Concept
Cure and Perfect Tender
Seller's right to cure
Seller's Right to Cure
Cure and Perfect Tender
Article 2 puts the seller under an obligation to transfer and deliver the goods in accordance with the contract.1 The buyer's right of rejection under § 2-601 enforces that obligation strictly, because it applies whenever the goods or the tender fail to conform to the contract.2 Under the perfect tender rule, the buyer may reject if the seller's performance fails to conform to the contractual specifications "in any respect."3 The extent of the nonconformity is not a condition of rejection, and the "substantial performance" rule that governs service and construction contracts does not apply.4 The buyer also need not show that the breach harmed it.5
The buyer in Albrecht v. Fettig contracted for 150 head of cattle, 80 percent Red Angus and 20 percent Black Angus. The seller delivered about 55 percent red steers, about 43 percent black steers, and the remainder neither, and the buyer rejected the lot. The court held that the buyer could reject the entire delivery. It refused the seller's argument that perfect tender had eroded into a test of substantial nonconformity, and it added that a delivery with such different proportions of black and red steers would not have substantially conformed in any event.6
The rule has a cost. Because the right to reject does not depend on harm, it gives buyers an inviting pretext: a buyer that finds it no longer needs the goods, or that the market price has fallen, can seize on a defect to escape the contract.7 The seller is exposed to that risk of strategic rejection, and the Code reduces it by giving sellers a second bite at the performance apple.8 A related limit binds the buyer directly: the right to reject for less than perfect tender must be exercised in good faith and not merely to escape an unwise bargain.9
Cure is that second bite. In the UCC sense, it is the seller's right under § 2-508 to correct a nonconforming delivery, usually within the contract period.10 In T.W. Oil, Inc. v. Consolidated Edison Co., the New York Court of Appeals explained that the right to cure was intended as a meaningful limitation on the absolutism of the old perfect tender rule, which allowed no leeway for imperfections and left no room for substantial performance of commercial obligations.11 Section 2-508 had no antecedent in the Uniform Sales Act and restricts the buyer's right to reject. Novel as the doctrine was, it adds a legal sanction to a practice many sellers had long followed, which was to make good on a defective delivery.12
The result gives each side something. The buyer is protected from having defective merchandise dumped in its lap with no recourse but a damages claim, and the seller gets a kind of second chance to meet its contract obligations.13 The New Jersey Supreme Court drew the practical consequences in Ramirez v. Autosport. The perfect tender rule survives to the extent that a buyer may reject goods for any defects, and the possibility of cure means that rejection does not terminate the contract. Curable defects therefore still justify rejection.14
Cure answers a rejection, and rejection has requirements of its own. It must occur within a reasonable time after delivery or tender, and it is ineffective unless the buyer seasonably notifies the seller (§ 2-602(1)).15 The seller's chance to cure begins once a nonconforming tender has been rejected.16
A buyer that inspects and does nothing has accepted, because failure to act constitutes acceptance and only affirmative action rejects.17 If the acceptance cannot be revoked, the buyer is confined by § 2-714 to damages measured by the loss in value caused by the nonconformity.18 Revocation is available only if the nonconformity substantially impairs the goods' value to the buyer, so substantial impairment, not perfect tender, is the standard once the buyer has accepted.19
Cure is the seller's option. Under the Code, the decision to attempt a cure is within the seller's discretion, and the buyer cannot compel it. Article 46(2) of the CISG, by contrast, gives the buyer a right to require the seller to cure.20 A seller that cures performs its original obligation a second time, because its duty was always to deliver in accordance with the contract.21
The contract date divides the right to cure into two settings. If the buyer rejects before the time for performance has expired, § 2-508(1) lets the seller seasonably notify the buyer of its intention to cure and then make a conforming delivery within the contract time.22 If the time has expired, § 2-508(2) gives the seller a further reasonable time to substitute a conforming tender, but only if the seller had reasonable grounds to believe the nonconforming tender would be acceptable, with or without a money allowance, and seasonably notifies the buyer.23 The stricter second setting follows from the perfect tender rule itself. The buyer may reject a late delivery even when time of delivery is not a material term, so § 2-508 imposes more stringent limits on cure after the contractual delivery date.24