Concept
Seller's Damages Under the UCC
Expectation interest (including direct, incidental, and consequential damages)
Seller's Damages Under the UCC
Article 2 gives a seller four money remedies against a breaching buyer: the difference between the contract price and the resale price (§ 2-706), the difference between the contract price and the market price (§ 2-708(1)), the profit the seller would have made on the sale (§ 2-708(2)), and, in three circumstances only, the contract price itself (§ 2-709). All four add the seller’s incidental damages.1
The four aim at one target, the seller’s expectation interest. That interest is the profit on the sale, the contract price (K) less the cost of performing (C), and each formula returns it. An action for the price yields K − C directly, and the market and resale differences yield it because the damages plus the market or resale value of the goods the seller keeps add up to K.2
The seller’s remedies largely mirror the buyer’s. Resale does for a seller what cover does for a buyer, the market measure parallels the buyer’s, and incidental damages and expenses saved adjust each measure.3 Two differences keep the mirror from being exact. A seller may sometimes demand the price itself, a form of specific enforcement that Article 2, like the common law, treats as limited and secondary and allows only when damages are inappropriate.4 And a seller has no general claim to consequential damages: the seller’s supplement to the primary measure is incidental damages, and even the lost-profit measure reaches only the profit on the contract with the breaching buyer.5
This section takes the seller’s remedies in the order a seller meets them: the three situations in which the price is recoverable, the seller’s obligations once it sues for the price, the damages that apply when the price is denied, and the incidental damages that accompany every measure.
Price for Accepted or Lost Goods
When a buyer fails to pay the price as it becomes due, the seller may recover the price together with incidental damages, and § 2-709(1)(a) names the first two situations in which the remedy is available: goods the buyer accepted, and conforming goods lost or damaged within a commercially reasonable time after the risk of their loss passed to the buyer.6 The claim rests on nonpayment, so the price must have fallen due and gone unpaid; a seller who sues before the due date has no claim yet. Goods still in the seller’s hands raise different questions, taken up in the next two subsections.
A buyer’s acceptance supports a price judgment because of what the seller’s other measures do. Resale and market damages price a substitute transaction: the seller holds goods the buyer refused, and the award covers the gap between the contract price and what those goods bring elsewhere. A seller whose goods are already in the buyer’s hands has no substitute transaction to price. The seller has performed, the buyer has what the contract promised, and what remains owing is a debt. Article 2 therefore allows the price for accepted goods and makes damages the rule elsewhere.7 Because the judgment orders the buyer to pay what the contract promised, it works as a virtual specific performance of the payment obligation,8 and it delivers the seller’s expectation exactly: the seller receives the price after already bearing the cost of performing, which leaves K − C.9
Sara’s boat sale shows how acceptance decides the remedy. Suppose Sara delivers the boat and Bert accepts it with no ground to revoke. Bert then owes the $21,000 price plus incidental damages.10 Had Bert instead wrongfully rejected the tender, Sara would have to give notice and resell in a commercially reasonable fashion; if the boat brought $20,000, she would recover $1,000 plus her resale costs less any savings, and she could not force Bert to pay the price and take the boat.11 The Code confirms the point for every wrongful rejection: a seller held not entitled to the price is still awarded damages for non-acceptance.12 The boat is the same in both versions. What differs is whether Bert kept it, so the first question in any seller problem is whether the buyer accepted the goods.
Acceptance supports the price action only while it stands. A buyer who justifiably revokes acceptance has not breached; the Code’s fallback for a seller denied the price speaks only of a buyer who wrongfully rejected or wrongfully revoked acceptance.13 After a justified revocation the goods no longer count as accepted, the seller is the party in default, and the buyer’s remedies for the seller’s breach displace the price claim. A buyer who accepted imperfect goods and has no ground to revoke stands differently: that buyer remains bound for the price and, after giving notice, recovers the loss from the non-conformity as damages.14
The second situation in § 2-709(1)(a) concerns goods the buyer never gets to use. If conforming goods are lost or damaged within a commercially reasonable time after the risk of loss has passed to the buyer, the seller may recover the price.15 Two reasons support the rule. A seller whose goods are destroyed has nothing to resell and no market sale to compare, so a resale or market measure would price nothing. More basically, the risk-of-loss rules, taught elsewhere in the course, have already placed the casualty on the buyer, and awarding the seller less than the price would shift back onto the seller a loss the contract put on the buyer. The statute keeps the rule narrow in two ways: it reaches only conforming goods, and only losses that occur within a commercially reasonable time after the risk passed.
Sara’s boat shows what the risk-of-loss condition turns on. If fire destroys the boat before the risk of loss has passed to Bert, he has no liability and Sara may be excused from performing on grounds of impossibility. If the fire comes after the risk has passed, Bert owes the $21,000 price, an exceptional remedy in a Code that strongly favors limiting damages through resale or the contract-market difference.16 The same fire produces opposite results depending on who held the risk when it burned, so an answer about lost goods must say which party that was.
Whichever situation applies, the judgment carries incidental damages under § 2-710, taken up at the end of this section. The list in § 2-709 is also exhaustive. The price is recoverable in these two situations and in one more, goods identified to the contract that the seller cannot resell after reasonable effort.17 A seller who sues for the price after a bare repudiation, holding unaccepted goods that can be resold, falls outside the list and recovers damages measured by resale or by the market.
The second step does the most work on an exam, because a fact pattern that says the buyer has the goods invites an automatic price award that a justified revocation would defeat.
Price for Unresalable Goods
Section 2-709(1)(b) supplies the third situation in which a seller may recover the price: goods identified to the contract that the seller is unable, after reasonable effort, to resell at a reasonable price, or that the circumstances reasonably indicate cannot be resold by such effort.19 Goods are identified when the seller selects the particular goods for this buyer, as by setting aside units from inventory for shipment. The first two situations concern goods the buyer accepted and goods lost after the risk passed to the buyer. This one reaches goods that stay in the seller’s warehouse, so it must explain why a seller still holding the goods may collect their full price.
The explanation starts with how the seller’s other remedies work. Resale damages price a substitute transaction: the seller sells the refused goods to someone else, and the award covers the shortfall, so the damages plus the resale proceeds equal the contract price.20 That arithmetic assumes the goods can be sold. When they cannot, no substitute transaction exists to price, and the seller reaches the profit that performance would have produced only by collecting the price itself. The remedy resembles the buyer’s right to specific performance when goods are unique or substitutes are unavailable, and it rests on the same reason: damages cannot do the job.21 Article 2 treats that kind of enforcement as secondary, which is why the statute confines the price to accepted goods, lost goods, and goods that are just not resalable.22
Specially made goods are the typical case. A seller who embroiders a buyer’s family crest onto linens and sets them aside for shipment holds goods that no other customer will want, so when the buyer repudiates, the seller is entitled to the price. Sara’s boat shows both outcomes. If the boat is a stock model and Bert wrongfully rejects it, Sara must resell and recovers only the shortfall.23 If Bert had instead ordered a boat built to his personal specifications, and Sara cannot resell it at a reasonable price after reasonable effort, or the circumstances show that trying would be futile, she may sue for the full $21,000.24 Even then the remedy remains exceptional, because Article 2 strongly favors limiting the seller to resale damages or the contract-market difference.25 Custom manufacture is not the test, however. The statute asks only whether the goods can be resold at a reasonable price, so ordinary goods qualify when the market will not take them.
The statute gives the seller two ways in. The first is a record of failure: the seller tried to resell and found no reasonable price. The second spares the seller a futile attempt when circumstances, such as a buyer’s crest or a design fitted to the buyer’s plant, reasonably show that trying would be unavailing. The effort requirement guards against a particular temptation. A seller who could sell the goods tomorrow might prefer to sue for the price and skip the work of finding another buyer, and that seller would then hold both the price and goods that still have value. Article 2 therefore requires reasonable attempts at resale before the seller claims the price,26 in line with the general rule that an injured party cannot recover losses it could have avoided by reasonable effort once the breach became known.27
Answers go wrong in two directions. Some award the price whenever a buyer repudiates, which overlooks that a seller of ordinary goods who has not tried to resell, and has no reason to think trying would fail, stays within the resale and market measures. Others deny the price because the seller never attempted resale, which overlooks the alternative for goods that could not reasonably be sold at all. A seller held not entitled to the price still recovers damages for non-acceptance, so the seller keeps a remedy either way and only the measure changes.28
Holding and Reselling Goods
A seller who sues for the price must hold for the buyer any goods identified to the contract and still in the seller’s control, except that if resale becomes possible the seller may resell them at any time before the judgment is collected.30 Section 2-709(2) adds two consequences: the net proceeds of any resale must be credited to the buyer, and payment of the judgment entitles the buyer to any goods not resold.31 Subsection (1) decides when the seller may collect the price, and subsection (2) coordinates that judgment with the goods themselves. The rule has four parts, a duty to hold, a permission to resell, a credit for the proceeds, and delivery of whatever remains, and each part prevents the same result: a seller who ends the case holding both the price and the performance.
The reason runs through the seller’s expectation. Had the contract been performed, the seller would have received the price and given up the performance, and allowing the seller to keep both puts it in a better position than performance would have.32 The seller instead recovers the price minus the value of what it keeps. A resale avoids part of the loss for the same reason: the damages plus the resale price equal the contract price, and no more.33 A buyer who pays the judgment is entitled to the goods, so the seller must keep them available.
The duty to hold reaches only goods identified to the contract and still in the seller’s control. Goods the buyer accepted are already in the buyer’s hands, and goods lost after the risk passed no longer exist, so subsection (2) has nothing to hold in those two situations. The duty does its work where the seller sues for the price of goods it could not resell, because those goods sit in the seller’s warehouse and the buyer’s payment is what entitles the buyer to them.
The exception for resale reflects the fact that inability to resell describes a moment, not a permanent condition. A seller qualifies for the price because reasonable effort failed or would clearly fail. Markets recover, however, and a buyer for a specially made item may turn up after suit is filed. Once resale becomes possible, the reason for collecting the price on those goods disappears, which is why the statute lets the seller resell until the judgment is collected and not merely until it is entered.34 The requirement of reasonable attempts at resale before claiming the price points the same way.35
The credit makes the arithmetic come out right. The proceeds credited are the net proceeds, meaning what the resale yields after the expense of making it, and they reduce what the buyer owes on the judgment dollar for dollar. When the seller resells only some of the goods, the buyer owes the reduced judgment and takes the rest. If a seller with a $50,000 judgment for 50 identical units resells 20 of them for $18,000 net, the buyer owes $32,000 and receives the remaining 30 units on payment.
Two errors recur. An answer that awards the full price and says nothing about resale proceeds treats the judgment as a closed account. An answer that says the seller loses the price remedy once resale becomes possible overlooks that the remedy continues for whatever remains unsold. The next subsection takes up the case in which the price is denied altogether and the seller falls back on damages.
Damages When Price Is Denied
Section 2-709(3) keeps the narrowness of the price action from leaving a seller without a remedy. After the buyer has wrongfully rejected or revoked acceptance of the goods, failed to make a payment due, or repudiated, a seller held not entitled to the price “shall nevertheless be awarded damages for non-acceptance under the preceding section.”37 The preceding section is § 2-708, and the mandatory wording makes the fallback automatic: a seller who sues for the price and loses because the goods can be resold still holds a damages claim. The fallback follows from the Code’s ranking of remedies, since the price action is a limited form of specific enforcement and damages are the primary remedy everywhere else.38 A seller who still holds goods another customer will take has lost only the shortfall a substitute sale leaves, and the damages measures price that shortfall.
Three measures do that work, and they differ in how they price the goods the buyer refused:
- The contract-resale difference (§ 2-706(1)) applies when the seller resells in good faith and in a commercially reasonable manner. It awards the contract price minus the resale price, plus incidental damages, minus expenses saved.39
- The contract-market difference (§ 2-708(1)) awards the contract price minus the market price at the time and place for tender, plus incidental damages, minus expenses saved, and it serves a seller who does not resell.40
- Lost profit (§ 2-708(2)) applies when the market measure is inadequate to put the seller in as good a position as performance would have. It awards the profit, including reasonable overhead, that the seller would have made from full performance by the buyer, with incidental damages, due allowance for costs reasonably incurred, and due credit for payments or proceeds of resale.41
Resale demands care. After proper notice to the buyer, the seller must resell in a commercially reasonable fashion, and the seller must act reasonably, in good faith, and within a reasonable time in making the substitute transaction.42 A seller who does so can price the breach by the actual resale. If S and B contracted for goods at $1,000, B repudiated, and S resold for $800, S recovers $200 plus incidental damages, such as reasonable charges for the care and custody of the goods after the breach, less any expenses the breach saved.43 Sara’s boat gives the same arithmetic on two paths. If she resells for $20,000, she recovers $1,000 plus resale costs less savings; if she does not resell and proves a market price of $20,100 at the time and place of tender, she recovers $900 on the same adjustments.44 The $100 gap exists only because the resale price and the market price differ.
The market measure fixes its price at the time and place for tender. Assume a contract for 100,000 widgets at $1 each, delivery due in Gary on May 1, and a repudiation on April 15. The seller measures against the Gary price on May 1, which is $.90, and not against the $.95 prices quoted on April 15. The recovery is $100,000 minus $90,000, plus no incidental damages, minus the $1,000 of transportation expense the repudiation saved the seller, or $9,000.45
Both the resale and the market measure assume that the substitute sale replaced the lost one. When the seller could have made both sales, the second did not replace the first, and a measure that nets the resale against the contract price returns nothing for the sale the seller lost. Section 2-708(2) exists for that case, and the lost-volume seller recovers the profit it would have made from performance by the breaching buyer.46 The dealer is the standard example. In Neri v. Retail Marine Corp., a retail boat dealer whose buyer backed out and who then sold that boat to another customer recovered its lost profit, because it could have supplied both customers.
The seller who claims lost-volume status must prove it, and the proof has three parts. A resale amounts to lost volume only if the person who bought the resold goods would have been solicited by the seller had there been no breach and resale, the solicitation would have succeeded, and the seller could have performed that additional contract.47 See also .48 Each part blocks a different way the second sale could be a mere substitute. If the second buyer would never have been approached, the breach produced that buyer. If the solicitation would have failed, the second sale did not exist apart from the breach. If the seller lacked capacity for both contracts, the resale simply replaced the first sale. Courts have also extended the doctrine by analogy to volume providers of services.49
Once lost volume is proved, the award includes reasonable overhead as well as profit, because fixed overhead is owed whether the seller makes nine sales or ten, so the lost sale’s contribution to it is part of what the breach took.50
The text of § 2-708(2) adds one hazard, because it allows “due credit for payments or proceeds of resale.” Applied literally to the second customer’s payment, the credit would erase the lost-volume seller’s award. Commentators therefore argue that courts should simply ignore the credit language in lost-volume cases, because only then does § 2-708(2) put the seller in the position performance would have.51
Seller's Incidental Damages
Section 2-710 attaches a list of reaction costs to every remedy an aggrieved seller has. Incidental damages “include any commercially reasonable charges, expenses or commissions incurred in stopping delivery, in the transportation, care and custody of goods after the buyer’s breach, in connection with return or resale of the goods or otherwise resulting from the breach.”53 The list follows the path of goods a buyer has refused. The seller may have to stop a shipment already moving, pay a carrier to haul the goods back, pay a warehouse to hold and insure them, and pay a broker to sell them again.
The section is needed because each primary measure prices the goods and nothing around them. Resale damages are the contract price minus the resale price, market damages are the contract price minus the market price, and an action for the price is simply the price. None of those figures records what the seller spent in getting from the breach to the point where the measure could operate. Article 2 therefore complements every measure with incidental damages, adds them to the price judgment and to the resale and market recoveries, and subtracts any expenses the breach saved.54 The add-on does not depend on the primary measure producing a positive number. A seller who resells at exactly the price the buyer promised has no direct loss, yet still recovers the cost of storing, insuring, and advertising the goods, because none of those expenses would have arisen had the buyer performed.55
Two limits run through the list. Every charge must be commercially reasonable, and every charge must result from the buyer’s breach. The seller picks the carrier, the warehouse, and the broker while the buyer pays, so the reasonableness requirement polices the bills. The causation requirement excludes costs the seller would have borne whether or not the buyer performed, since the remedy reimburses expenses the seller would not have incurred had the buyer performed.56
The second manufacturer’s loss turns on a structural feature of Article 2: the seller has no general category of consequential damages. Some losses that could be called consequential are recoverable as incidental damages or as lost profits, but no general claim exists.57 None of the seller’s formulas includes consequential damages, and treatises accordingly say a seller is not entitled to them, although one commentator calls the point unsettled.58 The buyer’s side differs. A buyer’s loss can extend to profits on a resale or other use of the goods in dealings with third parties, which § 2-715 reaches, while the seller’s measures already price the profit on the sale to the breaching buyer, and even the lost-profit measure of § 2-708(2) reaches only that profit.59
When a seller does suffer a collateral loss, the claim is pushed toward the incidental category, and the closing words of § 2-710 are the usual route. In Dietec Co. v. Osirius Group, the seller sought profits lost in other transactions after its buyer paid late, and also the cost of high-interest financing and other arrangements needed to keep its business running. The court barred the lost profits, which Article 2 does not give a seller, but allowed the financing costs as incidental damages because they were commercially reasonable costs of avoiding loss and coping with the breach.60 Courts divide over interest more generally. The court in St. Paul Structural Steel Co. v. ABI Contracting, Inc. accepted a seller’s interest payments as incidental damages.61 Other courts deny such claims as consequential damages in incidental dress, and Judge Posner concluded that interest on a general business loan not tied to the subject matter of the sale would not be recoverable as either incidental or consequential damages under Wisconsin law.62 The cases sort claims by what the money was spent on. Out-of-pocket costs of coping with the breach are incidental, while profit the seller would have earned in other transactions is consequential and unavailable. An answer should label each item before it prices it.