Concept
Breach by the Obligee
Accord and satisfaction
Breach by the Obligee
Breach of an accord by the obligee does not discharge the original duty, but it gives the obligor a remedy: a suit for specific performance of the accord, in addition to any claim for damages for partial breach.1 Specific performance is a court order commanding a party to do what the contract promised, where money would only compensate for the failure. The usual setting is a refused tender. The obligor, who owes the original duty, offers the substitute the accord specified. The obligee, who promised to accept it in satisfaction, turns it away and then sues on the original duty. The previous section ran the other way, with the obligor as the party in breach, and the two results are worth reading side by side.
Two consequences follow, and each has its own reason. The first is that the original duty survives. An accord is a contract in which the obligee promises to accept a stated performance in satisfaction of the obligor's existing duty, and it is performance of the accord that discharges the original duty.2 A refused tender is not performance, since the substitute was never accepted in satisfaction. It is tempting to think that an obligor who did everything the accord asked must be discharged, but the rule points the other way, because the obligee's refusal is what kept the accord from being performed.
Surviving, however, is not the same as being enforceable. Until the accord is performed, the original duty is suspended, and the rule names only one breach that ends the suspension: a breach by the obligor serious enough to discharge the obligee's duty to accept the substitute.3 Alice's refusal is not that breach. She is therefore suing on a duty that the accord has suspended, and nothing in the suspension rule lets her end the suspension by breaking her own promise.
The second consequence is the remedy. What Mel bargained for was Alice's promise to accept the car and let the debt go. Damages could only estimate the value of that promise after the fact, while an order of specific performance delivers the promised acceptance itself. The Restatement keeps a damages claim for partial breach open alongside that order, so Mel need not choose between the two.4
Reversing the breaching party shows what is distinctive here. If Mel is the one who breaks the accord, say by announcing he will never deliver the car, and the breach is serious enough to discharge Alice's duty to accept it, then Alice may enforce either the original $1,000 duty or a duty under the accord.5 When Alice breaks, she receives no such election. The obligor's discharging breach releases the obligee from the accord, but the obligee's own breach does not release the obligee from anything. If it did, an obligee could escape the accord just by refusing to honor it, and the promise to accept the substitute would bind no one.
The pattern is not limited to a debt settled for a used car. Suppose a plaintiff sues a defendant for $800,000 over an auto accident, and the parties agree in writing to settle for $300,000 payable in three annual installments of $100,000, plus $75,000 to the plaintiff's lawyer.6 In that agreement the plaintiff promises to accept a stated performance in place of the larger claim. If the plaintiff refused a conforming payment and pressed on with the $800,000 claim, the plaintiff would be the party in breach, and the remedies described above would be the defendant's to pursue.
On an exam, a refused tender should lead to the same short answer each time: the obligee is the breaching party, the original duty survives but is suspended, and the obligor may hold the obligee to the accord.