Concept
Novation in Common Settings
Novation
Novation in Common Settings
The Restatement (Second) of Contracts defines a novation as a substituted contract that includes as a party one who was neither the obligor nor the obligee of the original duty.1 A substituted contract is one that the obligee accepts in satisfaction of the obligor's existing duty,2 and once made it discharges that duty. A later breach of the substituted contract gives the obligee no right to enforce the original duty.3 Everything in a novation therefore depends on the obligee's acceptance.
Nobody in a real transaction announces a novation. The party who wants out acts through some other event, such as forming a business, moving out of rented space, selling a house, or selling insured property, and whether anyone was released has to be read from facts gathered for another purpose. Each of the four settings below has the same cast: an original party who wants out, a newcomer who takes over, and a counterpart who holds a promise from a particular person. The transfer moves performance to the newcomer. It moves liability only if the counterpart agrees to the substitution, which is the lesson of the delegation material above that consent to a newcomer's performance is not release.
The settings differ in who the counterpart is and in which of its words or acts is most likely to be mistaken for a release.
| Setting | Original party | Newcomer | Whose agreement completes the novation | What is not enough |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Promoter's contract | Promoter | Corporation | The third party | The corporation's formation or adoption of the contract |
| Lease | Tenant | Assignee or subtenant | The landlord | The landlord's consent to the transfer |
| Mortgage | Seller (mortgagor) | Buyer | The lender (mortgagee) | Deeding the equity to the buyer, even with the buyer's promise to pay |
| Property insurance | Seller (insured) | Buyer | The insurer | The sale of the insured property |
The first setting is the one in which the newcomer does not yet exist when the original duty is made.
Promoters and Corporations
A promoter sometimes has to commit before the corporation exists. The incorporator may not have finished creating the entity, and the promoter does not want to lose a lease, or a purchase of machinery at a desirable price, by waiting.4 A contract signed on behalf of a corporation that has not yet been formed is a pre-incorporation contract, and it raises the question who is liable on it.5 In novation terms, the third party is the obligee, the promoter is the obligor, and the corporation is the newcomer who may or may not be allowed to take her place.
The promoter begins as a party. Whether she is liable turns on the parties' intent, and a careful lease says so, for instance by providing that the third party may enforce the lease only against the corporation once it is formed. If the lease is silent, courts generally hold the promoter liable as a party, especially if the corporation is never formed, because although she purported to act for a corporation, none existed when she acted.6 Statutes add little certainty. No American jurisdiction has a statute dealing specifically with promoters' contracts.7 The 2016 Model Business Corporation Act makes all persons purporting to act as or on behalf of a corporation, knowing there was no incorporation, jointly and severally liable for liabilities created while so acting, but the effect of such provisions on promoters' contracts is unclear.8
The corporation does not become liable by coming into existence. Mere formation does not make the entity liable on the contract, and it is liable only if it adopts the contract. Adoption may be express, by an act of the board of directors, or implied from conduct, as when a newly formed company moves into the leased space and thereby accepts a benefit of the lease.9 Adoption adds an obligor without removing one, and even after the corporation adopts, the promoter remains liable until a novation.10
Suppose Patti, a promoter for XYZ Corp., finds an office available from Third Party (TP) at a good price. She signs the lease 'Patti' on April 7, and XYZ Corp. is formed on April 10. Patti is a party to the lease and is liable on it. If the corporation were never formed, she would remain liable for the rent. If it is formed, she remains liable until a novation, which is an agreement among TP, the corporation, and Patti that the corporation will replace her under the contract.11
That result follows from the definition. TP's agreement is what makes the corporation a newcomer to a substituted contract, and when that contract is made it discharges Patti's duty, so a later default by the corporation leaves TP a claim on the new agreement and gives TP no right to enforce the original duty.12 Without TP's agreement, the corporation's moving in and TP's accepting its rent show only that TP took the corporation's performance. They do not show that TP agreed to look to the corporation alone, which is the same sorting that governed delegation.
The third party's agreement can be written into the contract from the start, and the sources show why a third party might give it. Dealing with a corporation that does not yet exist carries added risks, and the novation arrangement eliminates them while leaving the risk every corporate creditor accepts, that the corporation will not have the money to pay. It does this without giving the third party a personal guarantee of the kind corporate creditors must specially demand, so it seems a logical reading of what the parties would have agreed.13 The rebuttal is that a third party dealing with an existing corporation can check its finances and cannot do so before the corporation exists, so one might argue that only a contract leaving the promoter bound until complete performance removes the added risks.14 Because the argument runs both ways, a clear clause is what settles the question.
The two leases involve the same corporate steps: formation, written adoption, then default. What differs is the third party's agreement to look only to the corporation, which Dev's owner gave in the lease and Marta's owner never gave. A promoter who wants out should get that agreement in writing, and a third party who wants the promoter's liability to survive adoption should avoid any word that could be read as a release.
Lease Transfers
A tenant who transfers a lease passes the premises to someone else but cannot pass the liability without the landlord's agreement. The reason is privity of contract, the direct contractual relationship that a lease creates between landlord and tenant. That relationship does not exist between the landlord and a tenant's assignee or sublessee. It also survives the transfer: privity of contract continues between landlord and tenant after the tenant assigns or sublets and vacates, unless the landlord expressly agrees to substitute the transferee and to look only to the transferee for the rent and for satisfaction of all obligations under the lease.16 That substitution is a novation, so a tenant who wants to avoid liability for rent after the transfer must obtain the landlord's release from any continuing obligations under the lease.17 If the landlord, the tenant, and the transferee agree that the transferee replaces the tenant, the arrangement is a substituted contract with a newcomer as a party, and it discharges the tenant's duties when it is made.18
The form of the transfer changes the paperwork but not this result. Courts look to the language of the transfer document and to its term, generally finding an assignment when the balance of the term is transferred and a sublease when less is.19 After a sublease the landlord has neither privity of contract nor privity of estate with the subtenant, so an action for rent or other breach of the lease runs against the original tenant, with whom the landlord remains in privity of contract.20
The landlord's consent to a transfer answers a different question from release. Consent does not implicitly terminate the privity of contract between the original parties to the lease.21 Leases often prohibit an assignment or sublease without the landlord's consent, and those restraints are generally upheld, although many leases, or the law, require that consent not be unreasonably withheld.22 A landlord who gives permission, perhaps because it had to, has agreed about who may occupy the premises. It has not agreed to give up its claim against the person who promised the rent. A landlord who wants more security can condition its consent on the assignee's agreeing to pay the rent, which creates privity of contract between landlord and assignee.23 That condition adds an obligor and removes none.
On an exam, a stem that reports the landlord's written approval or knowledge of the new occupant has described consent to the transfer and has not yet described a release. The question is whether the landlord agreed with the tenant and the transferee to look only to the transferee. Without that agreement, the tenant stays on the lease contract whether the transfer was an assignment or a sublease.
Mortgage Assumptions
The sale of mortgaged land puts all three novation roles on stage at once. The lender is the obligee, the seller who borrowed the money is the obligor, and the buyer is a stranger to the original duty, which makes the buyer the newcomer in the definition.25 A mortgage gives the lender, the mortgagee, an interest in the real estate to secure repayment of the loan, and it establishes an obligation running from the mortgagor, the owner of the mortgaged property, to the mortgagee. Deeds of trust are generally handled the same way.26
Selling the land does not carry the debt with it. If the mortgagor deeds an equity interest to someone else, the mortgagee keeps its security interest in the land and keeps its claim on the obligation against the original mortgagor. The mortgagor remains liable until released or until the obligation is paid, and at that point the mortgagee surrenders the mortgage and executes a discharge, which is recorded.27 A voluntary agreement among the seller, the buyer, and the mortgagee releases the original mortgagor, and that agreement is a novation.28 It is a substituted contract that the lender accepts in satisfaction of the seller's duty, so it discharges that duty when made, and a later default by the buyer gives the lender no right to enforce the original duty.29
That is why sellers are generally better off not letting a third party take over their mortgage: if the third party later defaults, the seller remains liable.30 A buyer's own commitment does not change this. A buyer who assumes the mortgage pays the seller the difference between the amount of the mortgage and the selling price, and also agrees to be personally liable on the debt, so the buyer is liable upon default.31 The seller stays liable as well unless a novation has occurred. Assumption is a promise from buyer to seller, however binding between the two of them, and it adds an obligor. It is not an agreement with the lender that the lender will look only to the buyer.
A cooperative lender is the usual trap. A lender that learns of the sale and keeps accepting the buyer's payments has taken the buyer's performance and nothing more. A novation requires the lender's agreement to accept the buyer as obligor and to release the seller.
The fact that separates the two sales is whether the lender agreed to look only to the buyer. In the first sale the lender's year of accepted checks shows consent to the buyer's performance and nothing more. In the second, the lender, seller, and buyer all assented to the substitution, and the discharge took effect when the agreement was made. A seller who wants out of a mortgage therefore needs the lender's agreement, and the buyer's assumption cannot supply it.
Insurance Policy Transfers
Coverage under a property insurance policy does not travel with the property, because the policy is a personal contract: the insurer is entitled to choose the person with whom it contracts, in order to decrease the moral hazard. A property insurer assumes the risk of its insured's carelessness but not the risk that the insured will destroy the property on purpose to collect the proceeds.33 For the same reason, a policy of property insurance generally cannot be assigned without the insurer's consent, and most policies contain non-assignment clauses.34
So when A sells her residence to B during the policy term and moves out, B is not covered by A's homeowner's policy.35 The omission is dangerous on both sides. Without the insurer's consent the insurance may not pass to the new owner, and because the original owner no longer has an insurable interest after the sale, the insurance could become void.36 Here the buyer is a stranger to the policy, neither the insurer who owes coverage nor the insured who is owed it, and the buyer becomes a party only if the insurer agrees.
The result changes when the insurer joins the transfer. If A, A's insurer, and B all agree that B is substituted for A as the insured once B assumes ownership, B is covered, and contract law calls that arrangement a novation.37 The insurer's assent supplies what the sale could not. An assignment made with the insurer's consent has the same effect, creating in effect a novation, and the assignee takes what amounts to a newly formed contract, free of defenses the insurer had against the prior policyholder.38 A stem that reports a sale of insured property, and a buyer who has moved in, has therefore not said that the buyer is covered. The answer turns on whether the insurer agreed with both owners to accept the buyer as the insured.
Shifts of rights short of that agreement fall short of a novation. If an assignment is attempted without the insurer's consent, many courts hold it void as to the insurer but valid between assignor and assignee as an assignment of proceeds. The assignor remains the insured and the policy continues, absent a contrary provision, although in some situations an unconsented assignment may void the whole policy.39 An assignment to a mortgagee or lien holder as collateral security does not work a complete novation either, because the original policyholder keeps an interest as an insured and receives any proceeds beyond the secured debt. The assignee's interest therefore stays subject to defenses the insurer had against the original policyholder and did not know of when it consented. The insurer is, however, estopped to assert a defense of which it was on notice at the time of consent against an assignee who took without notice of it.40 In both arrangements the original insured is still an insured, whereas a novation puts the newcomer in the original party's place.