Concept
Tender, Receipt, and Delivery
Risk of loss
Tender, Receipt, and Delivery
The Code builds every sale around two obligations: the seller must transfer and deliver the goods, and the buyer must accept and pay for them, each in accordance with the contract.1 Unless the contract provides credit or some other means of payment, those obligations are concurrent conditions. The buyer's duty to pay depends on the seller's tender of the goods, and the seller's duty to tender depends on the buyer's tender of payment.2 Both rules are defaults, since each begins "unless otherwise agreed," and the parties may make payment and delivery sequential.3
Concurrency matches what most parties would choose. If the duties were independent, each side would have to perform even after the other breached, and the performing side would then have to sue, paying litigation costs with no guarantee of full recovery. Conditioning each duty on the other's performance means a party need not perform once the other side breaches.4 The risk-of-loss rules rest on two events inside this exchange, the seller's tender and the buyer's receipt. They are different events, and the difference decides cases.
Tender is the seller's act. Where the parties have not agreed otherwise, delivery takes place at the seller's place of business at a reasonable time, and the seller tenders by putting and holding the goods at the buyer's disposition and giving the buyer any notification necessary to enable it to take delivery. Once the seller has done that, the buyer must accept and pay or be in breach.5 Because tender has several parts, a claim that the seller tendered is tested one part at a time.
Each requirement closes a gap that would leave the buyer unable to act. A buyer cannot collect goods it has no reason to think are ready, so notice is part of the seller's performance. A buyer cannot collect goods that are not being held for it, which is why the Code speaks of putting and holding them. The Code does not demand ceremony, either. A comment to the Code identifies two senses of tender. In the strict sense, tender is an offer coupled with present ability to fulfill every condition resting on the tendering party, and it must be followed by actual performance if the other party is ready to proceed. Something less will still put the other party in default if it fails to proceed in some manner.6
Receipt belongs to the buyer. It consists of taking physical possession of the goods, so the seller's tender comes first and the buyer's receipt follows.7 Receipt is not acceptance, either. After the buyer has the goods and inspects them, it must decide whether to accept or reject. Silence amounts to acceptance, and rejection takes affirmative action, because sellers can nearly always assume that goods have been satisfactory if they have heard nothing to the contrary.8
An interval can separate tender from receipt, and risk problems arise in that interval. The seller has done what it can, but the buyer does not yet hold the goods. One commentator would read the Code's tender provision to shift the risk to the buyer at the point when the seller has done everything in its power to make conforming goods available and the buyer has had a reasonable time to take possession.9
The form tender takes depends on how the goods are to travel. If the contract authorizes shipment and does not require the seller to deliver at a particular place, tender occurs when the seller arranges for shipment and puts the goods into the carrier's possession. The buyer may not receive them until days later.10 The carrier shortcut applies only when the contract does not require delivery at a particular place. Otherwise the seller tenders in the ordinary way, by putting and holding conforming goods at the buyer's disposition with the notification the buyer needs.11 The later sections on carrier cases and on goods held by a bailee take up these settings in detail.
The risk rules choose among these moments, which is why treating tender and receipt as interchangeable produces wrong answers. In a case outside the carrier and bailee provisions of § 2-509(1) and (2), risk passes to the buyer on receipt if the seller is a merchant and otherwise on tender of delivery. A merchant is one who deals in goods of the kind, or who by occupation holds himself out as having knowledge or skill peculiar to the goods or practices involved.12 A loss that falls between tender and receipt is therefore decided by who the seller is.
The only fact that changed between the two scenes is the seller's status. It matters because the merchant rule waits for receipt while the nonmerchant rule stops at tender. Later sections take each rule in turn.