Concept
Identification of Goods
Risk of loss
Identification of Goods
A rule that puts a fire loss on the buyer or on the seller needs particular goods to act on. Two questions therefore come before any allocation: whether the thing destroyed is “goods” within Article 2, and whether those goods existed and had been identified to the contract when the loss occurred. Section 2-105 answers both. Subsection (1) defines goods, and subsection (2) requires that goods be existing and identified before any interest in them can pass.1
Article 2 asks these questions because it no longer asks when title passed. Each of its provisions applies irrespective of title unless the provision itself refers to title, and risk of loss under § 2-509 is among the issues that title once resolved.2 The drafters did not want a practical question, such as who bears a loss, to turn on the location of an intangible something that no one can prove, so they substituted proof of words and actions of a tangible character.3 Identification fits that approach, because it depends on what the contract says and what the seller does with the goods.
Consider a seller whose warehouse holds hundreds of anvils and who has promised a buyer 100 of them. The warehouse burns before the seller sets any particular anvils aside for this buyer. The contract has not yet reached the burned anvils, and the seller cannot use § 2-613 to escape its promise, because that section protects only goods identified when the contract is made, and it has no application to garden-variety goods.4 The definition of goods comes first, and identification follows it.
Goods Under Article 2
Section 2-105(1) defines goods as all things, including specially manufactured goods, that are movable at the time of identification to the contract for sale. Three kinds of things are excluded: the money in which the price is paid, investment securities, and things in action. Three are expressly included: the unborn young of animals, growing crops, and other identified things attached to realty as § 2-107 describes.5 The risk-of-loss rules are provisions of Article 2, so a loss to something outside this definition never reaches them, and other law decides it.
Movability is the core of the definition, and it suits a body of rules built around physical handling. Even when seller and buyer sit next door to each other, performance ordinarily requires moving the goods from one to the other, and every trip exposes them to loss: the carrier may lose them, its employees may damage them, thieves may steal them, and fire, storm, or shipwreck may destroy them.6 A milling machine, a pallet of anvils, and a truckload of lumber can all be loaded and carried. The parenthetical for specially manufactured goods confirms that a thing built to one buyer’s order is still goods. Movability is tested at the time of identification, which the next subsection explains.
Some things are not movable in the ordinary sense when the contract is made, and the definition names them so that their status is settled. The unborn young of animals and growing crops are physically part of something else at that moment, and the cross-reference to § 2-107 decides which attached things qualify. A farmer who contracts to sell the crop growing on a certain piece of land is therefore selling goods. If bad weather destroys the crop and the contract keeps the risk on the farmer until the crop is duly delivered to a carrier, her performance is excused. If the risk had already passed to the buyer before the casualty, § 2-613 would not apply, and the buyer would bear the loss under § 2-509.7
The three exclusions follow the same logic. The money in which the price is paid is what the buyer gives in exchange for goods, so it cannot also be the goods sold. Investment securities fall to Article 8, which the definition cites for them. Things in action are intangible rights, such as an unpaid account, that a holder enforces by suing rather than by taking possession. A fire can destroy the paper on which an account is recorded, yet the right to collect survives, so a rule about the loss of physical things has nothing to act on.
A stem that calls a transaction a sale has not yet settled that Article 2 applies, so the first step is to identify what is being transferred. A contract to sell land falls outside the definition because land is not movable. When a building is destroyed between contract and closing, courts take three views, and the majority puts the loss on the purchaser through equitable conversion.8
Existing and Identified Goods
Section 2-105(2) sets two conditions that goods must meet before any interest in them can pass. They must exist, meaning be physically in being, and they must be identified, meaning designated as the particular goods that fill the contract. A machine not yet built and a crop not yet planted fail the first condition. A unit in a warehouse among thousands of identical units, with nothing tying it to this buyer, fails the second. Goods that lack either quality are “future” goods, and a purported present sale of future goods, or of any interest in them, operates only as a contract to sell.10
Both conditions rest on one idea: an interest has to attach to a particular thing, and a nonexistent object or an undesignated item in a pool of similar goods gives it nothing to attach to. A seller who writes “I hereby sell you 500 widgets” before any widget is built or set aside cannot transfer what does not yet exist. The Code reads those words as a promise to transfer later.
Identification can occur in two ways. A contract can identify goods when it is made, as when it calls for a particular existing item or for the wheat growing on a particular field. Otherwise the seller identifies goods by acts such as pulling them from stock, tagging them with the buyer’s name, and setting them aside. Either way, the fact rests on words and actions that can be proved, which fits the Code’s choice to let consequences flow from the contract and the action taken under it rather than from an abstraction like title.11
Identification does not always require the seller to single out each unit. An undivided share in an identified bulk of fungible goods is sufficiently identified to be sold even though the quantity of the bulk is not determined. Any agreed proportion of the bulk, or any quantity agreed by number, weight, or other measure, may be sold to the extent of the seller’s interest in the bulk, and the buyer then becomes an owner in common.12 Fungible goods, such as grain or oil, are interchangeable unit for unit, so tagging particular kernels would add nothing. What the contract must supply is the bulk. A buyer who purchases 1,000 bushels out of the wheat in a named bin holds an identified share, while a buyer promised 1,000 bushels from no designated stock holds a promise of future goods. The share cannot exceed the seller’s own interest in the bulk. Section 2-105(3) adds that there may be a sale of a part interest in existing identified goods, such as a half interest in one particular racehorse.13
Identification also decides who may invoke the casualty excuse in § 2-613. That section applies when goods are damaged without fault of either party before risk of loss passes to the buyer and the contract requires for its performance goods identified when the contract is made. If the loss is total, the seller is freed from its obligation. If the loss is partial, the buyer may treat the contract as void or accept the goods with due allowance for the deterioration. The excuse reaches only goods whose continued existence the agreement presupposes, and it has no application to the typical sale of garden-variety goods.14
The reason for requiring more than the “kind and amount” of the goods is to prevent a seller from using § 2-613 to excuse its performance in contracts for ordinary goods that it could replace on the open market.15 In Clark v. Wallace County Cooperative Equity Exchange, a seller promised 4,000 bushels of corn, a fall freeze damaged the crop, and the seller delivered only part. The Kansas court refused to excuse the shortfall, because the contract did not require corn from any particular land or grower, so the corn was not identified when the contract was made. Interchangeable goods fare no better. In Valley Forge, a seller lost a shipment of Ramin dowels to a storm at sea and received no excuse, because dowels are fungible and the seller admitted it could replace them on the open market. A seller of combat boots destroyed in a train derailment lost on the same reasoning in Bende and Sons, Inc. v. Crown Recreation, Inc., since any combat boots would have satisfied the purchase orders.16 The farmer who sold the wheat growing on a particular field stands on the other side of the line: her contract tied the goods to that field, so her performance is excused if the risk has not passed to the buyer.
Two moments of identification must stay apart on an exam. A seller who tags goods the week after contracting identifies them from that point, but the tagging does not satisfy § 2-613, which asks whether the goods were identified when the contract was made.17 A contract for generic goods therefore falls outside that excuse no matter what the seller later designates.