Concept
What the Buyer Recovers
Rightful rejection
What the Buyer Recovers
A buyer who rightfully rejects goods, or justifiably revokes its acceptance, may cancel the contract, take back the price it has paid, and collect damages for the loss the breach caused, and it may do all three together. Section 2-711(1) collects these remedies, and revocation of acceptance gives the buyer the same rights as rejection.1 Each remedy has its own measure, taught with the rest of the buyer's remedies. This section traces where a rightful and effective rejection leads.
A hypothetical shows the whole recovery at work. A buyer contracts to buy 100 pumps for $20,000 and pays $8,000 in advance. The pumps arrive out of specification. The buyer inspects them, tells the seller promptly that it rejects them, spends $500 inspecting them and keeping them safe until the seller collects them, and buys 100 conforming pumps elsewhere for $23,000. It recovers three things: the $8,000 deposit, the $3,000 by which cover exceeded the contract price, and the $500 in expenses. After that recovery the buyer has paid a net $20,000 and holds 100 conforming pumps, which is the position the contract promised. It owes the seller nothing on the $12,000 balance.
Every one of these remedies belongs to a buyer who has not accepted. A buyer has not accepted when it rightfully rejects, and acceptance is not final when the buyer justifiably revokes.2 The rejection must also be effective: it must come within a reasonable time after delivery or tender, and the buyer must seasonably notify the seller.3 A buyer who was right about the defect but late or silent has failed to reject under § 2-602(1). It has accepted, and its rights with respect to the nonconforming goods no longer include rejection.4 Acceptance does not end its remedies, however. The buyer may still revoke if the nonconformity substantially impairs the value of the goods to it, and revocation restores the rights of a rejecting buyer.5 A buyer that rejects goods that conform has not rejected rightfully, and § 2-711 does not reach it; the seller's remedies for the buyer's breach apply instead. Even a buyer that passes both tests can lose its remedies to a seller's proper retender under § 2-508, which precludes the § 2-711 remedies except compensation for any delay.6
Recovery of the price matters most to a buyer that paid before it could inspect. Whether or not the buyer cancels, it may recover as much of the price as it has paid, and the remedy does the most work in three situations: the buyer prepays and the goods never arrive, the buyer pays before inspection and then rightfully rejects, or the buyer pays and later justifiably revokes acceptance.7 Cancellation discharges the obligations still executory on both sides, but the buyer keeps its remedy for breach of the whole contract or any unperformed balance.8 Gragg Farms and Nursery v. Kelly Green Landscaping shows the remedy and its gate together. The buyer had paid freight on a mixed shipment of willow oaks and pines. After it effectively rejected the oaks, the court let it recover the share of the freight attributable to them, allocated by tree size because freight tracked size more than market value. The same buyer owed the price of the pines, because it never told the seller it was rejecting them.9
Damages for the loss of the goods themselves come in two alternative measures. A buyer that buys substitutes in good faith and without unreasonable delay recovers under § 2-712 the amount by which the cost of cover exceeds the contract price. A buyer that never replaces the goods recovers under § 2-713 the amount by which market price exceeds the contract price. Both measures compensate one loss, so the buyer collects under one and not both, and each is reduced by expenses the breach saved the buyer.
Incidental damages reimburse what the rejection itself costs the buyer. Section 2-715(1) covers "expenses reasonably incurred in inspection, receipt, transportation and care and custody of goods rightfully rejected," commercially reasonable charges in connection with effecting cover, and any other reasonable expense incident to the delay or other breach.10 The category tracks the buyer's duties after rejection. A buyer that took physical possession before rejecting, and that holds no security interest in the goods, must hold them with reasonable care at the seller's disposition for a time sufficient to let the seller remove them.11 Without reimbursement, the buyer would finance the seller's failed performance. In Atlan Industries, Inc. v. O.E.M., Inc. the buyer justifiably revoked acceptance of defective resin and recovered, besides the price paid and cover damages, the cost of the labor it spent inspecting the material and preparing it for return.12
A right to an expense does not excuse the buyer from proving its amount. In Gragg Farms the buyer's watering of the rejected oaks satisfied its duty to hold them with reasonable care, and the court allowed the labor of unloading, heeling in, and disposing of the trees. It denied the cost of the watering itself, because one sprinkler served hundreds of trees and the evidence did not show how much of that labor and water went to the thirty-five willow oaks.13
Consequential damages reach further, and they demand the same discipline. They cover any loss resulting from the buyer's general or particular requirements and needs of which the seller had reason to know at the time of contracting, and which cover or other means could not reasonably prevent.14 The loss must be foreseeable under Hadley v. Baxendale. A seller answers for it if it arises from circumstances the seller knew or had reason to know, even if the seller did not consciously assume the risk. The loss must also be certain.15 In Deaton, Inc. v. Aeroglide Corporation the buyer rightfully rejected Mini Dumps, but its lost-profits award rested only on the gap between the seller's suggested retail price and the buyer's cost. The business was new, and the buyer offered no proof of potential customers or of its cost of doing business, so the award was too speculative to stand. The court recognized that a new business may recover lost profits proved with reasonable certainty and that mathematical certainty is unnecessary. The failure was one of proof, not of category.16
These remedies cumulate; the buyer need not choose among them. Before the Code, a buyer who rescinded and refused the goods could recover the price it had paid and no more, while a buyer who sought damages had to affirm the agreement and keep the goods.17 That election penalized a buyer for walking away from a deal the seller had breached, since the buyer lost its bargain as well as its money. The Code rejects the policy: the buyer may cancel and also recover damages.18 The only coordination the remedies require is the one noted above, that cover and market price measure the same loss.
Money is not the only recovery. A buyer in possession of rejected goods may hold a security interest in them under § 2-711(3), a power taught earlier in this chapter along with the buyer's right to resell as an aggrieved seller would.19 A buyer that has paid some or all of the price of identified goods may also, under certain circumstances, recover those goods from the seller under § 2-502. That right vests when the goods are identified to the contract, and a buyer that has not paid in full must be ready to tender the balance.20
Once it has met the Code's duties after rejection, a buyer whose rejection was rightful and effective has no further obligations with regard to the goods, and it may turn to these remedies.21