Concept
From Title to Control
Risk of loss
From Title to Control
Article 2 untied risk of loss from ownership. Under the preamble to § 2-401, each provision of the Article on the rights, obligations, and remedies of sellers, buyers, and third parties applies irrespective of title unless the provision specifically refers to title, and risk of loss under § 2-509 is one of the questions that locating title used to resolve.1 A court asked who absorbs a fire loss therefore does not start by asking who owned the burned goods. It asks what the parties agreed, whether either is in breach, and where the transaction stood when the loss occurred, and it then places the entire loss on one party.2
Before the Code, the search for title decided the case. Under the Uniform Sales Act, for example, title to goods unascertained at contracting presumptively passed when the goods were ascertained and delivered to a carrier for the buyer, or at the destination if the seller had to pay the cost of transportation.3 Title passes, if at all, at a moment that no person can prove by evidence. The Code's drafters objected to letting a practical question between practical people, such as who bears the risk of loss, turn on the location of that intangible, and they substituted proof of words and actions of a tangible character.4 The substitution has paid off. The risk provisions of §§ 2-509 and 2-510 have so far generated only a small fraction of the litigation that the Uniform Sales Act produced in a comparable period, and the decisions are generally sound readings of the drafters' intent.5
In title's place, the Code asks who controls the goods and who is likely to carry insurance on them. The buyer, the drafters reasoned, “has no control of the goods and it is extremely unlikely that he will carry insurance on goods not yet in his possession.” A seller who still holds the goods stands in the opposite position. The Code aims to put actual losses on insurers rather than on a party who may or may not have insurance when the loss occurs, and the anti-subrogation provisions of § 2-510 further that aim.6
The aim shows most clearly when the seller keeps the goods. In a case outside subsections (1) and (2) of § 2-509, the residual rule passes the risk to the buyer on receipt of the goods if the seller is a merchant, and receipt means taking physical possession. A merchant seller that retains the goods may therefore bear the loss long after title has passed and the price has been paid.7
The mirror case leaves the seller with title and the buyer with the goods. In a footnote in Sumner v. Fel-Air, Inc., the Alaska Supreme Court collected authority for two propositions: a seller who retains title after delivery is treated as though he retained only a security interest in the goods, and risk of loss passes to the buyer on delivery even where the seller adopts a conditional sale agreement, as in Centurian Corp. v. Cripps (Utah 1981).8 A reserved title after delivery secures the price. It does not return the goods to the seller's hands, and the buyer who holds them bears their risk.
The two versions mirror each other. The merchant who kept the boat kept the risk, even if title had passed and the price was paid. The seller who delivered the boat gave up the risk, though he kept title. Control explains both results, and title explains neither.
Title has not vanished from Article 2. Some provisions refer to it specifically, among them the warranty of title (§ 2-312), the sale-on-approval provision (§ 2-327(1)(a)), a purchaser's title (§ 2-403(1)), the seller's insurable interest (§ 2-501(2)), and suits against third parties (§ 2-722).9 The risk provisions do not turn on title. The sections that follow apply the Code's inputs one transaction type at a time.