Concept
Effects of Acceptance
Acceptance and notice of breach
Effects of Acceptance
A buyer who accepts goods changes its legal position in three ways. It owes the contract price for the goods. It can no longer reject them, and it can revoke only on a heavier showing. And it keeps its claim for damages for the seller's breach, provided it gives the seller timely notice. (Acceptance here means acceptance of goods tendered under a contract already formed, not acceptance of an offer; the two ideas share a vocabulary but belong to different stages of the deal.1) The first two changes hold the buyer to the bargain, and the third protects the buyer while it is held.
Duty to Pay
A sale obliges the buyer to accept and pay for the goods in accordance with the contract.2 Section 2-607(1) fixes the amount that acceptance triggers: the buyer must pay at the contract rate for any goods accepted.3 The rule binds a buyer who accepts by conduct as firmly as one who accepts by saying so. A decision applying Oklahoma's Code found acceptance where the buyer received goods, processed them, and sold the finished product to a third person without making any effort to reject them, because those acts were inconsistent with the seller's ownership. It then restated that a buyer must pay at the contract rate for goods it has accepted.4
Because the measure is the contract rate, a defect in the goods does not reduce the debt on its own. The defect gives the buyer a separate claim for its loss, and the buyer must prove that loss.
The seller's breach does not change that arithmetic. The Code does not contemplate that a seller's general breach would fully preclude the seller's action on the price. The buyer must instead prove its setoff damages, if any, under the pertinent sections, by proving rejection, revocation of acceptance, or breach of warranty.6 The proof is the buyer's job, because the burden is on the buyer to establish any breach with respect to the goods accepted.7 A buyer that proves nothing therefore pays the full price, however plain the seller's breach.
The Code's exit from the duty to pay is revocation of acceptance, which a buyer may use when a nonconformity substantially impairs the value of the goods to the buyer.8 The next subsection explains why that route is narrower than rejection.
Proof of damages is also not enough by itself, because the buyer must have notified the seller of the breach within a reasonable time after it discovered or should have discovered the breach, or be barred from any remedy.9 Courts defend that condition by pointing to the seller's position: without it, a seller could face stale claims and lose the chance to marshal evidence for a defense. They also refuse to let a claimant who sues on the Code's theory of liability satisfy the requirements it likes and neglect the others.10 The notice rules have their own section below. Their link to payment is this: after acceptance the buyer is a debtor for the price and a claimant for its loss, and only the claimant who gave notice may subtract anything.11
When a problem gives you a buyer that kept the goods and now complains, take the questions in order. Did the buyer accept? If so, it owes the contract rate. Did it notify the seller of the breach within a reasonable time? If not, it has no remedy. Can it prove damages? Only proven damages come off the price. Does it have a basis for revoking acceptance? The buyer can fail at any one of these steps.
Loss of Rejection, Damages Kept
Section 2-607(2) packs three consequences into a single sentence. Acceptance precludes rejection of the goods accepted. An acceptance made with knowledge of a nonconformity cannot be revoked because of it, unless the buyer accepted on the reasonable assumption that the nonconformity would be seasonably cured. And acceptance does not of itself impair any other remedy the Article provides for nonconformity.13 The first two clauses take away the buyer's power to undo the sale; the third leaves its claim for money intact.
Rejection ends at acceptance, even when the goods do not conform. A buyer may accept nonconforming goods, and acceptance then precludes the buyer from rejecting them.14 In a dispute over a horse, the buyer argued that telephone calls made after shipment amounted to an effective rejection. The court answered that under § 2-607 acceptance precludes rejection; because the buyer could make no effective rejection, the burden of proving breach of warranty rested on him.15
The reasonable opportunity to inspect marks how far silence can count against a buyer: it ensures that silence alone does not impute acceptance until the buyer has had adequate time to inspect. It gives no help to a buyer that has drastically changed and used the goods. Such goods cannot later be rejected and treated as unaccepted, even though a latent defect was present.16
The second clause addresses the buyer that knew of the defect when it accepted. Acceptance occurs when the buyer, after a reasonable opportunity to inspect, signifies that the goods are conforming or that it will take or retain them in spite of their nonconformity; a buyer who accepts that way with knowledge of the nonconformity cannot later revoke, unless it accepted on the reasonable assumption that the seller would cure the defect.17
Revocation remains the narrower remedy even where the cure exception applies. A buyer may reject goods if the tender fails in any respect to conform to the contract, but to revoke it must show, among other things, that the nonconformity substantially impairs the goods' value to the buyer. Courts explain the difference by the policy that it makes good sense to require more from a buyer who has accepted the goods than from one who has rejected them.18
The third clause protects the buyer's claim for money. A buyer that takes an entire shipment may still sue for the seller's nonconforming delivery, because a buyer accepting a nonconforming tender is not penalized by the loss of any remedy otherwise open to it.19 The same holds for a buyer whose goods carried a defect that was not easily detected. Such a buyer does not lose its right to recover damages for the seller's breach of warranty by simply having accepted the goods.20
That claim is for money, and it depends on notice. Prince v. LeVan describes the buyer who neither rejects nor revokes acceptance but keeps the goods and seeks damages for the nonconformity. That buyer has no remedy at all unless it notifies the seller of breach within a reasonable time, and when proper notification follows acceptance, the remedy is damages, not cancellation.21 In Michiana Mack, Inc. v. Allendale Rural Fire Protection, the buyer never tried to rescind the contract or return the truck and sued only for damages. The trial court concluded that the buyer had accepted the truck because there had been no effective rejection. It found the buyer's remedy under § 2-714 and ordered the seller to repair the truck or refund the purchase price and to pay damages, including the buyer's interest and insurance expenses.22 The statute states the notice condition directly: the buyer must notify the seller within a reasonable time after it discovers or should have discovered the breach, or be barred from any remedy.23
The notice that preserves the claim need not be elaborate. The cases ask whether the seller was alerted that the transaction was troublesome and needed to be watched. In one dispute over alleged express warranties, the buyer's evidence that it brought maintenance, parts, shortage, and defective-supply problems to the seller's representatives, who visited its offices to resolve them and repeatedly promised to do so, let a jury infer that notice was both sufficient and timely.24 In a class action over the Suzuki Samurai, the court held that allegations of executive awareness of the safety problem, investigations by seven state attorneys general, announced remedial steps, and other rollover litigation established that Suzuki knew the transactions were 'troublesome and must be watched.'25 The next section takes up what notice must contain and when it must arrive.