Concept
Executory Accord Contrasted
Substituted contract and substituted performance
Executory Accord Contrasted
An accord resembles a substituted contract on the surface. In each, a debtor who owes one performance makes a deal with the creditor to render a different one instead.1 The three devices differ in what the creditor accepts and in when the old duty ends. In a substituted contract, the creditor accepts the new promise itself, so the original duty is discharged when the new contract is made, and the obligor's later breach gives the obligee no right to enforce the original duty.2 In a substituted performance, the creditor accepts a different performance in place of what was due, and the duty is discharged by that acceptance.3 In an accord, the creditor promises to accept a stated performance in satisfaction of the existing duty, and the original duty is discharged only when that performance is rendered.4
Only the accord holds the old duty in place while the new performance is pending. The two subsections below follow that interval: first what the suspension of the old duty means for each party, then what follows when either party breaks the accord.
Suspension Until Satisfaction
A owes B $7,000, and A offers fifty tons of hay in place of the money. B accepts. Unless the parties clearly manifested an intent to discharge the money duty at once, they have made an accord, and the agreement does not discharge A's duty to pay $7,000.5 Acceptance of the offer only forms the accord. The satisfaction is the delivery. When A delivers the hay and B takes it, the satisfaction discharges A's original obligation to pay $7,000 and also A's obligation to deliver the hay, so one event ends both duties.6 The Restatement states both steps: the accord is the obligee's promise to accept a stated performance in satisfaction of the existing duty, and performance of the accord is what discharges the original duty.7 That performance is the satisfaction and the agreement that promised it is the accord, which is why the two terms travel together.8
Between the agreement and the delivery, the original duty is suspended, unless A commits a breach of the accord that discharges B's new duty to accept the hay in satisfaction.9 Suspended means held in abeyance. B cannot sue for the $7,000 while A's time to deliver is still running, yet the duty has not been extinguished and remains available if the accord fails.10 B's right to enforce the original duty waits until A's time to perform has passed or A commits a breach of the kind the rule describes. The next subsection takes up that breach.
Suspension protects both parties. A gets time to perform without being sued, because the original duty is held back until the obligor has had time to perform. B keeps the original claim, which stays on the books until the satisfaction occurs.11
The label executory accord stresses that the accord itself does not discharge the duty. It also echoes an older view, now generally rejected, under which an unperformed accord was no defense to an action on the underlying duty.12 Under that view B could have sued for the $7,000 while the hay was still on its way. The suspension rule closes that door.
On the day after the agreement, before any hay has moved, B's rights depend on what the parties manifested about discharge. On the facts as given, B must wait, because the agreement is an accord and the $7,000 duty is only suspended. Had A and B clearly manifested that the hay promise was to replace the $7,000 duty at once, they would have made a substituted contract: the money duty would have been discharged when they made it, and B's only recourse for undelivered hay would be a suit on the hay promise.13 The hay and the delivery date are the same in both versions. Only the moment of discharge differs: the agreement itself in the substituted contract, the delivery in the accord.
Breach of the Accord
If A never delivers the hay, B holds two claims and may choose between them. B can sue on the accord for breach of A's promise to deliver the hay, or sue for the $7,000 originally owing, because that duty was never discharged.15 The Restatement attaches one condition: the obligee may enforce either the original duty or any duty under the accord only if the obligor's breach discharges the obligee's duty to accept the performance in satisfaction.16 The condition does real work. B promised to accept the hay in satisfaction and stays bound by that promise until A's breach releases it. A lapse that leaves B's duty to accept in place leaves the $7,000 duty suspended. Once A's breach discharges that duty, nothing holds back the original claim, and B still has the accord claim as an alternative.
The same two paths open when an accord compromises a disputed claim. Parties who compromise a disputed claim are frequently found to have made only an accord, so a creditor who agreed to take a settlement sum and never receives it may sue on the accord for the compromise sum or bring an action for the full amount the creditor claims is due.17
The election follows from what B bargained for. B gave up the original right in exchange for the actual performance, and satisfaction is the event that discharges the original duty. Until it occurs, the duty stays on the books.18 A's breach prevents satisfaction, so B returns to a right B never surrendered. The accord claim stays available too, because the accord is itself a contract and failing to perform it is a breach for which suit lies.
The same reasoning supports a presumption about settlements for less. A seller is owed $450 for a piano, and on July 1 the seller and buyer agree that the seller will accept $425 by August 1 in settlement. August 1 passes and nothing arrives. Whether the seller may now pursue the full $450 depends on what the parties intended on July 1, and the law presumes they made an executory accord and not a substituted contract, because a rational creditor would not accept a mere promise to pay only part of a debt in substitution for a promise to pay the full amount.19 The seller may therefore sue on the accord for the $425 or sue for the full $450.20
The presumption yields to contrary intent. If the parties clearly meant the new promise to replace the old duty at once, they made a substituted contract, and after a default the obligee is confined to a suit on the new promise.21 The classification therefore decides the remedy. The substituted contract leaves the obligee only the new contract, while the accord leaves the obligee a choice.
The remedies change when the obligee is the party who breaches. Breach of the accord by the obligee does not discharge the original duty, but the obligor may maintain a suit for specific performance of the accord, in addition to any claim for damages for partial breach.22
The original duty survives B's breach because discharge comes only with satisfaction, and B's refusal kept the satisfaction from occurring.23 A is therefore still bound by the old duty while holding a contract under which delivering the hay was supposed to end it. The Restatement gives A a suit to enforce the accord, with damages for partial breach on top, so A is not left holding only the old debt.24
The two rules mirror each other, because each remedy follows the party who was counting on the accord being carried out. When the obligor breaches, the obligee returns to the original right and keeps the accord claim as an alternative. When the obligee breaches, the original duty stays in place and the obligor gets a suit to enforce the accord. On an exam, identify the breaching party first. Then apply the election to an obligor's discharging breach, and specific performance with partial-breach damages to an obligee's breach.