Concept
The Expectation Formula
Expectation interest (including direct, incidental, and consequential damages)
The Expectation Formula
Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 347 turns the expectation interest into arithmetic, subject to the limits of §§ 350-353.1 The injured party recovers the loss in the value to it of the other party's performance, caused by the failure or deficiency; plus any other loss, including incidental or consequential loss, caused by the breach; less any cost or other loss it has avoided by not having to perform.2 In shorthand:
Expectation damages = loss in value + other loss − cost or loss avoided
The three terms together place the injured party where performance would have: compensated for the benefits it would have received, less the savings it was reasonably able to make by not having to perform.3 Loss in value prices the promised performance itself. Other loss reaches the expenses and harms around the performance. The third term deducts what the breach spared the injured party, so that the plaintiff is never put in a better position than performance would have provided.4 However a court arranges the arithmetic, one part counts the losses the breach caused and another takes account of the savings, gains, and recoupments that ending the contract produced.5
A single sale shows the terms at work. Shawn breaches a contract to sell his SUV to Brianna for $10,000, and the SUV is worth $12,000. Brianna's loss in value is the $12,000 she should have received, the $10,000 she never has to pay is a cost avoided, and her expectation damages are the $2,000 difference, the benefit of her bargain.6 A reasonable fee paid to a broker in an effort to find another vehicle would be added as other loss, whether or not the search succeeded.7
Which term demands the most care depends on who breached. When the paying party breaks the contract, the performing party's loss in value is simply the unpaid sum, and the difficulty lies in finding what the performing party saved. When the performing party breaks the contract, the payer's cost avoided is simply the money it has not yet paid, and the difficulty lies in valuing the performance that failed to arrive.8 Loss in value comes first below because the other two terms adjust it.
Loss in Value
The first term of the formula prices the performance itself. It compares the value to the injured party of the performance that should have been received with the value of whatever was actually received, which is nothing when no performance arrived.9 Lawyers call the result the direct loss, harm to or deprivation of the thing the promisor agreed to provide; a failure to deliver a car or a house is the standard example.10 Every expectation problem starts from this figure, because the other two terms adjust it for surrounding harm and for savings.
A common yardstick for the missing performance is its market value. Market value, measured at the time of performance, is often the basis for computing damages even though it only imperfectly reflects the ideal of compensation.11 The convention survives because it spares the plaintiff from proving precise losses, a task that is often difficult and costly and seldom yields figures anyone can trust.12 A promise to sell shares for $10,000, for example, is measured by the difference between the contract price and the market price of the shares.13
When the market price equals the contract price, the formula yields zero without erasing the claim. A buyer who could have purchased identical shares at the contract price on the delivery date suffers no loss, yet the breach still earns a judgment for nominal damages.14 The party aggrieved by a breach is ordinarily entitled to some remedy, even if only nominal damages, which Restatement (Second) § 346(2) describes as a small sum fixed without regard to the amount of loss.15 A Texas court treated a dollar, ten dollars, or even a hundred as nominal and held that $1,000 was too much.16
When the injured party actually buys a substitute, the substitute transaction shows the loss directly. A buyer whose gasoline seller breached a $50,000 contract, and who paid a third-party supplier $60,000 to obtain the same quantity on time, has expectation damages of $10,000, the difference between what performance would have cost and what the substitute cost.17 For goods, Article 2 codifies this route as the buyer's right to cover, measured by the cover price less the contract price, a remedy a later section develops.18 The actual price stops controlling when it exceeds what a reasonable replacement would have cost. A singer whose coach repudiates a $1,500 lesson contract, and who hires a substitute for $1,800 when equivalent lessons sell for $1,600, recovers $100 and not $300, because the claim is confined to the market rate she could reasonably have found.19 A prompt substitute also confines the loss to the direct difference between the contract price and the substitute's price and keeps the breach from disturbing other planned transactions.20
Deficient performance applies the same comparison with a second value above zero. For nonconforming goods, the loss in value is the value to the buyer of the goods that were to have been delivered less the value of the goods actually delivered, while for goods never tendered it is simply the value of the goods that were to have been tendered.21 In Hawkins v. McGee, a surgeon promised a good hand, and the court compared the hand as promised with the hand that resulted. The pain of the operation played no part in that comparison, because it was part of the price the patient was willing to pay for a good hand and so furnished no test of the hand's value.22 Where the performance can be completed or corrected, the cost of doing so offers an alternative to the difference in value.23
A service contract values the missing performance the same way. The value of a service is usually measured by the cost of replacing it with a substitute,24 so when an employee quits in breach and the employer reasonably hires the only qualified replacement at a higher wage, the extra wage is the employer's loss in value. The breaching employee cannot ordinarily shrink that claim by pointing out that the replacement is better qualified, because the comparison runs between the performance promised and the cost of obtaining it, and the employer need only have sought equivalent services at reasonable cost.25 An employer who breaches by failing to pay owes the unpaid sum, and what the employee earns in a replacement job comes off as a loss avoided, while the costs of finding that job are added back as incidental loss.26 An executive dismissed with a year left on a $200,000 contract, who is idle for six months and then earns $180,000 a year, has a $200,000 loss in value, less $90,000 of replacement pay, or $110,000, plus her job-search costs.
Damages are one remedy among several, and the money measure matters most where the performance can be priced. A treatise on land sales lists, beside damages, liquidated damages, specific performance, vendor's and vendee's liens, and restitution.27 Specific performance orders the breaching party to perform and is usually the best remedy for breach of a land sale contract, because it gives the non-breaching party exactly what she bargained for.28
Incidental Damages
The second term of § 347 reaches past the performance to the expenses that surround it, and incidental loss is its narrower, more mechanical half.30 Incidental damages are the expenses reasonably incurred after the breach in dealing with it: the administrative costs of coping with the breach, protecting and enforcing the injured party's rights, or mitigating its effect, including the cost of arranging substitute performance.31 The comments to § 347 add the cost of a reasonable effort to avoid loss, whether or not the effort succeeds, as where a buyer pays brokerage fees in arranging or attempting to arrange a substitute transaction. For a seller of goods, they include the costs of halting delivery and of transporting, housing, and caring for goods after the recipient's breach.32
These costs need their own term because an award of direct loss can leave the injured party short. Suppose a buyer backs out of a sale and the seller resells the goods for exactly the contract price. The seller has no direct loss, yet she may have stored the goods, insured them, and paid for advertising or an auction, none of which she would have spent had the buyer performed. She must recover those expenses to reach her rightful position.33
Contract law denies recovery for losses the injured party could have avoided,34 and that rule explains why the cost of avoiding a loss is itself recoverable. Avoided losses are not recoverable, but the cost of avoiding them is: a discharged employee who finds a substitute job may recover resumé printing, postage, and cab fare to interviews, none of which would have been incurred but for the wrong, and a pedestrian hit by a car may recover the cost of treatment that prevents permanent disability.35 The test is the reasonableness of the effort and not its success.36
Incidental damages sit close to consequential damages and are easy to confuse with them. The difference lies in where the expense arises. Incidental damages are expenses directly related to the injured party's attempt to manage the breach, while consequential damages arise from the breach's impact on some other transaction or activity that depended on the contract.37 A dressmaker whose contracted assistant backs out of a busy season illustrates the split. The money spent advertising for a replacement is incidental, and the profit lost on customers turned away when no replacement appears is consequential.
Because both items fall within the same term of § 347(b), the label seldom changes the award. The comments call the terms incidental and consequential not controlling and say that all losses, however described, are recoverable.38 The working rule is to count each item once and only once, since leaving it out undercompensates and counting it twice overcompensates.39
Sales law is where the label can decide the result. Article 2 lists an aggrieved seller's incidental damages as the commercially reasonable charges, expenses, or commissions incurred in stopping delivery, in the transportation, care, and custody of goods after the buyer's breach, in connection with return or resale, or otherwise resulting from the breach.40 It lists the buyer's as expenses reasonably incurred in inspecting, receiving, transporting, and caring for goods rightfully rejected, commercially reasonable charges in effecting cover, and any other reasonable expense incident to the delay or other breach.41 In Dietec Co. v. Osirius Group, the court held that Article 2 did not let the seller claim consequential damages, meaning profits lost in other transactions, for the buyer's late payment. It nevertheless allowed the seller's high-interest financing and other arrangements to keep its business running as incidental damages, because they were commercially reasonable costs of avoiding loss and coping with the breach. Had they been classed as consequential, the seller would have recovered nothing for them.42
Causation sets the outer boundary. An expense qualifies as incidental only if the breach caused it, and expectation damages never place the plaintiff in a better position than performance would have.43 A worker promised a job in another city who moves there and is then turned away cannot add the moving expense to the pay and benefits of the lost job, because the worker would have paid for the move had the employer performed. Money spent in preparing to perform belongs instead to the reliance measure, which reimburses out-of-pocket expense and is worth choosing mainly when the contract was a bad deal.44 Job-search costs stand differently, because the search exists only because of the discharge.45 The expense of the lawsuit itself lies outside the category: under the American rule, contract litigants pay their own attorneys' fees and many other litigation costs unless the contract provides otherwise or another traditional exception applies.46
Each expense in an exam fact pattern therefore faces two questions: did the breach cause it, and was it reasonable? An expense that passes both belongs in the other-loss term of § 347(b) whatever its label, and one that fails the first is a cost the injured party would have borne on performance and falls outside the award.
Consequential Damages
Consequential damages cover what the breach does to the injured party's plans for the performance. Direct loss is harm to the thing itself; consequential, or ensuing, loss results from the plaintiff's inability to use the property as intended, as when a buyer meant to resell the goods at a profit or use them in its business.48 It is measured not by the value of the promised performance alone but by the gains the performance could have produced for collateral reasons, or by the loss its absence causes.49 When a defendant fails to repair a factory's machinery as promised, the factory cannot operate and the plaintiff cannot make the profit it otherwise would have made.50
The term exists because replacing a thing does not replace its use. Repairing a damaged car does not compensate for losing the car while repairs proceed, and buying substitute goods may not compensate for going without them between the promised delivery date and the day the buyer manages to cover. Where replacement is impossible, as with many physical injuries, loss of use may be the main element of damage.51 A prompt substitute can eliminate the problem: by buying a replacement, the singer in the preceding section confined her loss to the direct price difference and avoided any adverse effect on her other plans.52
Whether a loss counts as direct or consequential depends on what the promisor undertook. A promise to dig a well at a set price might guarantee that the plaintiff can get the labor without paying more, or it might guarantee that the plaintiff's cattle will have water. If the driller guaranteed water, compensation may include the cattle lost when none was produced; if the driller guaranteed only against a higher price for labor, compensation is the cost of having another driller dig the well.53 The parties' relationship, the economic setting, the business structure, and even business culture bear on the scope of the promise.54
Lost profit is the most common consequential claim, but the label alone does not settle the category. Profit the plaintiff would have made on the contract that was breached is direct, or general, damage, recoverable without a showing of foreseeability and often easier to prove with reasonable certainty. Profit from a collateral contract is consequential and must meet the foreseeability test.55 The rent a commercial-property buyer expected to collect is a typical consequential loss.56 In a cabinet dispute, the buyer argued that the manufacturer's lost profit should be measured by the four days its factory stood idle. The court answered that the relevant inquiry was the profit on the deal as a whole, and that the shutdown period bore on consequential damages instead.57
The vocabulary descends from Hadley v. Baxendale, in which millers whose mill stopped when a crank shaft broke lost profits because delivery of the replacement shaft was delayed.58 Courts apply Hadley's two prongs by treating profit on the contract itself as general damages and profit from collateral dealings as consequential.59 The phrase special damages causes confusion, because in tort it means money losses such as medical expenses and lost wages, while in contract it describes remote, hard-to-prove items such as lost profits, and the market measures are called general damages. The safer practice is to speak of direct and consequential loss and to define the terms.60
The classification decides cases when a contract excludes consequential damages. In Applied Data Processing, Inc. v. Burroughs Corp., some of the buyer's losses occurred only because it had its existing records on IBM and went back to IBM when the seller's equipment failed. The court found them consequential. The seller would likely have been liable for them, since it had reason to know the special facts before the contract was made, but the contract excluded consequential damages, so the buyer recovered nothing for them.61 Article 2 sets a drafting trap here: § 2-715(2) states some but not all of what makes damages consequential.62 A court that treats its words as a complete definition may find that ordinary-course damages satisfy them too, and a clause excluding consequential damages would then strip out direct damages along with consequential.63 Contract provisions that exclude some elements of damages but not others deserve close reading for the same reason.64
Double counting is the other hazard, because market value often capitalizes the same earnings that a lost-profits claim measures. A machine's market value can be estimated by the present value of the income it would produce, and an apartment building is worth essentially its expected net rents, so awarding both the market value and those profits pays for the same income twice.65
Even a well-classified consequential claim must clear two gates. The loss must be proved with reasonable certainty, and it must be of the general kind the parties contemplated at the time of contracting; damages outside that contemplation are not recoverable even when clearly proved.66 The next section takes up both.
Costs and Losses Avoided
The third term of the formula subtracts. Section 347(c) deducts any cost or other loss the injured party has avoided by not having to perform.68 The first two terms add up what the breach took, and this term credits what the breach handed back. The rightful-position standard places the plaintiff where she would have stood had the wrong not occurred, not better and not worse, so a loss she has avoided cannot be recovered.69
Consider a seller whose buyer repudiates before the seller performs. Had the contract been performed, the seller would have received the price and given up the performance. An award of the full price would let her keep both, a better position than performance would have given her, so she recovers the price less the value of the performance she retains.70 The buyer's claim runs the same way in reverse: the buyer recovers the cost of a substitute only after subtracting the price it no longer owes.71 Tanya contracted to paint Eric's house for $10,000 and expected to spend $9,000, and Eric breached before she began. She was entitled to expect $10,000, but the breach spared her $9,000 in costs, so she recovers her net expectation of $1,000.72
The deduction has two parts that arise in different ways. Suppose a seller is to manufacture two products and the buyer repudiates after the first is made. The saving from not making the second is cost avoided, and the saving from selling the first to another buyer is loss avoided.73 A discharged employee's replacement wages are likewise a loss avoided.74 Both parts come off the award, so on most problems the label matters less than catching each saving exactly once.
A contractor stopped partway shows the subtraction on a profitable job. A contractor who agreed to build a house for $100,000 at an expected cost of $80,000, and who is stopped by repudiation before spending anything, recovers only the $20,000 profit, because the $80,000 of expected cost is avoided entirely.75 If the owner repudiates after the contractor has spent $50,000, only the remaining $30,000 of cost is avoided, and damages are the $100,000 price less $30,000, or $70,000. The more performance remains when the breach occurs, the more of the price savings offset, and the recovery approaches pure profit.
The same $70,000 emerges from the other direction: $50,000 already spent plus $20,000 of lost profit. Courts use the profit-plus-costs-incurred method and a method that prorates the price by the share of work done interchangeably, because they almost always produce the same result.76 The outlay-plus-profit version has a practical advantage. In a cabinet dispute, the court approved an award of the manufacturer's lost profit together with the direct expenses it had incurred making the cabinets, because awarding profit alone would have forced the manufacturer to pay those expenses out of the profit it was owed.77
The equivalence holds only when the contract was profitable. Suppose the price is $10,000, the contractor has spent $5,000, and finishing would have cost $10,000 more. Price less cost avoided is zero, the correct compensatory result, since the breach cost the contractor nothing it would otherwise have kept; the profit-plus-costs method would instead award the $5,000 already spent. To say the contractor has no damages is not to say there is no recovery, because restitution for unjust enrichment may remain available.78
A harder question arises in a business, because not every cost on the books is one the breach saved. Variable costs, typically the wages and materials tied to a project, rise and fall with business volume, and the breach reduces or eliminates them. Fixed costs, or overhead, are obligations the firm owes as long as it stays in business whatever its volume, such as rent under a long lease, interest owed to bondholders, real estate taxes, and salaries owed to top managers under long-term contracts.79 Only the variable kind counts as cost avoided. Vitex Manufacturing Corp. v. Caribtex Corp. affirmed a $21,114 award on that reasoning. The court held that overhead should be treated as part of gross profit recoverable as damages and not as part of the seller's costs, since the seller's overhead bore no direct relationship to any particular transaction and would have been the same whether or not the contract was made.80
The arithmetic shows why. Suppose performance would have yielded $21,000 above the variable costs it required, and $8,000 of factory rent is owed to the landlord either way. The manufacturer recovers $21,000, the expected revenue less the variable costs avoided. Treating the rent as an added cost avoided would credit the breaching buyer with an $8,000 share of the gross profit the manufacturer expected to earn. The landlord has the prior claim on that gross profit, the manufacturer's owner takes the $13,000 that remains, and the breaching buyer has no place in the line of takers.81
A variable cost reduces the award only to the extent the breach actually saved it, because the injured party is compensated for the benefits it would have received less the savings it was reasonably able to make by not having to perform.82 Money already spent has not been saved, and neither has an obligation the injured party cannot escape without liability, as where it hired someone for the job on terms that make cancellation cost the full fee.83 The word reasonably cuts the other way too. Contract law denies recovery for losses the injured party could have avoided after the breach,84 so a contractor who finishes a job after a clear repudiation ordinarily recovers the price less the cost of the unnecessary finishing work, the same figure stopping would have produced.
Savings take other forms besides costs. However a court structures the calculation, it counts the losses the breach caused and subtracts the savings, gains, and recoupments the injured party made as a result of the contract's termination.85 Whether another job counts as a substitute depends on whether it replaces the lost performance. Contractors who can add laborers and work many sites at once are treated as lost-volume sellers, so profit on other jobs is not subtracted and the court awards the price on the breached job.86