Concept
Elements of a Valid Novation
Novation
Elements of a Valid Novation
A novation discharges the original obligor completely, so the law asks for more than a new face at the table. An obligee who agrees to one gives up a claim against a known obligor and takes in its place a claim against someone new. A novation is a substituted contract that includes as a party one who was neither the obligor nor the obligee of the original duty,1 and like any substituted contract it discharges the original duty. If the new contract is later breached, the obligee has no right to enforce the old duty.2 Whether a particular three-party arrangement reaches that result depends on four elements:3
- There must be a prior valid obligation for the new agreement to discharge.
- The obligee, the original obligor, and the newcomer must all agree.
- The parties must apparently intend to extinguish the old duties immediately.
- The new contract must be valid and enforceable, and the obligee's assent to the discharge must rest on consideration or one of its substitutes.
The fourth element carries the Restatement's rule on assent to discharge, which accepts consideration or one of two substitutes: circumstances in which a promise would be enforceable without consideration,4 or action or forbearance that the assent induced.5
The elements are cumulative. If any one is missing, no discharge occurs and the original obligor stays liable. A stem that shows a newcomer stepping into the obligor's place has therefore not finished the analysis. The quickest way to finish it is to take the elements in order, beginning with the one that every other element presupposes: a duty to discharge.
A Prior Valid Obligation
A novation discharges a duty, so a duty must exist to be discharged. A substituted contract is one the obligee accepts in satisfaction of the obligor's existing duty,6 and a novation is a substituted contract that adds a newcomer as a party.7 The word existing carries the first element: there must be a previous obligation.8 The substituted contract then discharges that duty,9 and only a duty that binds someone when the new agreement is made can be ended.
The reasoning reaches every person the old duty touched. The obligee's acceptance of the newcomer surrenders a claim, and a person with no claim has nothing to surrender. The original obligor's exit is a release from a duty, and a person who never owed anything has nothing to be released from. When the duty is missing, a three-party document may still have whatever effect its own terms support as a new contract, but it discharges nothing.
The window-washing arrangement supplies the standard picture. Harry's one-year contract to wash Al's windows once a week for $100 is the prior obligation. Al sells his store to Betty, and when Al, Betty, and Harry meet, the contract between Harry and Al is still running.10 Al can leave with no further rights or duties only because there was a contract for the new agreement to extinguish. A fact pattern without that starting point looks different.
Suppose instead that John and Jane had made a binding contract for the sale before the three signed. The same document would then discharge Jane's duty, provided the other elements were met, because a valid duty would exist for it to end. The paper, the signatures, and the newcomer are identical in both versions; the whole difference lies in the original contract. A label does not settle the classification, so the first question to ask of any claimed novation is whether the original deal was ever a binding contract. The element usually passes without argument, because the original contract is typically undisputed. It decides the case only when the facts describe negotiations that never produced a binding agreement.
Agreement of All Parties
A novation changes the legal position of three people at once, so all three must agree. A novation is a substituted contract that includes a newcomer as a party,12 and the standard statement of the elements requires the mutual agreement of all parties to the old and the new contract.13 Two of the three cannot arrange the matter for the third. The obligee's assent comes first, because the obligee holds the claim that the novation extinguishes.
An obligee cannot be forced to trade one obligor for another. When a substitution materially changes the obligee's rights, the obligee need not accept the substitute's performance, and an obligor who tries to cast off the duty commits a breach.14 Even when the obligee has no substantial interest in the obligor's own performance, an obligee who never released the obligor can sue the obligor as well as the substitute if the substitute fails to perform.15 The rule has to work this way. If delegating a duty freed the delegator, every solvent person could escape debts by delegating them to an insolvent.16
What the obligee assents to has two parts, and both are required. The obligee must accept the newcomer as the person responsible for the duty, and the obligee must release the original obligor. When all three parties agree to substitute one obligor for another and to release the original obligor, the resulting contract is a novation.17 The release is the part that ends the claim against the original obligor, so it is the part an obligee cannot be taken to have given casually. A creditor can be glad to have a second source of payment and can say so; without a release, the original obligor stays bound.
The original obligor's assent is easy to overlook because the release works in that person's favor. The original obligor still gives something up. When Al, Betty, and Harry agree that Betty replaces Al, Al loses his right to have his windows washed, Harry loses his right to collect from Al, and Betty becomes obligated to pay for the washing.18 Al therefore has to agree to the trade, even though the release is the piece of it that benefits him.
The newcomer's assent completes the set. Nobody becomes bound to a duty by other people's agreement, and the newcomer must be a party to the substituted contract. Betty becomes liable to Harry only because she herself undertakes to pay him.19
The three assents can sound alike in ordinary conversation, which is why the window-washing facts can be read two ways. When Al sold the store, he introduced Betty to Harry, and the three agreed that Harry would keep washing windows under the contract for Betty. The evidence about the conversation will probably be vague and contradictory: Al said something about being happy to be relieved of further concerns about the store, and Harry said something about being pleased to deal with Betty. The question arises if Betty fails to pay and Harry looks to Al.20
On one reading, Al was telling Harry that he had assigned his rights and delegated his duties to Betty, and Harry was saying he did not object. Al then remains liable as a delegator, because Harry never manifested assent to releasing him from liability on the contract. Harry would have had no right to object to the assignment and delegation on these facts, and telling him was a customary courtesy, so his reply shows acquiescence and nothing more.21 On the other reading, Al and Betty were proposing that Betty would assume liability on the contract if Harry would release Al, and Harry's expression of approval accepted the proposal. That reading produces a novation. Al has no further rights or duties, because Harry agreed to accept Betty as the sole party responsible for paying him.22
The words are the same under both readings. What differs is whether Harry's approval answered an offer to substitute Betty for Al, so the fact to look for is whether the obligee manifested agreement to look to the newcomer alone. A stem that reports only that the obligee was pleased with the newcomer, or raised no objection, reports assent to the newcomer's performance. The original obligor stays liable until a release is shown.
Immediate Extinguishment
Discharge by novation takes effect when the new agreement is made, not when the newcomer later performs. A substituted contract discharges the original duty,24 and the third element asks whether the parties apparently intended the duties under the old contract to end immediately.25 The question is one of timing. The obligee may accept the newcomer's promise and release the original obligor at once, or the obligee may agree only to take the newcomer's performance and keep the old claim alive until it arrives. Only the first arrangement is a novation.
The timing decides who bears the risk of the newcomer's default. After a novation the old duty is already gone, so a default leaves the obligee with a claim on the new agreement alone.26 Where discharge waits for performance, an unpaid obligee may sue on the new agreement or on the original obligation, which has not yet been discharged.27 An obligee may take a newcomer's promise as an additional source of payment without meaning to surrender the first, so the law asks for evidence that the obligee meant the old duties to end now.
Parties rarely announce which arrangement they mean, so intent is read from the entire circumstances.28 The inquiry that separates a substituted contract from an accord applies here, because a novation is a substituted contract with a newcomer added. Replacement is the likelier reading when the contract is still executory on both sides and both parties' duties are being changed. Acceptance of different performance without discharge is the likelier reading when the obligor is struggling or already in breach and the obligee is trying to salvage what it can.29 Neither circumstance settles the matter alone; the question remains whether the obligee agreed to an immediate discharge.
Harry's assent in the window-washing arrangement illustrates the first reading. He accepts Betty as the sole party responsible for payment, and that assent discharges Al on the spot, with no condition attached to it in the facts.30 The same pattern appears when a landlord releases a former tenant in exchange for the business's new owner's promise to pay the rent: the release is the price of the newcomer's promise, and it is given along with it.31 Later sections of this chapter take up how the suretyship rule treats that promise.
An arrangement in which the original duty is discharged only on performance, often performance by a third person, is an executory accord. It is a separate category, mentioned here to mark the boundary.32
The landlord in that scene is as willing to deal with Nina as Harry is to deal with Betty, and Nina pays rent just as Betty pays for the washing. The one fact that moves the answer is the moment of release: Harry gives it at the meeting, and the landlord postponed it until a year of payments had been made. A creditor who postpones the release keeps the original obligor as a fallback, and a creditor who gives it at once has chosen to look only to the newcomer. The last element asks whether the new contract is itself valid and whether the obligee's assent to the discharge is supported by consideration.
Valid New Contract and Consideration
A novation discharges the original duty only if the obligee's assent to the discharge is effective, and the Restatement states when it is. Except for situations it treats separately, an obligee's manifestation of assent to a discharge is not effective unless one of three conditions is met.34 The assent must be made for consideration,35 or be made in circumstances in which a promise would be enforceable without consideration,36 or have induced action or forbearance that would make a promise enforceable.37 The three are alternatives, and a novation ordinarily satisfies the first through the structure of the transaction itself.
The requirement exists because a discharge gives up something valuable. If a bare statement of assent could end a claim, a creditor's passing word of sympathy might wipe out a debt, and no one could tell whether the claim was gone. So the law asks of a release what it asks of a promise: the assent must rest on a bargain, on circumstances that make a promise binding without one, or on the reliance the assent produced. An obligee who bargains for a release gives the assent real force, and the person released can count on it.
The Restatement rule governs the obligee's assent, and it works alongside the fourth element, that the new contract be valid and enforceable.38 The obligee gives up a claim against a known obligor in return for the newcomer's undertaking. If the undertaking could not be enforced, the obligee would have traded a real claim for nothing, so what replaces the old duty must be a duty the law will enforce.
Most novations satisfy the first route. The obligee releases the original obligor, the newcomer promises to perform, and the newcomer's promise is the consideration for the release.39 In the window-washing arrangement each side of the exchange is visible. Al has lost his right to have his windows washed, Harry has lost his right to collect from Al, and Betty has become obligated to pay for the washing, so each of the three has incurred a legal detriment and the consideration requirement is met.40 The same exchange appears when a landlord releases a former tenant in return for the business's new owner's promise to pay the rent.41 The separate category called novation was traced to consideration problems thought to arise from the old common-law rule that consideration must be supplied by the promisee. That rule has long been abandoned almost everywhere, and the problem went with it.42
The second route looks away from bargain altogether. An assent to discharge is effective if it is made in circumstances in which a promise would be enforceable without consideration.43 Contract law already enforces certain promises that no one bargained for, and a release that would bind if framed as a promise has no reason to be weaker than the promise. The rules that make promises binding without consideration decide which circumstances qualify. Because the newcomer's promise usually supplies consideration, this route matters mainly where the exchange is missing.
The third route supplies reliance. An assent is effective if it has induced action or forbearance that would make a promise enforceable.44 A person who changed position because the obligee said the original obligor was released did so on the strength of that assent, and letting the obligee retract afterward would shift the loss onto the person who relied.
Because the routes are alternatives, an answer can run them in the order in which novations usually satisfy them and stop at the first one that holds.
Add one fact, that Betty promises to pay Harry $100 a week in return for the release, and the first route is met at once. A stem that reports only friendly or forgiving words from the obligee has not yet described an effective discharge.