Concept
Agreement Controls Allocation
Risk of loss
Agreement Controls Allocation
Section 2-509 is a set of default rules, and subsection (4) says so: its provisions “are subject to contrary agreement of the parties.”1 A risk-of-loss problem therefore begins with the contract. The carrier, bailee, and residual rules apply only if the contract has not allocated the risk itself.2
The defaults can yield because they are a sensible guess about typical deals. Article 2 gave up the old inquiry into when title passed, an intangible that no one can prove, and looks instead to the parties’ words and actions.3 The risk rules then put the loss on the party most likely to have insured against it and to take precautions against it, which is usually the party who controls the goods.4 The parties to a particular deal may know better than the drafters who holds the insurance and who holds the goods. Their attempts at private legislation should be recognized and carried out by the courts.5
The parties can allocate risk in two ways. They can write a clause that states the allocation in so many words, or they can choose a trade symbol to which the Code gives a risk-of-loss meaning.6 F.O.B. means “free on board” and F.A.S. means “free alongside,” both defined in § 2-319, while C.I.F. and C.F. are defined in § 2-320.7 Incoterms may govern instead.8 Choosing a symbol is therefore itself an agreement about risk, and the carrier cases below show how the symbols work.
Variations should be stated clearly, and most of all when they would shift the risk to the buyer before it takes possession.9 The defaults assume that the party holding the goods is the party best placed to protect and insure them. A clause that moves the loss to a buyer who does not yet hold the goods departs from that assumption, so it should leave no doubt about what the parties meant. Auction practice supplies an example: a registration form that places “full responsibility” on the buyer from the moment of sale has been held a contrary agreement.10
A clause requiring the buyer to carry insurance on the goods is a different kind of clause. It speaks to coverage, not to who bears the loss, and it does not supply the clear statement that a shift of risk calls for.11 Standing alone, it leaves the Code’s defaults in place. On an exam, read what the clause is about. Language that assigns responsibility for the goods from a stated moment allocates the risk. Language that requires insurance allocates nothing.
Agreement is not the only thing that can move the allocation. Equitable estoppel has been used to impose the risk of loss on a party who otherwise would not have borne it.12 Section 2-509 is likewise subject to the provisions on sale on approval, taken up later in this chapter.13