rule flexibly, allowing even new businesses to recover where a reasonable basis exists.25 Courts increasingly credit accounting experts who use copious data and sophisticated techniques, but a claimant cannot assume that a court will accept her own estimate without supporting factual material, and a plaintiff whose expert makes no attempt to estimate the amount lost may fail.26
A claimant whose profit proof fails keeps something. Illustration 2 limits recovery to reliance expenses or, if none can be proved, to nominal damages, and comment a observes that the amount actually spent is usually easy to prove even when the profit cannot be.27 Reliance works as a fallback because it treats the venture as breaking even: the claimant recovers what it spent, no court has to find that any profit would have existed, and the result puts the claimant as close to its expectation as the evidence allows (unless the defendant proves the claimant would have lost money).28 Rental value is another alternative measure, as Evergreen noted.29 The section on when profits cannot be proved develops both.
Nature of the Transaction
Comment b opens its discussion of proof by observing that the difficulty of proving lost profits varies greatly with the nature of the transaction.31 Its examples can be read as ranking transactions by the unknowns that stand between the breach and the profit. Each unknown is a fact about a world that never existed — what a third party would have done, what a later year would have brought, what a competitor would have taken, what the job would have cost — and the claimant must prove each one while the defendant attacks it. A transaction with a single unknown yields a figure the factfinder can compute. One with many yields a figure that rests on guesses.
The seller who loses a sale sits at the easy end. When a buyer's breach costs a seller a sale, proof of lost profit will ordinarily not be difficult.32 The contract fixes the price, so revenue needs no forecast, and the seller's own records of what the goods cost to buy or make supply the other half of the subtraction. Almost nothing is left to estimate.
The task is harder for a buyer who claims that the seller's breach cost it profit in other transactions.33 That profit comes not from the broken contract but from dealings with third parties that the contract would have made possible, so the buyer must prove what customers would have bought, in what quantities, and at what prices. How hard that is depends on how much third-party behavior was already settled when the breach occurred. A buyer with an existing business that bought goods for resale can compute its lost profit as the profit it would have made on the resale, and a subcontract or the buyer's normal markup usually supplies the figure; for commodities, the market price at the time of the intended resale supplies it with ease and certainty.34 In both settings the downstream price is a fact rather than a forecast, which removes the third-party unknown.
That line, between a downstream sale already fixed and one that exists only as a hope, concerns third parties. Distance in time adds a separate difficulty. Where a seller agrees to furnish all of the buyer's requirements over a period of years, proof of the profit lost through the seller's breach is more difficult.35 Every input becomes a multi-year forecast: the buyer's needs, the prices, the costs, and the strength of the buyer's own market. Illustration 8 shows that a long term can still be sorted into provable and unprovable parts. A scrap-steel dealer contracts to buy all of a manufacturer's scrap output for five years at a price tied to the market, and the manufacturer repudiates after one year. The dealer's profit depends largely on the manufacturer's output and on the cost of transporting the scrap to the dealer's purchasers, so recovery for the remaining four years depends on whether the dealer can prove those two figures with reasonable certainty. If he can prove them for part of the period, he recovers lost profits for that part.36 The illustration's further point about specific performance belongs to the later section on alternative remedies.
Agency contracts show how a single feature can shrink the list of unknowns. In Illustration 7, A makes B his exclusive agent for the sale of machine tools in a specified territory, then repudiates and replaces B with C. B can use evidence of the sales and profits he made before the repudiation, and of those C made after it, to prove his lost profits with reasonable certainty.37 Exclusivity makes that evidence persuasive. The agent's earlier sales in the territory, or the principal's sales there after the breach, may permit a reasonably accurate estimate of the lost commissions.38
Where the agency was not exclusive, the agent's ability to withstand competition is in question, and the same showing is more difficult, though not necessarily impossible.39 Competition adds one more unknown. With rivals selling the same goods, the principal's later sales no longer reveal how much of the territory the agent would have kept, and the agent's own past record becomes the evidence that may still supply a sufficient basis for judging the question.40 The non-exclusive agent keeps a path to recovery and carries a heavier evidentiary load than the exclusive agent.
Even when the price is fixed, the cost side of the subtraction can defeat a profit claim. In Illustration 3, a builder contracts to construct a building of radical new design for $5,000,000, and the owner repudiates after the builder has spent $3,000,000 in reliance. If the evidence does not permit the builder's lost profits to be estimated with reasonable certainty, the builder recovers the $3,000,000, but it must then prove that amount with reasonable certainty.41 The price is known, so the profit turns on what it would have cost to build a design nobody has built before, and a claimant with no reliable evidence of that cost cannot show that the contract would have been profitable. The fallback is reliance, which the section on when profits cannot be proved develops.
These categories describe how heavy the burden of proof is, and they do not decide who wins. Comment b says only that proof is harder in the later categories, and its treatment of the non-exclusive agent adds that success is not necessarily impossible. A claimant in a hard category who brings the right evidence recovers, and a claimant in an easy category who brings none does not.