Concept
Novation and the Suretyship Clause
Novation
Novation and the Suretyship Clause
The Statute of Frauds requires a signed writing for a promise by a surety or guarantor to a creditor to pay the debt or perform the obligation of a principal debtor, when the creditor has reason to know of the surety relationship.1 A surety is primarily liable, as a joint obligor, for another's debt or obligation, while a guarantor is liable only if the other fails to meet the obligation.2 The writing rule reaches both, and this chapter calls it the suretyship clause. A co-signer on a loan is the familiar surety.3 A novation puts the clause under strain, because a newcomer promises a creditor to pay what someone else owes, and the promise sounds like a surety's. The promise falls outside the clause.
The clause has a cautionary purpose. Writing requirements slow down those subject to them, and it is easy to promise offhandedly to guarantee a loan without appreciating how serious the consequences may be. A signed writing gives the promisor a chance to reconsider a well-meaning but reckless promise. The risk is greatest with sureties, because many are not paid for their promises, and a promise that does not feel businesslike is less likely to be made with businesslike caution.4 Each of these points assumes a promisor who stands behind a debt that someone else owes.
A novation is a substituted contract that includes as a party one who was neither the obligor nor the obligee of the original duty.5 The substituted contract discharges the original duty, and breach of the substituted contract does not give the obligee a right to enforce the original duty.6 Consider a tenant case. The new owner of a business promises the landlord to pay the rent, and the landlord agrees in exchange to release the former tenant from the remaining obligations. The landlord has accepted a promise in satisfaction and discharge of a third party's existing obligation, which is not a suretyship arrangement. The parties have removed one original party and substituted a newcomer, so the new contract runs between only the new owner and the landlord, and it discharges the former tenant.7
The clause protects a promisor who answers for a duty that another person still owes, and a novation leaves no such person. The newcomer becomes a party to the substituted contract, the original duty is discharged, and the newcomer is the only one left to answer for the debt.8 The newcomer's promise is made in exchange for the debtor's release; it does not stand behind the debtor's continuing liability.9
A practical reason points the same way. Some treatments list novation as the first exception to the clause rather than as a case outside it, and the reason for the exception is simple. If the newcomer's promise discharges the original obligor, and a court then held that promise collateral, and so unenforceable without a writing, the creditor could collect from neither.10 Whether one says the promise is outside the clause or within an exception, no writing is required.
A true guarantee keeps the debtor liable. Suppose a promisor tells the owner of a shoe store to sell a pair of shoes to X and says the promisor will pay. No writing is required, because that is the promisor's primary promise and guarantees no one else's obligation. If the promisor instead says the shoes may be sold to X and that the promisor will pay if X does not, the promise is collateral to X's primary liability. The promisor is a surety or guarantor, the promise is within the statute of frauds, and it needs a signed writing.11 No earlier debt is extinguished in either version, so neither promisor is a newcomer replacing a discharged debtor. The pair still frames the sorting question: in the first version the promisor owes the price, and in the second X owes it and the promisor stands behind X.
Step two decides most cases, because the words of the promise are the same on both sides of the line. A newcomer who says the loan will be paid may be offering to replace the debtor or to back the debtor. The deciding fact is whether the creditor agreed to look only to the newcomer and released the debtor, the same fact that separates novation from delegation. A promise that does fall within the clause may still escape the writing requirement under a separate exception. The requirement does not apply when the promisor's main purpose is to obtain an immediate and direct economic benefit or advantage for himself.12