Concept
Fact Versus Amount of Loss
Certainty of damages
Fact Versus Amount of Loss
Section 352 bars damages for loss beyond the amount that the evidence permits to be established with reasonable certainty. It does not, however, require the injured party to prove the total amount of its loss; it excludes only those elements of loss that cannot be proved with reasonable certainty.1 Courts apply that limit in two steps. The threshold question is whether the claimant has proved injury, meaning that the breach in fact caused some loss. Only if it has does the second question arise: whether the evidence gives the factfinder enough to determine how much the loss was.2 The first step concerns the fact of damage and the second concerns the amount. Keeping them apart lets you predict outcomes, because courts demand real proof at the first step and are generally more forgiving at the second.
Each step guards against a different risk. Where serious doubt exists whether the claimant suffered any loss, the certainty doctrine precludes recovery of that element. A venture with no history of profit may have lost money whether or not the contract was kept, so the breach may have prevented losses rather than caused them.3 Once a loss is shown to exist, the risk changes. Refusing all relief because the number cannot be fixed exactly would let the breacher escape a wrong already proved. The working rule follows: the more clearly the claimant shows the fact of injury, the harder the factfinder will try to reach some compensation figure.4
Panhandle Eastern Pipe Line Co. v. Smith states the division in two clauses: "The existence of damages must be proved; the amount of damages must be decided with all the certainty the case permits." The court added that the amount in that case could not be determined with precise mathematical exactness, but it did not have to be.5 Modic v. Modic reaches the same place by borrowing from tort law. Once the fact of damage is established with reasonable certainty, the plaintiff receives considerable latitude in proving the amount, lest the wrongdoer escape his obligation.6
That latitude follows from what the court already knows. A court reasonably certain that the loss was at least some positive sum will not use the certainty rule to award $0, the one number almost certainly wrong.7 Certainty does not demand that any one number be certain. It asks whether damages of at least a given amount are reasonably certain, and an award at that level survives even if the figure itself is unlikely. As the claimed amount rises above that minimum, the likelihood that damages reached such a level declines, and the extra increments need support.8 The next section takes up why the law gives the claimant this benefit of the doubt.
The reverse pattern, with the fact of loss shown but the amount not, appeared in a reviewing court's treatment of a verdict for Flying B, a trucking company. On the record, the court explained, the jury could well have concluded that (1) racial discrimination caused lost profits by delaying Flying B's drivers and reducing the loads Flying B hauled, but (2) no testimony let the jury put a number on how many loads were lost, so (3) although lost profits were proved, their amount could not be established "with reasonable certainty," as the jury instruction required.9
Latitude on amount depends on some helpful evidence. Where the claimant offers any, the factfinder does its best to fix damages in some justifiable amount. Where it offers no plausible, relevant evidence of the amount of its loss, it cannot recover that element at all.10 Flying B's proof showed that loads were probably lost but gave the jury nothing from which to compute a sum.
A claimant who clears both steps ordinarily proves three things: the fact of loss, its cause, and its amount. Florafax International, Inc. v. GTE Market Resources, Inc. found the fact of lost profits beyond a sixty-day period in the testimony of Bellerose's president, who regarded the relationship with Florafax as a long-term one and said that performance concerns drove his decision to terminate. That testimony showed the relationship in all probability would have continued had GTE adequately performed.11 The sixty-day notice provision meant Bellerose might have terminated anyway, but the record did not require the conclusion that it would have. The court held that Florafax carried its burden to prove the fact, cause, and amount of its lost profits with reasonable certainty.12
Courts do not all state the two-step rule alike. Some state it strictly, requiring that both the existence and the amount of damage be proved with reasonable certainty. In theory, a court using that formulation might strike a lost-profit claim even though the plaintiff showed with reasonable certainty that profits were at least $100, if nothing established how much more was lost.13 Others take a soft approach, which is demanding about proof that the breach caused damage but forgiving about amount. The labels express attitudes rather than rules, and even the soft approach does not countenance speculation or an irrational guess about damages.14 Whatever the formulation, all courts agree that the plaintiff need not prove the amount with precision and that the rule bars only losses exceeding the amount proved with reasonable certainty.15
The common mistake is to collapse the steps. One version treats an inexact figure as if it meant the loss was unproved, which Panhandle rejects. The other treats a proved loss as if it entitled the claimant to whatever number the jury prefers, which overlooks that Flying B's probable loss still failed for want of evidence of amount.