Concept
Goods Held by a Bailee
Risk of loss
Goods Held by a Bailee
Some goods never travel between contract and delivery, because a warehouse already holds them. For those goods, § 2-509(2) fixes the moment the risk of loss reaches the buyer.1 A bailee is someone who holds goods that belong to another, and the professional bailee in the typical case is a warehouse.2 Like the rest of § 2-509, this rule governs only when the parties' contract is silent, because the parties may allocate the risk as they see fit.3
Which moment controls depends on the paper, if any, that the seller gives the buyer. When a bailee holds goods to be delivered without being moved, the risk of loss passes to the buyer:
- on the buyer's receipt of a negotiable document of title covering the goods;
- on the bailee's acknowledgment of the buyer's right to possession of the goods; or
- on the buyer's receipt of a nonnegotiable document of title or other written direction to deliver, but only after the buyer has had a reasonable time to present it under § 2-503(4)(b).4
Each trigger is a tangible event: a paper changes hands, a warehouse speaks, or a reasonable time runs out. That fits the Code's design, which asks courts to look at the parties' words and actions rather than at the passing of title, an abstraction that no one can prove.5 Until one of the events occurs, the risk stays on the seller.
The two document triggers differ in a way that matters. A seller who passes a negotiable document of title to the buyer shifts the risk on the buyer's receipt, and that case is simple.6 A nonnegotiable document or written direction is harder, because subsection (2)(c) incorporates § 2-503(4)(b). A reader who stops at subsection (2) misses the point. One who follows the cross-reference finds that the risk of loss of the goods, and of any failure by the bailee to honor the document or obey the direction, remains on the seller until the buyer has had a reasonable time to present it.7 Put simply, the seller keeps the risk for as long as it reasonably takes the buyer to secure the bailee's acknowledgment of the transfer.8
The acknowledgment trigger raises a question that the text leaves open: acknowledgment to whom? In Jason's Foods, Inc. v. Peter Eckrich & Sons, Inc. a seller agreed to deliver pork ribs by transferring them from its account at an independent warehouse to the buyer's account at the same warehouse. The seller instructed the warehouse to make the transfer, and a clerk noted it on the warehouse's books, but no one acknowledged it to the buyer before a fire destroyed the ribs. The buyer received the warehouse's receipt only afterward.9 The Seventh Circuit held that the bailee's acknowledgment must be made to the buyer. It found it very strange to read the provision as calling for acknowledgment to the seller, and it left the loss on the seller.10 The clerk's entry recorded the seller's request, not the warehouse's recognition of the buyer. The court also made clear that the acknowledgment need not be formal or written, so a telephone call to the buyer can suffice.11
A second question is who counts as a bailee. A seller that keeps sold goods at the buyer's disposal can always claim to be holding them for the buyer, and if that claim sufficed, subsection (2) would move the risk the moment the contract was made. The pre-Code colt case, Courtin v. Sharp, shows how the argument arises: a seller kept a colt for the buyer, the colt was killed without the seller's fault, and the seller could say it was a bailee that had acknowledged the buyer's right to possession.12 Commentators reject the argument. Even when a seller retains goods already sold and the contract calls the seller a 'bailee,' the seller is not a bailee for purposes of subsection (2). Its situation falls under subsection (1) or (3), and only a formed, explicit bailment would justify treating the seller as a bailee.13 Letting sellers claim the label would undermine one of the basic policies of the Code's risk of loss scheme.14 Courts have taken the same approach. In Silver v. Wycombe, Meyer & Co., a seller that kept furniture at its plant at the buyer's request could not invoke subsection (2). In Conway v. Larsen Jewelers, Inc., a necklace on layaway was stolen from the jeweler's store, and the court applied § 2-509(3) because the parties did not have a true bailor-bailee relationship.15