Concept
Rescission and the Pre-Existing Duty Rule
Rescission
Rescission and the Pre-Existing Duty Rule
A party who wants more money for the same work runs into the pre-existing duty rule. A promise to pay extra for performance already owed lacks consideration, because the performer gives nothing new in return.1 Rescission offers a way around the rule. An agreement of rescission is one in which each party agrees to discharge all of the other party's remaining duties under an existing contract,2 so a genuine rescission leaves no old duty standing. The performer can then say that the parties rescinded the first contract and made a second at the higher price. If that is true, no duty pre-existed, and the new promise rests on a fresh bargain.3
The New Hampshire rock-excavation case shows the argument at work. A contractor agreed to excavate a cellar for a stated price and then struck solid rock that neither side had expected. The parties agreed to a higher, fair price for removing the rock, and the contractor finished the job. The court treated the old price term as discharged by agreement and enforced the new promise, so the contractor did not sue on a modification of a duty already owed. The first step of that reasoning is the easy one. Both sides still owed performance when the deal was reworked, and a party who has not fully performed and who manifests assent to discharge the other's duty discharges it to that extent without consideration.4 Releasing the old price term therefore raises no consideration problem of its own.
The difficulty comes at the second step. Once the old term is gone, everything depends on the new bargain, and in the new bargain the contractor promises only to excavate the cellar, the work he was already bound to do. If reciting rescinded and new contract were enough, any party bound to perform could escape the pre-existing duty rule by getting the other side to sign a sentence, and the rule would catch only the careless. A label states the result the parties want. It does not show that either side gave anything new. Courts therefore divide. Some readily find a rescission and a new contract whenever the facts permit that reading, while others ask whether the parties really relinquished the old bargain and whether the adjustment is fair.5 Two pressures pull against each other here. Parties to a continuing relationship need room to adjust a contract when circumstances change, but a promise to pay more for the same performance gives the promisor nothing new and can disguise pressure.
Both cases use the vocabulary of rescission, but the facts beneath it differ. In the rock case, the parties met a condition neither had anticipated and agreed to a fair adjustment, which amounts to a real relinquishment of the old price. In the painter case, nothing has changed except the painter's leverage, so the recital describes a relinquishment that never happened in substance.
Two doctrines reach the rock result directly, without the fiction of a rescission. Under the unforeseen-difficulties rule of Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 89(a), a promise modifying a duty under a contract not fully performed on either side is binding if the modification is fair and equitable in view of circumstances the parties did not anticipate when the contract was made.7 The rule's illustration is an excavator who meets unexpected solid rock and orally agrees to remove it at a reasonable unit price far above the original rate. The owner is bound to pay the higher amount.8
The second route is forbearance. A contractor who was entitled to stop performing because of a mistake, and who continues anyway, has done something he was not obliged to do, and that continued performance is consideration for the added payment. Even a contractor whose mistake claim was too weak to justify stopping gives consideration by refraining from asserting a good-faith belief that he was free to stop.9 Each route asks what the owner actually received for the higher price, and that is the question a rescission label cannot answer.
A higher price that clears the consideration hurdle can still fail for another reason. In the painter facts, the painter threatened non-performance in bad faith to extract the extra $2,200, and a promise obtained that way is 'extorted' from the owner.10 Apparent assent obtained by coercion that amounts to duress can be defeated, and the resulting contract avoided.11 The pre-existing duty rule and duress each receive fuller treatment elsewhere. What matters here is that a rescission recital answers neither question.