Concept
What Risk of Loss Means
Risk of loss
Risk of Loss in Sales
What Risk of Loss Means
Goods have to travel. Even when seller and buyer are next-door neighbors, performing a sale of goods generally requires the goods to move from one to the other, and the trip exposes them to harm: the carrier may lose them, its employees may injure them, thieves may steal them, and fire, storm, or shipwreck may destroy them.1 Under UCC § 2-301, the seller must transfer and deliver, and the buyer must accept and pay, each in accordance with the contract.2 Those duties say nothing about what happens when the trip fails. Risk of loss fills that gap. When goods are destroyed after the contract is made and before the buyer has them, and neither party is at fault, it decides which party absorbs the loss.
The allocation decides who pays. A buyer who had the risk of loss when the goods were destroyed is liable for the price under § 2-709, even though the goods are gone. A seller who had the risk is liable in damages for nondelivery unless it tenders a performance in replacement for the destroyed goods.3 The wreckage is the same either way, and the only question is whose risk it was.
Bearing the risk is not a breach. Suppose Acme agrees to sell 100 anvils to RRI, and the anvils are destroyed while Acme has the risk of loss. The destruction does not put Acme in breach. But because Acme has the risk, it must still deliver 100 anvils to RRI, and if it refuses on the ground that the goods were destroyed, Acme then breaches.4 The result follows from the seller's duty to deliver: a loss that falls on the seller leaves that duty in place. Had the anvils been destroyed after the risk passed to RRI, the loss would have fallen the other way, and RRI would owe the price for goods it never received.5
The Code does not split the loss. It places the entire loss on one party, chosen by three inputs: the parties' agreement, whether either party is in breach, and the moment in the transaction when the loss occurred.6
Agreement comes first. Section 2-509(4) makes the provisions of that section subject to contrary agreement of the parties. A contract may therefore allocate the risk by a clause that says so in so many words, or by a symbol such as C.I.F. or F.O.B., which carries special risk-of-loss meaning under the Code. In an international deal, Incoterms may govern instead.7 This is why a careful lawyer reads the contract before reading the statute, and why the Code's own rules operate only when the contract is silent.
The second step does the sorting, because its answer decides which section governs at all. The Acme loss above, with no breach by anyone, is a § 2-509 problem. A breach before the loss changes that.
Acme does. The tender was itself a breach, so § 2-510 supplies the allocation, and where goods fail to conform to the contract, the risk of loss remains with the seller until acceptance or cure.10 Neither had happened when the fire struck. A breach before the loss pulls the problem out of § 2-509 entirely, and a later section takes up the breach rules in full.
When no one has breached and the contract is silent, § 2-509 supplies the defaults, and their shape is easy to state. If the seller is a merchant, the risk generally passes to the buyer on receipt of the goods. If the seller is not a merchant, it generally passes on tender of delivery. Where the contract authorizes the seller to ship by carrier without requiring delivery at a particular destination, the risk passes when the goods are delivered to the carrier. Where the seller must deliver to a particular destination, it passes when the goods are tendered there so as to enable the buyer to take delivery.11 The sections that follow define identification, tender, receipt, and the merchant, and then take the carrier, bailee, and residual cases in turn.
Risk of loss must also be kept apart from excuse. A seller who bears the risk of destroyed goods remains bound to deliver, as Acme was, unless some further ground excuses its performance. The anvils are replaceable, so Acme's duty survives their destruction. Suppose instead that the contract calls for one particular used car, a vehicle for which there is no replacement, and that it is destroyed through no fault of either party while the seller has the risk of loss. Because the contract called for one particular vehicle, the seller's performance is excused.12 The risk allocation says who answers for an ordinary loss, and excuse asks whether the contract can still be performed at all.