Concept
Approval and Return Sales
Risk of loss
Approval and Return Sales
Two arrangements put conforming goods in a buyer's hands together with a right to send them back, and they allocate risk of loss in opposite directions. A buyer who holds goods on approval is deciding whether to keep them, and the risk stays with the seller until the buyer accepts. A buyer who holds goods for resale under a sale or return controls them like an owner, and the ordinary allocation rules apply. Both arrangements start from the contract, because the seller's obligation is to transfer and deliver and the buyer's is to accept and pay, each in accordance with the contract.1 A return right changes what the buyer's duty amounts to while the right lasts. That raises a question the earlier rules never faced: who bears a loss that strikes goods the buyer holds but may still return?
On the surface the two arrangements look alike. In each, the goods sit with the buyer, so a fire at the buyer's premises reads the same on an exam stem. The purpose of the delivery is what separates them, so classify the arrangement before running any risk rule. A stem that says only that the buyer may return the goods has not yet told you which rule applies.
Sale on Approval
A sale on approval delivers goods to the buyer on a trial basis, and under § 2-327(1) risk of loss passes to the buyer upon acceptance of the goods, unless the parties agree to the contrary.2 Until acceptance the risk stays with the seller even though the buyer has the goods. That result departs from the residual rule covered earlier, under which a merchant seller's risk would end once the buyer received the goods, and the approval provision displaces that rule.
The allocation rests on the buyer's lack of commitment. A buyer who agreed only to try the goods has not agreed to insure them, and charging that buyer with a fire or a theft would turn a free trial into a purchase with a hidden liability. The seller who offered the trial is better placed to price and insure that exposure. The rule is stated in terms of acceptance, not title. Article 2 resolves risk of loss under § 2-509 without asking where title sits, and § 2-327(1)(a) is one of the few provisions that refers to title at all.3
Every loss case under this rule therefore turns on whether the buyer had accepted when the loss occurred, and two rules decide that. Use of the goods consistent with the purpose of trial is not acceptance, so a buyer who runs the machine, sits on the sofa, or wears the coat to see whether it suits has not accepted by doing so.4 Failure to notify the seller seasonably of an election to return the goods, however, is acceptance.5 Seasonably means within the time the parties agreed on or, if they set none, within a reasonable time.6 The silence rule exists because only the buyer knows whether it intends to keep the goods. Without it, a buyer could hold and use the goods indefinitely while the seller stood by as their insurer, and placing the duty to speak on the buyer ends the seller's exposure when a reasonable buyer would have decided. Acceptance also reaches everything delivered together: if the goods conform, accepting any piece of a suite accepts the entire suite.7
Suppose Design Firm delivers a suite of furniture to newscaster Savannah Anchor's living room on approval, and a tornado later destroys the home and the whole suite. Anchor's use of the furniture was not acceptance, so the question is whether she failed to notify Design Firm seasonably that she was electing to return it. If she failed, she accepted the suite and bears the loss, and if she did not, the risk was still Design Firm's.8 A long silence can support a finding of acceptance. In Valley Bank & Trust Co. v. Gerber, a couple received home furnishings on approval and, more than two months after delivery, still had not told the seller they disapproved of them. The Utah court found a reasonable basis for concluding that the couple had accepted.9 Two months is ample time to decide whether furniture suits a home, so continued silence reads as a decision to keep it.
A stem in which the buyer takes goods home, uses them, and loses them to a fire invites the lazy answer that the buyer had possession and so bears the loss. Ask instead whether the deal was an approval sale and, if so, whether the buyer had accepted by the time of the loss. That depends on the length of the trial period and on whether the buyer gave notice of an election to return. Possession does not answer it, and neither does use that fits the purpose of testing. The parties may also have agreed to put the risk on the buyer during the trial, and a clear term to that effect controls.
Sale or Return
A sale or return also lets the buyer send conforming goods back, but the buyer took them primarily to resell. Under § 2-326(1), conforming goods delivered on terms that let the buyer return them make a sale or return when delivered primarily for resale and a sale on approval when delivered primarily for use. Suppose a distributor delivers 1,000 magazines to a newsstand on terms that the newsstand pays only for those not returned within 40 days. The newsstand took the magazines to sell, and the return right lets it ship back copies that go stale on the rack. Its payment duty is measured by what it keeps, and the resale purpose puts the deal on the sale-or-return side of the line.
That purpose explains why the Code treats this buyer differently from the trial buyer. A newsstand deals in magazines and is therefore a merchant.11 Such a business keeps its stock on its own premises, controls how the goods are displayed and secured, and can be expected to insure its inventory. The approval buyer has made no commitment to the goods, while the resale buyer has committed to dealing in them, so its return right is an option for shedding unsold stock and gives no reason to leave the seller exposed. The control-and-insurance logic behind the earlier allocation rules points at the buyer.
For risk purposes a sale or return is treated like an ordinary sale. The carrier and merchant-seller rules from the earlier sections fix when the risk passed, unless the parties agreed otherwise, and once the magazines are on the newsstand's shelves the risk is the newsstand's. A fire on day 12 that destroys the stock is therefore the newsstand's loss, and it still owes the price for the burned copies, because the option to return reaches only goods in substantially their original condition.
The same allocation governs the return trip. The buyer must exercise the option seasonably, and under § 2-327(2) the return is at the buyer's risk and expense. Suppose the newsstand packs 300 unsold copies on day 38 and hands them to an independent carrier, and the truck is destroyed in a collision on the way back. The loss falls on the newsstand, which still owes the price for copies that never reached the distributor. The buyer controls every choice about the return: whether to return, when, how to pack, which carrier to use, and whether to insure. The seller learns nothing until the cartons arrive. Leaving the transit risk on the seller would let the buyer ship goods back in any condition and by any route and push the loss onto the seller. The carrier-handoff rule that moves risk to a buyer when a seller ships does not run in reverse, because here the buyer is the shipper.
Set side by side, the two arrangements show that the return right is not what allocates the risk. A fire loss on goods held for a trial stays with the seller until acceptance, and a fire loss on goods held for resale lands on the buyer.
Both deliveries carried a right to return conforming goods, so the return right cannot be what sorted them. The purpose of the delivery did.